Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Supreme Court Will Re-Examine Prayer at Government Meetings
Supreme Court Will Re-Examine Prayer at Government Meetings
May 16, 2025 11:10 PM

Even before America became a republic, Americans have opened public meetings with prayer. The Supreme Court even acknowledged this fact thirty years ago in the case of Marsh v. Chambers. Writing for the majority, Chief Justice Burger said, “From colonial times through the founding of the Republic and ever since, the practice of legislative prayer has coexisted with the principles of disestablishment and religious freedom.”

But the “ever since” may soon ing to an end.

After two residents Greece, New York sued the town over a public meeting prayer, a district court judge said the town council did not intentionally exclude members of any faith. But the three-judge panel for the Second Circuit Court of Appeals unanimously disagreed, saying “the town’s habit of inviting clergy from only churches in Greece could be construed as government endorsement of a particular religion. Houses of worship in Greece are almost exclusively Christian.”

In December, Alliance Defending Freedom asked the Supreme Court to review the appeals court decision and on Monday the Supreme Court agreed to take up the case. As ADF notes, state attorneys general from 18 states in nearly every federal judicial circuit have united to ask the court to provide clear direction about the legality of allowing citizens to voluntarily deliver prayers consistent with the dictates of their own conscience. Additionally, forty-nine members of Congress and legislative leaders from two states filed their own briefs pointing out that the reasoning of the 2nd circuit jeopardizes the way deliberative bodies at every level of government have chosen to open their meetings for more than 225 years.

Hopefully, the court will uphold its own thirty-year precedent by recognizing that the prayer precedent—which was in place before the signing of the U.S. Constitution—does not violate the intention of the Founding Fathers.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Christians Flee Middle East; Will It Be For Good?
With persecution of Christians there at an all time high, many have chosen to leave the Middle East. Christianity Today, reporting on the latest Pew Research report, says the number of Christians in the Middle East has dropped from 14 percent of the population to just 4 percent. That translates to less than half a million people in the Middle East who identify as Christians. The problem turned from bad to worse with the rise of the Islamic State as...
U.S. State Department Releases Trafficking in Persons 2015 Report
Since 2001, the U.S. Department of State has released a Trafficking in Persons (TIP) Report. This report examines trafficking country-by-country, ranks each country and gives suggestions to each country’s government to improve the fight against modern slavery. The 2015 report begins with, among others items, a list of all situations that are now considered forms of human trafficking. Sex traffickingChild sex traffickingForced laborBonded labor or debt bondageDomestic servitudeForced child laborUnlawful recruitment and use of child soldiers Part of this report...
The Planetary-Argentine Pope and the Climate-Change Fanboy
Bill McKibben The minute it was announced – months in advance of its official release –Laudato Si was instantly “highly anticipated” by nearly every opinion and news source. Finally a Christian document the masses could support because … why, exactly? Oh, yeah, global warming and a call for global government control of energy and, therefore, the world’s economies. So, es as no surprise climate-change activist would weigh-in on Laudato Si, a document released in mid-June and one he identifies, naturally,...
Should We Have Property Rights Over Our Attention?
On an average day, a person is subjected to more than 5,000 advertisements and exposures to brands. Out of that number about 362 are “ads only.” That means that during your waking hours you are exposed to an average of 23 ads per hour, or about one advertisement every two and a half minutes. A lot of people along the advertising chain—from creation to display of ads—are getting paid. If everyone else is getting paid to distribute the ads, why...
USCCB’s Misunderstanding of Economics
Today, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB) called for supporting just wage public policies. While the religious leaders genuinely concern for the poor, they display a deep lack of understanding of basic economic principles, namely the law of supply and demand. Supply and demand directly determines the price (wages) of labor. A price higher than the market price leads not to higher wages, but higher unemployment. Read this article for a more detailed discussion of the ill-effects of...
5 Reasons the Federal Government Fails
In 2002, fewer than one in four Americans were dissatisfied with the nation’s system of government and how well it works. Since then that level of discontent has been steadily increasing. Last year the number who said they were somewhat or very dissatisfied reached 65 percent. The primary reason for our disgruntlement is the government’s record of failure. As Peter Schuck explained in his recent book Why Government Fails So Often, ‘government failure’ is neither a political creed nor a...
Owen Chadwick, 1916-2015
Earlier this month, the eminent historian Owen Chadwick passed away. Chadwick’s immense scholarly plishments includedActon and History, his study of our namesake here at the Acton Institute. John Morrill wrote a wonderful reflection for The Guardian on Chadwick’s life, character, and plishments at the time. From the article: His last two books were A History of the Popes 1830-1914 (1998) and The Early Reformation on the Continent (2002). Throughout his career, he also published brilliant short essays, normally developed from...
If Camille Paglia Is Upset With Planned Parenthood, Things Are Grim
No one can call Camille Paglia an easy person to pidgeon-hole. She’s a feminist, but refers to herself as a dissident one. She’s a professor, an author, a critic. In the late 1990s, she began writing a regular column for Salon (she continues to contribute, but not regularly.) She once said she would not be unhappy if her entire career were to be judged by this sentence she wrote: “God is man’s greatest idea.” Suffice it to say that she...
Peak Travel Season: Could You Spot A Human Trafficking Victim?
Human trafficking victims get moved frequently. It’s one way their traffickers can keep control over them – the victims often have no idea where they are. They can be transported by bus, train, 18-wheelers, and planes. Could you spot a victim? More importantly, would you know what to do? CNN’s Freedom Project has the on-going mission to end modern day slavery. They’ve given a list travelers can look for. 1. The person traveling is poorly dressed. (Now, I realize, given...
Wheaton College Refuses to Bow to Caesar’s Demands
Over the past couple of years the Obama administration has made it clear that when religious freedom conflicts with their political agenda, religious believers are the ones that will have to set aside their conscientious objections. And to be honest, I suspected that would be what happened more often than not. Sure, you’d have some brave holdouts, like the owners of Hobby Lobby and the dedicated nuns of the Little Sisters of the Poor. But for the most part, I...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved