Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Samuel Gregg: ‘Two Popes, But One Faith’
Samuel Gregg: ‘Two Popes, But One Faith’
Mar 28, 2026 1:15 PM

Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI was not able plete his encyclical on faith during his pontificate, and Pope Francis chose plete the work, Lumen Fidei (“The Light of Faith”.) Acton’s Director of Research, Samuel Gregg writes about the connection between these two men, made possible by their faith, at National Review:

[I]f there’s anything demonstrated by Pope Francis’s first encyclical letter Lumen Fidei (“The Light of Faith”), it’s a profound continuity between the two men: i.e., their love for and belief in the one, holy, Catholic and apostolic faith. Right at this encyclical’s beginning, Francis states the text’s first draft was prepared by his predecessor and “as his brother in Christ I have taken up his fine work and added a few contributions of my own” (LF 7).

The point being made here isn’t just that Joseph Ratzinger is probably the greatest theologian to sit on Peter’s Chair and may one day be declared a Doctor of the Church. A more subliminal message is that Catholicism’s content doesn’t change when one pope succeeds another. As many people don’t (and sometimes don’t want to) understand, Catholicism isn’t just another political movement that distorts or abandons its core beliefs under the guidance of consultants to gain votes from fickle voters.

Gregg notes that Pope Francis was under no obligation to take up Benedict’s text, but this is not an atypical occurrence, as many hands typically draft encyclicals. However, the obligations of faithfulness rests on the pope who signs the encyclical, and Francis’ fingerprints are clearly onLumen Fidei:

Herein we find, Francis teaches, Christian faith’s great significance today: its capacity to open up a modernity that, despite its genuine achievements, has profoundly cramped conceptions of reason, equality, freedom, and love and which usually ends up emptying all these things of substantive content. Without faith — and not just any faith, but Christian faith as the “theological virtue” as affirmed, Francis carefully footnotes, by both the First and Second Vatican Councils (LF 7) — self-described moderns are, like the Greek and Roman pagans, stuck in an intellectual prison largely of their own making.

Lumen Fidei makes very clear Francis’s deep awareness that religious faith is often understood by many moderns as “darkness” (LF 3). That’s partly because of mischief-making by particular Enlightenment thinkers that’s been uncritically assimilated by most contemporary liberals. But it’s also because many people today associate faith with murderers who fly planes into buildings.

Certainly there are such things as what Benedict XVI once described as “pathologies of faith.” But Lumen Fidei goes to considerable lengths to unpack Christian faith’s true meaning so as to distinguish it from its counterfeits. Francis juxtaposes Christian faith, for instance, with our penchant for putting our trust in contemporary idols.

In this encyclical on faith, Francis clearly points out, according to Gregg, that faith does not rest on emotion: “Christian faith isn’t therefore a ‘feeling-faith.’ It’s ‘not simply an individual decision’ (LF 39). Instead it is, Francis writes, ‘born of an encounter which takes place in history’ and which we know about “through the memory of others — witnesses — and is kept alive in that one remembering subject which is the Church.”

Gregg also goes on to show how Pope Francis discusses faith against the backdrop of suffering, especially those who suffer for the faith. This encyclical is clearly one that spans not only the pontificate of two men, but the whole of Christianity.

Read “Two Popes, But One Faith” at National Review.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Review: In Praise of the Bourgeois, Liberty-Loving Race of Hobbits
In light of the discussion about distributism in the ments, I’m posting John Zmirak’s excellent Religion & Liberty review of The Hobbit Party: The Vision of Freedom that Tolkien Got and the West Forgot by Jonathan Witt and Jay Richards (Ignatius Press, 2014) here on the PowerBlog. Note how he ends the review with a discussion of Tolkien and whether his work lent support to distributism. Have at it. In Praise of the Bourgeois, Liberty-Loving Race of Hobbits By John...
Firstfruits Economics
“Honor the Lord with your wealth and with the firstfruits of all your produce.” –Proverbs 3:9 In his latest video, Dan Stevers highlights the importance of giving God our first and our best, focusing mostly on the story of Cain and Abel. “The concept of firstfruits extends to every aspect of our lives,” he writes. “God doesn’t accept leftovers; God must be first.” The video contains excerpts from Robert Morris’ popular book, The Blessed Life: Unlocking the Rewards of Generous...
Education Reform: We’re Doing It Wrong
In this American Enterprise Institute Vision Talk, Chancellor of DC Public Schools Kaya Henderson talks about the state of public education reform. She says we have the opportunity to change everything we’ve been doing wrong in education for the past 100 years, but we are failing at the task. How, she asks, do we consistently produce quality education for all children? Can it even be done? It is interesting to note that one focal point of Henderson’s talk munity. Although...
Audio: Samuel Gregg on Relevant Radio
Acton Institute Director of Research Samuel Gregg has a busy calendar of media appearances these days; late last week, he joined host Sheila Liaugminas on Relevant Radio’s A Closer Lookfor a full broadcast hour to discuss the ing year in politics and wider society. That interview is available for your listening enjoyment via the audio player below. He’ll also be appearing this afternoon during the five o’clock hour on Ave Maria Radio’sKresta in the Afternoon; streaming audio will be available...
Yep, the Social Sciences Really Are Biased Against Conservatives
“Psychologists have demonstrated the value of diversity—particularly diversityof viewpoints—for enhancing creativity, discovery, and problem solving,” say a team of social scientists in a new paper. “But one key type of viewpoint diversity is lacking in academic psychology in general and social psychology in particular: political diversity.” Social psychology is an interdisciplinary domain that bridges the gap between psychology and sociology by studying how people’s thoughts, feelings, and behaviors are influenced by the actual, imagined, or implied presence of others. The...
The High Price of Human Trafficking
“Human trafficking is broader in scope than most people realize,” says Elise Hilton in this week’s Acton Commentary. Today, human trafficking impacts entire industries, and job sectors – both legitimate and illegitimate. Monetarily, it is the second largest criminal activity in the world. Only the illegal drug trade is more profitable. The profits generated from human trafficking play an enormous role in national and global economies. There is also the untold human cost. It is, as Pope Francis said, an...
How Much Does Government Regulation Cost America?
What is the annual cost of regulations for America? The short answer is that no one knows for sure. The officially reported regulatory costs as reported by the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) total up to $128.7 billion. But the real costs of regulation is impossible since, as the Nobel-winning economist James Buchanan said, “Cost cannot be measured by someone other than the decision-maker because there is no way that subjective experience can be directly observed.” Still, we can...
Audio: Gregg on Discomfort With Pope Francis
Samuel Gregg, Director of Research at the Acton Institute, joins host Al Kresta on Ave Maria Radio’s Kresta in the Afternoon to discuss the level of fort that some conservative Catholics have felt in recent months with the pontificateof Pope Francis. Is the pope a liberal, as he is sometimes portrayed by the media? Does he hold to longstanding teachings of the Catholic Church? Gregg and Kresta address these and other issues, and take calls from listeners in this half-hour...
The KKK, Selma, and southern Christianity
Two January 2015 film releases provide great opportunities for Christians to examine the not so admirable aspects of American church history in order to learn from the mistakes and successes of the past. First, the newly released movie Selma tells of the story of the passage of the Voting Rights Act of 1965 and the public protests leading up to LBJ signing the bill into law. My parents were born and raised during Jim Crow and the movie does a...
Monks and Markets
Not Abba Pistamon Today at Ethika Politika, I examine some ancient economic wisdom from one of the desert fathers: Abba Pistamon. Far from the newest of Nintendo’s Pokemon monsters (despite the sound of his name), Abba Pistamon was one of the first Christian monks. The dialogue between him and an unnamed brother that I examine from the Sayings of the Desert Fathers has a lot to say about production, labor, profit, and exchange. I write, Far from a gnostic allergy...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved