Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
No, Paul Ehrlich, Humans Aren’t Bags of Garbage
No, Paul Ehrlich, Humans Aren’t Bags of Garbage
Oct 20, 2026 8:16 AM

In a new mini-documentary, the New York Times kindly confirms what we already knowabout Paul Ehrlich. His predictions about overpopulation have beenastoundinglywrong, and his views about humanityare no less perverse.

Author of the famous panic manifesto, Population Bomb, Ehrlich made a name for himself by predicting mass starvation and catastrophe due to over-population. If left to our own devices, Ehrlich argued, we unruly beasts will feast and gorge and reproduce ourselves into an oblivion. Hissolution? Targeted starvation, abortion, and sterilization of the “selfish” and unenlightened. If the Earth is to endure, wemust pay the price for humanity’s ultimate transgression: existence.

The documentary summarizes theseviewsquite well, and includes a series of striking interviews with former disciples who have since rejected his theories. As for Ehrlich, he remains steadfast in his doubts about human value and possibility. “My language would be even more apocalyptic today,” he says.

Watch ithere.

Even in countries like India, where Ehrlich’s predictions were the gloomiest, population growth is curbing and economic and ecological transformation has allowed it to e an exporter of goods.

And yet, whenchallenged on why his predictions never came to pass, Ehrlich gives an answer characteristic of central planners and prognosticators of doom everywhere.Such predictions, he argues, mean something “very, very different” from what they do to we pea-brained plebs. The apocalypse is still nigh, and humans are still to blame.

One can’t help but be shocked by suchblind denial, but evenmore troubling is the fundamentalview that drives it— a distorted view of humanity that’s far more prevalent than Ehrlich’s specific population predictions, whether among the master planners of foreign aid or the foot soldiers of “family planning.”

ForEhrlich and many others, humans simply take, take, take; there’s no make, make, make. And thus, the struggle forprovision, prosperity, and human flourishingisquickly reduced to a mere battle over consumption. We are leeches, drainers, and destroyers, a virus on the Earth that must be curbed and contained, if not wiped pletely (a “cancer,” as Ehrlich sometimes prefers).

Take, for instance, one of his lines in the video above: “The idea that every woman should have as many babies as she wants is, to me, exactly the same kind of idea as everybody ought to be permitted to throw as much of their garbage into their neighbor’s backyard as they want.”

Humans = bagsof backyard garbage. NBD.

Fortunately for us (and for Ehrlich), humans aren’t globsof trashand the munity” isn’t some morbid zero-sum realmwhereineverynew baby represents a dead mushroom on a distant mountaintop.

As Julian Simon famously observed, humansare the “ultimate resource”— valuable assets to our families, neighbors, distant strangers, and, yes, Planet Earth herself.We were created in the image of a creator-God to be co-creators and gift-givers, sharing, exchanging, collaborating, and innovating alongside the grand family of humankind. Each new child represents not somebag of waste, but a a creator and a dreamer — a unique and precious person born for relationship and brimming with capacity for production, investment, and love.

Unlike Ehrlich’s, this is not fancy theology fit for a convenient ideology. History has proven itquite sufficiently, as organizations like PovertyCureand folkslike Simon, Matt Ridley, and Jonathan Lastare quick to illustrate.More than tweaking their numbers and predictions, it’s about time Ehrlich and others change their perspective accordingly,recognizing God’s gift of humanity and working to createa world that relishes it to the fullest.

Population boom, anyone?

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Was St. Francis of Assisi An Eco-Warrior?
With the newest papal encyclical due out soon, and with its purported title to beLaudato si’[Praised Be You] from St. Francis of Assisi’s great prayer, The Canticle of the Sun, Acton’s director of research Samuel Gregg takes a closer look at this saint. St. Francis of Assisi loved God’s created world; of that there is no doubt. However, is he the patron saint of the eco-warrior crowd? Gregg says there are far too many myths that surround this great servant...
No, Paul Ehrlich, Humans Aren’t Bags of Garbage
In a new mini-documentary, the New York Times kindly confirms what we already knowabout Paul Ehrlich. His predictions about overpopulation have beenastoundinglywrong, and his views about humanityare no less perverse. Author of the famous panic manifesto, Population Bomb, Ehrlich made a name for himself by predicting mass starvation and catastrophe due to over-population. If left to our own devices, Ehrlich argued, we unruly beasts will feast and gorge and reproduce ourselves into an oblivion. Hissolution? Targeted starvation, abortion, and sterilization...
Is Capitalism Killing War?
Last year Steven Pinker, a cognitive scientist at Harvard, published the intriguing book The Better Angels of Our Nature: Why Violence Has Declined. While some of his assumptions and conclusions about the overall decline of violence are questionable, he does seem to be correct about the decline of warfare over the past several decades. Consider this chart, produced by Vox, which shows the decline in deaths attributed to war since the 1940s. Human nature doesn’t change. With every generation of...
Now Available: ‘The Mosaic Polity’ by Franciscus Junius
CLP Academic has now releasedThe Mosaic Polity, the first-ever English translation of Franciscus Junius’ De Politiae Mosis Observatione, a treatise on Mosaic law and contemporary political application. The release is part of the growing series from Acton:Sources in Early Modern Economics, Ethics, and Law. Junius (1545–1602) was a Reformed scholar and theologian at the Universities of Heidelberg and Leiden, and is known for producing a popular Latin translation of the Bible and De theologia vera, which became “a standard textbook...
EcoLinks 06.03.15
Podcast: U.N. Secretary General Wants to “Join Forces” With Catholic Church? Chris Manion, Population Research Institute Ban Ki Moon, Secreatary General of the United Nations, wants to “join forces” with the Catholic Church to save the planet. Does Mr. Ban actually believe that Pope Francis will endorse the UN’s forced abortion and sterilization programs around the world? Ban Ki-moon urges governments to invest in low carbon energy Damian Carrington, The Guardian Ban also said, with a papal encyclical on climate...
Religious Freedom and the Common Good
What is the best test of mon good? How do you know if you have a society characterized by the flourishing of persons munity? Andy Crouch argues that we should look at the flourishing of the most vulnerable. “There are all kinds of conditions in which the affluent, privileged, powerful majority can flourish,” notes Crouch in his talk at QIdeas in Nashville. “But the far more demanding test in any society is the fate of the most vulnerable—the youngest, the...
What’s the ‘Magna Carta’ Got To Do With It?
James V. Schall, SJ, reflects on the importance of the Magna Carta – perhaps the best-known historical document in the world – at The Catholic News Report. What was this famous legal document really like? What did it do? Some, like Oliver Cromwell, thought it was useless. Others did not think it particularly unique, since there were already hundreds of such charters throughout Europe. Others saw it as the basis of political responsibility, by limiting kingly rule. Still others considered...
Are Catholic priests mainly Republicans and Protestant pastors mostly Democrats?
Farmers tend to be conservative—at least until they retire, when the skew liberal. Those who serve in the Marines and Air Force tend to be Republicans while soldiers and sailors lean toward the Democrats. Golfers are the most conservative sports players while poker players at the most liberal. Those are some of the intriguing findings from a series of interactive charts by Verdant Labs that show the average political affiliations of various professions. To determine the political leanings, Verdant used...
Neil Young, Starbucks and the War on GMOs
Our religious shareholder activist buddies in As You Sow and the Interfaith Center for Corporate Responsibility can e Neil Young in their ill-advised battle against genetically modified organisms. Seems ol’ Shakey – as Young is known to his friends, family and hardcore fans – has released a song that could’ve been written from all the GMO falsehoods and scare tactics spread by AYS and ICCR, including: More than 60 percent of all processed foods available today contain GE ingredients such...
The Red Cross’ Haitian Boondoggle
Disaster relief and aid to developing nations is big business. Really big. While the documentary “Poverty, Inc.” examines whether this business helps or hurts, it’s very clear from this NPR/ProPublica story that the Red Cross did not help Haiti. And the Red Cross didn’t help Haiti to the tune of $500 million. The Red Cross claims all the money went to Haitians. Haitians say no. Former Haitian prime minister Jean-Max Bellerive: I’m not a big mathematician, but I can make...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved