Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Political idolatry: A Lutheran view
Political idolatry: A Lutheran view
Aug 11, 2026 11:06 PM

Is faith in politics “another Gospel”? A distinguished Lutheran scholar has weighed in on the matter, clearly delineating a Christian’s duty as a citizen from his duty to the Christ and his fellow body of believers.

Gene Veith, the noted professor, provost, and editor, weighs in on the topic after taking notice of Acton’s article on President Trump’s recent “King of Israel” controversy.

In his blogatPatheos, Veith shares insights gleaned from Lutheranism’s traditional “Two Kingdoms” theology.

“The state’s purview is thefirst useof the Law, curbingexternalsin by means of lawful magistrates, rewards, and punishments, though such external and coerced obedience can never make a person internally righteous,” hewrites. es from the church’s proclamation (and belief in) the Gospel.

“It is not necessarily idolatry for Christians to work through the existing governmental systems to do so, even though this may involve promises with the governing authorities,” he adds. “But itisidolatry if we put our faith in them.”

He then quotes Martin Luther’s discussion of the First Commandment from hisLarge Catechism. The heart of the es as Luther describes idolatry.

“[T]o have a God is nothing else than to trust and believe Him from the [whole] heart,” Luther said. “That now, I say, upon which you set your heart and put your trust is properly your god.”

The full, extended quotation – and the rest of Veith’s article – is well worth your time. But this extract makes it clear what Luther would say to Christians who put their faith in the power of any earthly ruler.

Incidentally, his insights pair well with his subsequent blog on how easily how church figures find “God’s will on Brexit.”

Read the whole article here.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
John Wesley, ‘The Rich Man and Lazarus’
Readings in Social Ethics: John Wesley, “The Rich Man and Lazarus.” References below are to page numbers. A warning on the dangers of riches: “‘There was a certain rich man.’ And it is no more sinful to be rich than to be poor. But it is dangerous beyond expression. Therefore, I remind all of you that are of this number, that have the conveniences of life, and something over, that ye walk upon slippery ground. Ye continually tread on snares...
CARE Says ‘No’ to Federal Money
From today’s NYT: “CARE, one of the world’s biggest charities, is walking away from some $45 million a year in federal financing, saying American food aid is not only plagued with inefficiencies, but also may hurt some of the very poor people it aims to help.” “If someone wants to help you, they shouldn’t do it by destroying the very thing that they’re trying to promote,” said George Odo, a CARE official who grew disillusioned with the practice while supervising...
Acton Alum Offers An Insider’s Perspective On Hip Hip
Acton Alum, Andrae McGary, recently launched a blog to offer some perspective on hip hop for the hip munity. It’s called Street Soul Arts. His latest post discusses Princeton University religion professor, Cornell West, and the release of West’s second rap album. I’m glad to see this blog because he knows this world far better than I ever will. ...
Global Warming Consensus Alert: Blast From the Past
Jeff Jacoby, writing yesterday in the Boston Globe, takes a pleasant stroll down memory lane: INTRODUCING Newsweek’s Aug. 13 cover story on global warming “denial,” editor Jon Meacham brings up an embarrassing blast from his magazine’s past: an April 1975 story about global cooling, and ing ice age that scientists then were predicting. Meacham concedes that “those who doubt that greenhouse gases are causing significant climate change have long pointed to the 1975 Newsweek piece as an example of how...
STAND on ‘Wristband Activism’
STAND, the Student Anti Genocide Coalition, is discussing Kaylin Wainwright’s mentary about Darfur and campus activism on its blog. STAND, which says it has founded 700 chapters, answers Kaylin’s criticisms about campus “slacktivism” by pointing to its effective engagement on the Darfur issue. The PowerBlog takes no stand on STAND. We’re just glad that considerations about effectiveness are being discussed by activist groups. Read Kaylin’s “Darfur: Taking Student Advocacy beyond the Wristband.” ...
Asylum vs. Assistance
In connection to Acton’s recent coverage of the New Sanctuary Movement, which shelters illegal immigrants in churches to protect them from deportation, see this fascinating Christianity Today piece that explains the history of the church sanctuary concept. A few excerpts…. “As a product of a time when justice was rough and crude,” law professor Wayne Logan summarized in a 2003 Harvard Civil Rights-Civil Liberties Law Review article, “sanctuary served the vital purpose of staving off immediate blood revenge.” If the...
Environmental Stewardship News Round-Up (cont.)
The following items are the continuation of the Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation Newsletter, August 15, 2007: Those first five major developments are themselves worthy of an entire issue of this newsletter, and the last two are significant as well. But here are some additional stories worth noting since our last issue: 1. Natural explanation for all climate variability in last century? Science Daily, August 1, 2007 [University of Alabama climatologist Roy Spencer informed us of this article,...
The New (Green) Robber Barons
What do you call titans of industry who influence governmental regulation to provide them with tax and subsidy incentives to make a business venture profitable? They used to be called robber barons…now apparently they’re “eco-millionaires.” The NYT piece gives a brief overview of four such figures: Bruce Khouri “did not found Solar Integrated until 2001 once tax and subsidy incentives made the market more attractive.” Pedro Moura Costa says he “saw the carbon market could be big business and the...
Bridging Wesley’s Ditch
Stanley Cohen, the Martin White Professor of Sociology at the London School of Economics, is quoted as saying that “good intentions e bad practices.” In his critique of rather lame attempts to realize justice in the world (related to faulty definitions of justice), Herman Bianchi writes, “Even more dubious is another frame in which the formula is often couched: ‘Justice is the constant intention to give everyone his due.’ Never is it said, ‘See to it that everyone really gets...
Confessing Evangelical Economics
A number ments have been floating around the blogosphere related to the ing out of Colorado last week that a professor at Colorado Christian University was terminated because “his lessons were too radical and undermined the mitment to the free enterprise system.” Andrew Paquin, who taught global studies, reportedly assigned texts by Jim Wallis and Peter Singer. That in itself shouldn’t be enough to get someone fired. The context within which such authors were assigned and how the professor led...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved