Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
‘Sex Workers’ As Social Workers: A Hash Of Hollywood Idiocy
‘Sex Workers’ As Social Workers: A Hash Of Hollywood Idiocy
Oct 17, 2026 7:43 AM

“Fading Gigolo,” a movie starring and directed by John Turturro, is apparently a sentimental look at the world of prostitution. NPR says the film keeps ” the mood light even as the filmmaker is gently tugging the plot in other directions, to look at loneliness and longing and heartbreak.” Turturro himself says that sex workers are rather like social workers (which should thrill social workers):

I think there are positive things about what sex workers do. I know and consulted people who have been in that world, and it’s interesting on a human level that people sometimes go to these people for reasons beyond just sexual contact – maybe they’re looking for solace, or other things, and sometimes they are truly helped. I also think there’s a real exchange that goes on in these situations, whereas in so many other professions there isn’t.

He says a lot of other idiotic things that I won’t subject you to here; feel free to read the entire article if you must.

The movie stars Turturro as the “accidental” gigolo, Sofia Vergara and Sharon Stone as two of the gigolo’s “customers,” and Woody Allen as the would-be pimp. It’s all supposed to be very funny and sentimental and gooey and empowering.

Turturro does acknowledge that there are some “dark” things surrounding prostitution, but that’s not what he wanted to explore here. After all, who wants to spend $15 bucks on a movie ticket to see what really happens to men and women caught up in the world of prostitution? It’s so much more fun to make it light.

Here is what it’s really like to be a prostitute, in the words of someone who escaped that life:

As far back as I can remember my life was filled with fear, pain, and trauma. Later on, sexual exploitation joined my list of terror.

I was a terrified fifteen year old child standing on the corner of Logan and Division in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Pimped out and sold to the highest bidder. I was called a prostitute, a whore, and so many other hateful names that a child should never be called. No one seemed to see me as a fifteen year old. No one looked at me to see that I was being used, abused, sold. It was like the whole world just saw me as trash.

My pimp told me that if I ever left, I would be killed. That my family would be killed. Terrified, I did exactly as I was told. My mother never understanding why I was doing the things that I was doing. She didn’t know that my running away from home was my attempt at keeping them safe.

I was trafficked from city to city, state to state. If I did not bring in a certain amount of money, I was beaten. The brutality of the beatings included wire hangers, power cords, among other things.

After twenty years of this lifestyle, I became accustomed to living in fear and pain, darkness of the unknown. In order to stop feeling and thinking, I turned to drugs and alcohol.

What about a fun-filled film about child abuse? Maybe Turturro could tackle edy about child porn, or a light-hearted romp about spousal abuse, or a man who beats his elderly mother.

Prostitution and human trafficking aren’t funny. Prostitutes are not social workers. The sex trade is not about human connection. Objectifying and using human beings – created in God’s image and likeness – isn’t funny, or therapeutic, or “magical,” as Turturro says. It’s wrong. Just wrong. And trying to entertain people by saying otherwise is a betrayal to every person like the woman above who is brutalized, terrified and abused. John Turturro: be ashamed.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Ranking Small Business & Entrepreneurship
Forbes passes along a ranking of the fifty states (plus the District) on the friendliness of fiscal policy toward small business (HT: The Entrepreneurial Mind), provided by the Small Business & Entrepreneurship Council (PDF). Michigan ranked 10th in the list, which examines 29 governmentally-influenced factors such as personal e tax, capital gains tax, corporate e tax, property tax, death tax, electricity costs, and number of bureaucrats. Michigan was in the top half of most categories (it did rank 47th in...
Recovering the Soul of Conservatism
I saw the most fascinating and lively exchange between two political conservatives on C-Span Book TV last weekend. It featured Andrew Sullivan, the homosexual activist who is actually a libertarian politically, and David Brooks, the Jewish columnist for The New York Times. Brooks has an unusually keen insight into evangelicalism, as can be seen in his frequently thoughtful references to it. He is also a wonderfully nuanced political conservative of the very best sort. The televised event was sponsored by...
Appreciating Academic Genius
First Francis Beckwith and now this: Indiana Jones has been denied tenure (HT: Urban Onramps). This is outrageous. I note especially mittee’s disregard for Jones’ work in discovering the Ark of the Covenant and the Holy Grail. Sounds like mittee was made up of a bunch of secularists who don’t believe in that kind of thing. What does this say about Marshall College? Let’s hope Indy’s case ends up as well as Dr. Beckwith’s. ...
The New Evangelical Role in the Public Square, Part 2
In my previous article, Part One, I showed how a conservative political and social movement has evolved over the past fifty years in America and how the evangelical church began to get involved in this movement. This movement led to what has monly called the “Christian Right.” This abused, and misused word, is now used to disparage almost everything conservatives attempt to do in the larger culture. The result of this political debate over the past thirty years has been...
Timeline Toward The Brave New World
Following the recent Medico-Legal Society of Ireland’s Golden Jubilee Conference in Dublin, the Irish Medical Times provides a timeline of the history of genetics, beginning in 1859 with the publication of Charles Darwin’s The Origin of the Species. Other more recent highlights include the year 2003, in which “scientists at the University of Shanghai successfully fused human cells with rabbit eggs, reportedly the first human-animal chimeras (a mixture of two or more species in one body) created.” Earlier this year,...
The Idolatry of Political Christianity
On this eve of the mid-term elections in the United States, it’s worthwhile to reflect a bit on the impetus in North American evangelical Christianity to emphasize the importance of politics. Indeed, it is apparent that the term “evangelical” is ing to have primarily political significance, rather than theological or ecclesiastical, such that Time magazine could include two Roman Catholics (Richard John Neuhaus and Rick Santorum) among its list of the 25 most influential “evangelicals” in America. When the accusations...
Prayer of the Reign of Christ
Almighty and everlasting God, whose will it is to restore all things in your well-beloved Son, the King of kings and Lord of lords: Mercifully grant that the peoples of the earth, divided and enslaved by sin, may be freed and brought together under his most gracious rule; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and for ever. Amen. –U.S. Book of Common Prayer, “Of the Reign of Christ,” (1979), p. 254 “My kingdom...
The Catholicity of the Reformation: Musings on Reason, Will, and Natural Law, Part 6
This post sketches out the rough outline of Jerome Zanchi’s understanding of natural law. An interesting difference between Zanchi and Martyr is that Thomistic elements are far more important in Zanchi’s theology than in Martyr’s theology. The historian John Patrick Donnelly thinks Zanchi is the best example of “Calvinist Thomism,” meaning a theologian who was Reformed in theology and Thomistic in philosophy and methodology. Zanchi was born and raised near Bergamo where he entered the Augustinian Canons and received a...
Must I Vote to Be a Faithful Christian?
Though millions of Americans will go to the polls today to vote, midterm elections generally draw only 30 percent of eligible voters to the polls. (Presidential races draw around 50 percent.) These numbers put the U.S. in 139th place among 194 nations in a ranking of voter turnouts. Numerous reasons are offered for this low number. One may be the partisan gerrymandering of congressional districts that mean most House seats are “safe.” Political scientist Michael McDonald says “Just as sports...
New Book: The Solzhenitsyn Reader
Solzhenitsyn One word of truth shall outweigh the world. — Russian proverb ISI Books has released The Solzhenitsyn Reader: New and Essential Writings, 1947-2005 (650 pages; $30). This single pilation includes some of the Russian author’s most significant works, including poems, stories and miniatures (prose poems), essays and speeches in their entirety. There are also excerpts from the novels, memoirs and the extensive political and historical writings. You can order the book online here. In their introduction to the reader,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved