Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
New York AG takes aim at the NRA and the rule of law
New York AG takes aim at the NRA and the rule of law
Jun 30, 2025 9:01 PM

The attorney general of New York state, Letitia James, fired a shot across the bow of the National Rifle Association last week, filing a lawsuit to “dissolve” the nation’s largest gun rights organization “in its entirety.” This punitive legal action is aimed like a Gatling gun at our civic foundations.

James charged four NRA officials with defrauding the New York-based nonprofit of $64 million over three years to finance a lavish lifestyle for themselves, their families, and friends. The specific charges are best settled within the legal system. However, one gets the unsettling feeling that the specifics are beside the point. This is a transparent abuse of power to destroy a well-heeled political foe.

Diversion of charitable funds ranks among the worst moral failures and violations of one’s oath as a trustee – to serve as someone who, by definition, is entrusted with overseeing the proper dispersal of funds for their intended purposes.

However, the first remedy is not to close the doors of a 149-year-old grassroots organization that boasts 5.5 million members – unless that happens to be one’s overarching purpose.

That suspicion is confirmed by James’ own words. “We shut down the president’s own foundation,” James said. “We intend to do the same with the NRA.”

In less politicized cases, state officials only shutter charities when the nonprofit masquerades as another organization, or when virtually none of its funds serve their intended goals. For instance, then-Ohio Attorney General Mike DeWine sued to dissolve a “charity” called Cops for Kids when he learned only two percent of its funds went to charity. Last year, Washington state Attorney General Bob Ferguson closed two dozen charities – founded by a man associated with the Gambino crime family – that falsely claimed to be associated with the United Way (which never received a dime of its donations).

That clearly does not apply to the NRA, which posted contributions of $98 million in 2018 alone. Even if every allegation James made is correct, the NRA had substantial funds to left to spend on its donors’ intentions. Indeed, that seems to be the problem.

The NRA exists to defend the Second Amendment rights of U.S. gun owners. To that end, it spent $54 million in the 2016 election cycle – including more than $30 million supporting President Donald Trump. The remaining funds went to 223 Republicans and nine Democrats.

None went to Tish James, who has promised to take “a proactive approach” to enforcing gun control laws. Her disproportionate legal action against the NRA undermines two unalienable rights: the right to keep and bear arms, and the freedom of association. By dissolving the nation’s leading gun rights lobby and seeing that its funds are dispersed for “legitimate charitable purposes” – as defined by the attorney general, not the NRA’s donors – James undercuts one of her fiercest political rivals.

While membership organizations like the NRA are often portrayed as legislative Goliaths, they are in fact a collection of a million scattered Davids pooling their collective power to bind down the federal government with the chains of the Constitution.

No one expressed this better than Alexis de Tocqueville, who noted the iron-clad law that government action aimed at establishing “equality” renders the citizens increasingly powerless. “Since citizens have e weak while ing more equal, they can do nothing in industry without associating; now, the public power naturally wants to place these associations under its control,” Tocqueville wrote in Democracy in America.

Since these “associations are stronger and more formidable than a simple individual can be,” the government seeks to give them less freedom “than would be allowed for an individual,” he continued:

Sovereigns have that much more inclination to act in this way since it suits their tastes. Among democratic peoples it is only by association that the resistance of citizens to the central power e about; consequently the latter never sees associations that are not under its control except with disfavor.

For this reason, Tocqueville wrote, the state has historically sought to abort, regulate, or dissolve these intermediary institutions:

Among all the peoples of Europe, there are certain associations that can be formed only after the State has examined their statutes and authorized their existence. Among several, efforts are being made to extend this rule to all associations. You see easily where the success of such an undertaking would lead.

If the sovereign power had once the general right to authorize, on certain conditions, associations of all types, it would not take long to claim that of overseeing them and of directing them, so that the associations would not able to evade the rule that it had imposed on them. In this way, the State, after making all those who desire to associate dependent on it, would make all those who have associated dependent as well, that is to say, nearly all the men who are alive today.

In this way, the state gradually absorbs the nonprofits that make up civil society or refashions them into a cat’s paw to plish the will of politicians, not citizens. The NRA is but the latest example.

The NRA responded in a press release by calling James’ lawsuit “a power grab by a political opportunist.” It has filed a countersuit, claiming political bias – the same legal stratagem that President Trump employed in his unsuccessful defense.

President Trump greeted the news by saying, “I think the NRA should move to Texas and lead a very good and beautiful life.” The attorneys general of Texas and West Virginia, as well as Arkansas Gov. Asa Hutchison, responded by inviting the NRA to relocate to their states. But the impartial administration of justice should not depend on the sufferance of political leaders, the exigencies of geography, or the pendulum of electoral es.

James’ effort to suppress the NRA and deny equal protection of the law to a political foe shows the high price of politicizing charitable institutions.

radin / .)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Rev. Robert Sirico on Religious Liberty and the Obamacare Mandate
On Friday, a federal court ruled that Christian book publisher Tyndale House is temporarily exempt from the Obamacare contraception mandate. Tonight at 6:30 EST on TheBlaze TV, Rev. Robert Sirico will discuss that case, along with a wider discussion of religious liberty and opposition to the Obamacare mandate by other businesses and organizations. ...
Business, Profits, and Faith
In the Autumn 2012 issue of Response, Jeff Van Duzer, wrote an article entitled, “Does Business Matter To God,” on the issue of faith and work. He is a well-respected professor of business law and ethics at Seattle Pacific University who gives a unique look into the role faith plays in business. This entire issue of Response is dedicated to the topics of faith and work. I will write about a few other noteworthy articles over ing weeks. Van Duzer...
Abraham Kuyper: Vampire Hunter
A rare work in which Kuyper dispatches a particularly troublesome vampire.However history remembers me … it shall only remember a fraction of the truth. The multi-talented Abraham Kuyper is sometimes difficult to introduce. I often use the descriptors, “theologian, statesman, journalist” to highlight his many interests and talents. But there is much more than this to the life and work of plex pelling figure. As a recent introduction to Kuyper’s thought puts it, “Kuyper was a man of many hats:...
Court Rules Hobby Lobby Must Violate Its Faith
On Friday the cause of religious liberty was advanced when a federal court stopped enforcement of the Obama administration’s abortion pill mandate against Tyndale House Publishers, the world’s largest privately held Christian publisher of Bibles. But yesterday freedom faced another setback when a federal court rejected Hobby Lobby Stores Inc.’s request to be issued a similar injunction against the conscience-violating mandate: In his ruling denying Hobby Lobby’s request for an injunction, Heaton said that while churches and other religious organizations...
Every Day is Children’s Day
I remember when I was a kid and would ask why we celebrate Father’s Day and Mother’s Day. What about Children’s Day? To which I would receive the inevitable response, “Every day is Children’s Day.” I use the same response now when some smart-alecky kid pipes up with this kind of question. That may be true, in a sense, but today (Nov. 20) is also “Universal Children’s Day.” This event is a vehicle in part for UN advocacy on behalf...
Massive Fines and Growing Anxieties: The HHS Mandate
Religious groups and businesses who, by weight of conscience, are choosing not to participate in the HHS mandate requiring them to provide abortifacients, artificial birth control, sterilization procedures and abortions as part of “health” care coverage, are now faced with massive fines from the government. The fines for pliance are $100 per day per employee. For panies, that means millions in fines. Eric Baxter, Senior Counsel for The Becket Fund, says …the mandate places a “significant burden” on religious organizations’...
Video: Rev. Sirico Responds to Court Ruling on Tyndale House and Obamacare
On Nov. 19, Acton Institute President Rev. Robert A. Sirico discussed a recent federal court ruling on the Obama Administration’s HHS Contraception Mandate on ’s Real News. For more on this story, see the Tyndale House Publishers v. Sebelius resource page on the website of Alliance Defending Freedom. ...
Alexis de Tocqueville and the Character of American Education
A schoolhouse in New England from the 1830s. According to a recent Pew Center report, “Record levels of bachelor’s degree attainment in 2012 are apparent for most basic demographic groups.” 33% of 25- to 29- year-olds pleting both high school and college. According to the report, this number is up from five years ago and at record levels for the United States in general. But what does it mean? Statistics like these are constantly being produced, but they are no...
Acton Commentary: Sacrifice and Self-Interest
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I take a look at the relationship between sacrifice and self-interest. One of plaints against market economies is that they foster selfishness. But as Paul Heyne points out, it is crucially important to distinguish between self-interest and selfishness: “Many of the most eminent and sophisticated theorists in the economics profession make no effort to distinguish between self-interest and selfishness or between rational behavior and greedy behavior.” The failure to make such a distinction leads to...
‘The Field Guide to the Hero’s Journey’: Newest Acton Book
Our world desperately needs heroic people—people who shape events, who act rather than watch, who are creative and brave. Such people are needed in every field, in every realm of life—not only in law enforcement and disaster response but also in science, education, business and finance, health care, the arts, journalism, agriculture, and—not least—in the home. Rev. Robert Sirico and Jeff Sandefer, in their about-to-be-released book, have written a “blueprint” to the heroic life. The two joined Acton last week...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved