Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
People v. money: The flaws of Democratic Socialism
People v. money: The flaws of Democratic Socialism
May 20, 2024 8:22 AM

“This race is about people versus money,” said 28-year-old Democratic Socialist, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who last Tuesday usurped the nomination from high-ranking House Democrat, John Crowley. Her viral campaign video also accused the reigning King of Queens of not breathing the same air or drinking the same water as his constituents. Very few expected Ocasio-Cortez’s grassroots movement to topple Crowley’s Wall Street funded political machine.

“People versus money” is the anthem of anti-establishment candidates. As the Left moves farther left, it is a song voters hear on repeat. Ocasio-Cortez’s nomination reveals just how catchy the tune first popularized by Senator Bernie Sanders is. “Medicare for all, tuition-free public college, and federal jobs guaranteed,” they chant. However, the Democratic Socialist’s paradigm is flawed. In advocating for socialized health care and education, they have neglected to account for monetary costs and the reality of human nature.

As the old economic adage goes, “There is no such thing as a free lunch.” For instance, a report produced by the nonpartisan Urban Institute analyzing “Sanders Single-Payer Health Care Plan” predicted that total federal spending would increase by $32 trillion in a ten-year span. This number represents the federal government’s absorption of state and local governments, employers, and households spending on health care. This tremendous increase in government spending would correspond to a tax, too hefty to be politically palatable.

Similarly, the championing of free public college is a mirage for another high tax which would ultimately diminish the value of education to what the public is willing to collectively invest. If the past is any predictor, the cost of college will continue to rise as more federal dollars are funnelled in. Coupled with increased demand, the cost of higher education would exponentially grow and strain public budgets.

The new Queen of Queens assumes that money left in the hands of private individuals leads to greed and marginalization, so it is safest in the hands of the bureaucrats in Washington. A romanticized administrative state purged of self-interest underlies this assumption. Economic thinkers from Frederic Bastiat to Albert Jay Nock have deemed taxes, especially at the magnitude proposed by Democratic Socialists, to be “legal plunder.” In The Law, Bastiat describes this phenomenon as: “law benefit[ing] one citizen at the expense of another by doing what the citizen himself cannot do mitting a crime.” The expanded state required for Democratic Socialist policies deliberately violates man’s private economic liberty by cultivating a “monopoly of crime.” Maybe the victorious self-proclaimed “working-class candidate” should reconsider the value of the working man’s economic liberty before demanding a greater share of his paycheck.

In her campaign video, Ocasio-Cortez asserts that she “was born in a place where zip code determines your destiny.” Yet, last Tuesday Ocasio-Cortez became one step closer to defying her own maxim. The same characteristics she exhibited in this feat–creativity, ingenuity, and hard work–are the same that individuals demonstrate when they choose work over welfare. In decrying the plunder of taxes, Bastiat praises man’s God-given faculties that when applied to the world’s natural resources promote mon good superior to that promised by government.

“People versus money” does not always have to mean Wall Street. The government has proven to be an unreliable steward of man’s money. Have you checked out the U.S. Debt Clock lately?

Photo Source: 05262018-Corey Torpie-Office Opening

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Film noir and the movie-made American male
As a genre of dark intrigue, stoic protagonists, and femmes fatales, film noir has continued to beguile and entertain filmgoers for decades. But does it also have something to say about the relationship between happiness and justice? Read More… Recently I spoke at Hillsdale College on film noir as part of a program that introduced audiences to four of the most impressive movies in the genre that defined the tough detective in America and the less popular type of doomed...
When Catholic social teaching and neoclassical economics collide
A new book on a “just economy” from a Catholic perspective has more to say about injustices wrought by neoliberalism than it does about crony capitalism and the fraught history of the statist solutions it mends. Read More… Anyone looking for an engaging overview of what modern Catholic social teaching (CST) has to say about economic matters will find it in Anthony Annett’s book Cathonomics: How Catholic Tradition Can Create a More Just Economy. Yet Cathonomics is much more than...
The Incarnation: The basis for a free and virtuous society
The material and the spiritual were never meant to be opposed to each other, which is why we at Acton work to realize spiritual benefits in the context of the hustle and bustle of the material world. Read More… In the Genesis account of creation, we read that God “looked at all he had made and found it very good.” Today’s feast, which celebrates the Annunciation to Mary and the Incarnation of the Son of God, reminds us that no...
The “Dumbest Generation” has finally grown up
Mark Bauerlein’s follow-up to his 2008 book, The Dumbest Generation, delivers a depressing assessment of what hollowing out the academic canon has produced in the lives of students subjected to the dumbed-down curriculum. Read More… In his “Parable of the Madman,” Nietzsche, reflecting on the death of God, observes that “this tremendous event is still on its way,” continuing that “deeds, though done, still require time to be seen and heard.” The Madman notes the irony that even though “this...
When intellectual giants collide: Mateo Liberatore vs. Blessed Antonio Rosmini
The 225th birthday of Blessed Antonio Rosmini is a good time to remember that heated debate on the intersection of faith and reason, philosophy and the Word of God, is to be encouraged. You you never know what light will be shed—or when a saint is in the making. Read More… Christian philosophy and morality were far from my intellectual radar during the 1970s when I decided to focus on economic studies. At the time I was captivated by the...
Volodymyr Zelensky is the Servant of the People
In this 2015 starring the ic Zelensky, we witness what is now an absolutely surreal depiction of a man from nowhere thrust into history with the weight of his people’s fate on his shoulders. Imagine such a thing happening in real life. I know I can’t. Read More… Three Ukrainian oligarchs, a shadow Triumvirate as it were, stand on a balcony overlooking a gorgeous town square. An election for president is imminent and they’re tired of wasting millions on backing...
Russian aggression against Ukraine threatens religious liberty
Ukraine is under siege, and if history is any indicator, should Russia prove victorious, freedom of religion will also be under siege. Read More… Russia’s attack on Ukraine continues. Ukrainian resistance so far has been fierce, but Russian forces retain a huge advantage in firepower. A victory by Moscow would mean installation of a puppet government in Kyiv, with harsh repression to follow. Politically Russia was unfree even before the war. However, fear of popular protest led Russian president Vladimir...
Finding hope for Ukraine’s future
As the world watches in horror at the war in Ukraine, and the specter of a devastated Ukrainian economy and infrastructure lurks in the shadows, there is nevertheless good news still to be found. And it starts with free peoples and free markets. Read More… Thirty years ago, the world was in a transition that felt almost euphoric. The Soviet Union had been disbanded munism in much of the rest of the world was in retreat. Liberal democracies were ascendant,...
The Power of the Dog is everything that is wrong with Hollywood
Determined to destroy the Western, masculinity, and every shred of self-respect, this 12x-Oscar-nominated film from Jane Campion finally catches up to its own conceits, but far too late. Read More… My long series on Oscar movies ing to an end with angry words about Hollywood. To summarize, I liked Wes Anderson, loved Paul Thomas Anderson, was amused by Ridley Scott, disappointed by Steven Spielberg, and disgusted by Guillermo Del Toro. Of course, this is of no importance to the artists...
How do we determine the morality of economic sanctions?
Russia and individual Russians have been hard hit by sanctions imposed by nations around the world, all intended to deter Vladimir Putin from pursuing his illegal war in Ukraine. But what moral principles should guide our decisions about whether to impose sanctions and the form they take? Read More… Are economic sanctions morally permissible? That question has been asked by many people since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and the imposition of a range of economic sanctions on Russian entities and...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved