Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Stay At Home Mom? Yeah, You Don’t Count
Stay At Home Mom? Yeah, You Don’t Count
May 8, 2025 7:24 AM

I loved being a stay at home mom. Sure, it was tedious some days and there were times when I was a bit weary of mac and cheese, but overall, I loved it. I enjoyed watching my kids grow, learning with them, enjoying leisurely days of bug watching, sidewalk chalk and cartoons.

Imagine my surprise when I found out that being a stay at home mom doesn’t count as work. Not real work: you know, the kind of work where you get dressed up, talk to grown-ups all day, have meetings and enjoy the view from the cubicle. The Washington Post wanted to investigate which states treated women best when es to pay equality and they gave us this handy map:

Here is how the Post came up with this data:

The four factors analyzed to develop posite scores were: median annual earnings (for full-time, year-round women workers); the earnings ratio between men and women(again, for full-time, year-round women workers); the share of women intheworkforce and the share of women in managerial or professional jobs.

Looking at the map, Indiana is a failure (or at least on the brink.) They don’t have enough women working at full-time professional jobs, and if they do, they aren’t paying them enough. Shame on you, Indiana. Shame.

Except, what if women in Indiana (or any other state) are choosing something different? Here is Mollie Hemingway:

This is a great example of why you always need to look at what’s actually being measured. If you think “equal rights” means “equal es,” this is a great map. If your understanding of “equal rights” is about “liberty” or the freedom to make your own decisions, it’s a train wreck. Equal rights doesn’t mean we all work the same job at the same number of hours for the same pay and that none of us get to choose to care about homemaking. That’s not what equality means.

Women choose different jobs because we want different jobs. Many of us enjoy working and having careers. That doesn’t mean that many of us want to be on oil rigs away from most of civilization for months at a time, or garbage collectors, or even just jobs with long hours and no flexibility. And these different choices don’t make us bad people at all.

The map wants to measure “equality” in the paid, full-time workforce. Okay. But if someone is choosing not to be in that segment of the population, why is it bad? Why are some states being given a “failing” grade? If Mom is choosing to stay home, why does that count “against” that state? “Equal” here means “bringing home a full-time paycheck.”

So the message from these feminists is clear: If you work inside the home, you’re a failure.

Enough. Enough. Enough of this poisonous ideology.

If you’re going to measure something, measure it. But be upfront about what you’re measuring, and (if you really want to be good at your statistician’s job), keep ideology out of it. No one fails for making a legitimate choice to work at home, to work part-time or to work full-time. Don’t create failure where there is none.

Read This Map Shows What’s Wrong With Feminist Approaches To Labor Choices at The Federalist.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
IRS Caught on Tape: Keep Faith to Yourself
Alliance Defending Freedom has released a transcript and audio of a phone conversation an IRS agent placed to a non-profit organization that provides support to women in abusive pregnancy situations. In the recorded phone conversation, the agent lectures the president of the organization about forcing its religion and beliefs on others and inaccurately explains that the group must remain neutral on issues such as abortion. Agent Sherry Wan (:06-:41) – “…so you have your right. You have your freedom. You...
Art and the Common Good
Reformed theologian Abraham Kuyper, in his work Wisdom & Wonder, explores humanity’s relationship to creativity: Whereas idol worship leads away from the spiritual, obscures the spiritual, and drives it into the background, symbolic worship by contrast possesses the capacity, by repeatedly connecting the visible symbol with the spiritual, to direct a people still dependent on the sensuous toward the spiritual and to nurture that people unto the spiritual. Art should lead us to look beyond the created object, the artist...
George Wallace, Post-Traumatic Stress, and Black Voting
On June 11, 1963 Alabama Governor George Wallace became a national symbol for racial segregation by blocking the doors of a school to physically prevent the integration of Alabama schools. According to the Alabama Department of Archives, Governor Wallace “stood in the door-way to block the attempt of two black students, Vivian Malone and James Hood, to register at the University of Alabama. President John F. Kennedy federalized the Alabama National Guard, and ordered its units to the university campus....
Give In To Evil Or Give Up: What Should The Catholic Bishops Do?
National Catholic Reporter writer Michael Sean Winters has a message for the United States Catholic Bishops: plicit with evil or toll the death knell for the Church in the U.S. Unlike the Amish, who choose to live in a manner outside of modern culture, Winters exhorts the bishops to not only engage the world, but realize that being part of evil is simply part and parcel of that engagement: I bring up the Amish for a reason. They are lovely...
Econ 101 for Father Finn
In a May 28, Huffington Post article, Rev. Seamus P. Finn, OMI, exhibits a woeful lack of economic knowledge. In most cases members of the clergy can be forgiven somewhat for getting it so utterly pletely wrong. After all, few people go into the ministry because they’re fascinated with things like lean manufacturing techniques or monetary policy. But in this instance Finn must be taken to the proverbial woodshed for a lesson in what truly benefits the world’s poor. Why...
Religion & Liberty: The Moral Crisis of Crony Capitalism
Today’s new rich is the “government rich” according to Peter Schweizer. Massive centralization of money, resources, and regulation has allowed our public servants and many big businesses to thrive. The poor, new business start ups, the taxpayer, and the free market are punished. Washington and corporate elites profit from the rules and regulations they create for their own benefit and their cronies. As daily news reports currently reminds us, Washington is a cesspool of corruption and abuse of power. It’s...
Digitization of Newman Archive Announced
The University of Manchester has announced plans to digitize the holdings of the Cardinal Newman archive. Among the roughly 200,000 items of handwritten and other unpublished materials are 171 files of letters to (and from) “particular individual correspondents.” One such correspondent of particular interest is Lord Acton. A selection of Acton’s correspondence with Newman is available digitally courtesy of the Online Library of Liberty. Lord Acton’s periodical, The Rambler, is also the subject of seven separate files of Newman’s correspondence...
‘Morning-after’ Medication Now Available To All Ages
12 year old girls are a lot of things, but keenly aware of their own bodies, biological functions and the side effects of medications are typically not among their strong suits. Imagine a 12 year old girl who isn’t even sure how she might get pregnant, let alone if she is. Imagine a 12 year old who’s been coerced into having sex or has even been raped. Imagine she may or may not be pregnant, but has contracted an STD...
Can whistleblowing be Biblically justified?
Last week, 29-year-old Edward Snowden, a tech specialist who was contracted for the NSA and works for the consulting firm Booz Allen Hamilton, leaked the details of a classified surveillance program to the media. As Christians debate the ethics of Snowden’s actions we should consider the question, “Under what circumstances can there be biblically justified ‘leaking’ or whistleblowing?” What does being a “good neighbor” or a “Good Samaritan” (à la Luke 10) mean, obligation-wise, when es to warning others against...
Schmemann on Socialism
Man’s nature is to reject it, because it can only be thrust on people by force. The most fallen possession is closer to God’s design for man than malicious egalitarianism. Possession is what God gave me (which I usually (mis)use selfishly and sinfully), whereas equality is what government and society give me, and they give me something that does not belong to them. (The desire for) Equality is from the Devil because es entirely from envy. – Fr. Alexander Schmemann,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved