Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
MLK and Environmental Justice
MLK and Environmental Justice
Jul 13, 2025 12:12 AM

Environmental Justice Blog: “If Rev Dr Martin Luther King, Jr. was alive today he would be an environmental justice activist.”

Perhaps. MLK went to Memphis in 1968 on a mission for black garbage workers demanding equal pay and better work conditions. He was killed before he got there. 15 years later, black activists would stop a hazardous waste landfill in Warren County, North Carolina, often pointed to as the beginning of the environmental justice movement.

Are the two related? Sure. Martin transformed civil rights, and his agenda might have included environmental justice eventually. But I think his priority (like that of his protégé, the Rev. Jesse Jackson) was always people, not pollution.

Not that there’s anything wrong with that. (read on…)

And I don’t think that’s changed much. This more current bit (2000) on environmental justice in the African munity by black liberation theologian James Cone is illuminating.**

Until recently, the ecological crisis has not been a major theme in the liberation movements in the African munity. “Blacks don’t care about the environment” is a ment by white ecologists. Racial and economic justice has been at best only a marginal concern in the mainstream environmental movement. “White people care more about the endangered whale and the spotted owl than they do about the survival of young blacks in our nation’s cities” is a well-founded belief in the African munity. Justice fighters for blacks and the defenders of the earth have tended to ignore each other in their public discourse and practice. Their separation from each other is unfortunate because they are fighting the same enemy — human beings’ domination of each other and nature.

The leaders in the mainstream environmental movement are mostly middle- and upper-class whites who are unprepared culturally and intellectually to dialogue with angry blacks. The leaders in the African munity are leery of talking about anything with whites that will distract from the menacing reality of racism. What both groups fail to realize is how much they need each other in the struggle for “justice, peace and the integrity of creation.”

Keep reading:

Do we have any reason to believe that the culture most responsible for the ecological crisis will also provide the moral and intellectual resources for the earth’s liberation? White ethicists and theologians apparently think so, since so much of their discourse about theology and the earth is just talk among themselves. But I have a deep suspicion about the theological and ethical values of white culture and religion. For five hundred years whites have acted as if they owned the world’s resources and have forced people of color to accept their scientific and ethical values. [snip]

If we save the planet and have a society of inequality, we wouldn’t have saved much.

He affirms these thoughts in a 2004 interview here, adding this striking bit:

Most of the toxic dumps are in places where people don’t have resources to fight against them, usually munities…

That’s an interesting statement. Wonder if it’s true? I did. In a very non-scientific analysis I wanted to see whether toxic waste is going to predominately black or white cities. I opened up the 2005 EPA National Biennial RCRA Hazardous Waste Report and picked the top two “receivers,” the largest hazardous waste treatment and disposal facilities (what Cone calls “toxic dumps”) in each state. Then I checked out the demographic data for each of those cities.

The first two cities had by far the majority of waste disposed of in each state, so I think it’s a fair description of where most of our waste goes. Also, some states are higher waste generators but ship their waste out of state, so this list shows where toxic waste is disposed of – again, paying attention to Cone’s concern. States that don’t have TSDFs are listed as N/A; some states only had one. The amount disposed of in tons is in (). The % is black population, and if I couldn’t find data I noted that.

Here’s what I came up with. The national average for black population is 12.35%, and cities under that average are in bold.

[Note: Ignore breaks in the list; just the way the list formatted. They don’t mean anything.]

AL Emelle (58,840 tons) 76%

Attalla (23,801 tons) 13%

AK Anchorage (144) 6%

Elmendorf AFB (4) 10%

AZ Tolleson (26,155) 1.3%

Coolidge (3,827) 8.6%

AR Foreman (98,201) 25%

Benton (78,115) 4%

CA Compton (1,233,500) 40%

City of Industry (174,574) 4%

CO Henderson (17,599) 4%

Deer Trail (4,315) 0%

CT Bristol (9,743) 2.5%

Meriden (7,276) 7%

DE Wilmington (373) 56%

DC N/A

FL Bartow (6,781) 27%

Orlando (3,446) 26%

GA Valdosta (4,203) 49%

Morrow (900) 42%

HI Navy PWC (400) 10%

ID Grand View (113,188) 0%

Mayfield (22,672) 0%

IL Chicago (179,472) 36%

Peoria (103,619) 25%

IN Indianapolis (94,677) 25%

Butler (62,562) 0%

IA Davenport (262) 9%

Des Moines (174) 8%

KS Fredonia (144,138) 0.1%

Chanute (48,646) 1.1%

KY Smithfield (47,589) 0%

Calvert City (18,173) 0%

LA Waggaman (141,885) 54%

Sulphur (99,790) 3.2%

ME South Portland (2,214) 0.4%

Leeds (167) 0.1%

MD Baltimore (127,125) 63%

Forest Hill (9) 3%

MA Braintree (18,110) 1%

Lowell (5,027) 4.2%

MI Belleville (196,057) 6%

Detroit (77,358) 81%

MN Eagan (267,034) 4%

Cottage Grove (26,298) 2.5%

MS Artesia (55,961) 85%

Jackson (735) 70%

MO Hannibal (69,375) 6%

Cape Girardeau (62,277) 9%

MT N/A

NE Kimball (35,336) 0.2%

Fairbury (333) 0.1%

NV Beatty (51,464) 0%

Fernley (8,299) 0%NH N/A

NJ Deepwater (61,173) 0%

Middlesex (49,258) 3.5%

NM Carlsbad (8,434) 2.6%

Albuquerque (437) 3.1%

NY Middletown (158,520) 14.3%

Model City (74,423) 6%

NC Durham (46,932) 44%

Geidsville (18,266) Unk%

ND Belfield (351) 1.2%

Bismarck (141) 0.3%

OH Oregon (232,602) 1.1%

Vickery (97,134) 1.2%

OK Waynoka (44,207) 2.5%

Mcalester (3,283) 8.2%

OR Arlington (90,892) 0%

Hermiston (1,882) 0.9%

PA Palmerton (224,632) 0.2%

Bath (65,449) 2.6%

RI Cranston (33,672) 3.2%

Providence (4,894) 13.8%

SC Holly HIll (68,849) 52%

Sumter (48,087) 47%

SD Sioux Falls (133) 1.8%

TN Millington (21,002) 22.9%

Oak Ridge (1,150) 7.8%

TX Deer Park (104,389) 1.1%

Channelview (83,414) 12.8%

UT Grantsville (86,149) 0.2%

Aragonite (51,760) 0%

VT Barre (195) 0.4%

Burlington (28) 1.9%

VA Arvonia (45,321) 58%

Chesapeake (448) 28%

WA Kent (17,325) 8%

a (13,831) 11.2%

WV Morgantown (5,285) 4%

Natrium (4,374) Unk%

WI Menomonee Falls (21,244) 1.7%

Eau Claire (15,917) 0.6%WY None

63 cities are under the national average for black population, and 27 cities are over it. What’s more, major disposal sites like the one in Compton CA are ranked by Scorecard.org as among the cleanest in the United States and are regulated by Cal EPA and EPA Region 9, who manage the most progressive and heavily-enforced waste disposal program in the world.

Like I said – unscientific. It’s certainly possible for example that these disposal sites are located in predominately black areas within each city (for those cities that actually have predominately black areas). But it does seem like there are a lot of “dumps” that don’t fit his generalization. Instead, TSDFs are located in nearly every state and in cities that vary widely in their socioeconomics; only one out of every three is predominately black.

So what’s the point? Christians like Professor Cone, the Rev. Al Sharpton and I have all been drawn to Psalm 24:1 for a reason – it proclaims that the earth is in fact the Lords. It doesn’t belong to mankind. And if any family munity or poor or wealthy or black or white person is drinking polluted water or breathing polluted air, we still have work to do on His behalf.

Rather than using ecology in a “disciplined and sustained fight against white supremacy,” (and calling Christians who don’t do so racist), we should use mon love for God and stewardship for God’s creation as a means of getting past the sorts of suspicions that Cone feels so deeply.

Perhaps one day all those who care for God’s creation will not be judged by the color of our skin as Brother Martin put it, but by the content of our character.

[Don’s other habitat is The Evangelical Ecologist]

**[Disclaimer: I was drawn to Cone because he is a black theologian writing on the environmental movement. I want to be clear I’m not judging black Christian ecologists across the board the way many find one Dominionist and use his statements to describe all Christians.]

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
What Nicholas Kristof got right
Recently, Nicholas Kristof’s published an op-ed about the Social Progress Index, a multi-year study of the quality of life in 163 countries. Kristof writes, “New data suggest that the United States is one of just a few countries worldwide that is slipping backward.” While at first reading this sounds like bad news, I think the data (and underlying science) is a bit plicated than they might appear. The SPI seeks to offer “a new way to define the success of...
When cronyism meets ‘creative destruction’
Amid rapid globalization, Americans have faced new pressures when es to economic change, leading to abundant prosperity, as well as significant pain and disruption munities. In search of a villain, populists and progressives routinely blame the expansion of free trade and rise of global conglomerates, arguing that entrenched and moneyed interests are now allowed to run rampant from country to country with petition or accountability. In search of a solution, those same critics tend to relish in nostalgia, either reminiscing...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: freedom and equality
“Equality” is a term that people uss a lot of nowadays – too much, some would argue. This week in Forbes, the Acton Institute’s managing director, international Alejandro Chafuen writes about equality and its relationship to freedom. Not all agree on which factors of equality are most important – equality of opportunity, e equality, equality before the law, and so on – but however we define it, freedom and equality cannot be separated. Dr. Chafuen’s analysis incorporates much from a...
Amy Coney Barrett: handmaid of the Lord, not the state
In their attempt to forestall the nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court, a growing number mentators point to her membership in a Christian group that once used the term “handmaid.” This “controversy” shows, among other things, how the works of Margaret Atwood have displaced the traditional Western canon. However, it also adds a thin veneer of respectability over rehashed anti-Catholic prejudice, camouflages anti-Christian bigotry, and conceals a noxious and unconstitutional religious test for office. It takes little...
Gavin Newsom’s gas-powered vehicle ban: the wrong approach to fight climate change
One would expect that the decades-long exodus of low- and e residents fleeing California would be cause for reflection and self-critical introspection on behalf of its effective one-party government. Skyrocketing costs of living and a cratering middle class – caused by years of anti-business regulation, powerful public sector labor union monopolies, and one of the highest tax burdens in the nation – should be ample reason for the Golden State’s progressive leadership to reassess its approach to governance. But don’t...
Beyond civility: Ginsburg, Scalia, and friendship
The first presidential debate provided an accurate and disheartening summary of our current political climate – three men shouting over each other for 90 minutes. Opposite sides of the political spectrum cannot seem to agree on basic truths or mon ground. The majority of Trump and Biden voters say that they have few or no close friends who voted for the opposite party. A thriving society requires that we are able to debate important questions and find solutions together. What...
Fratelli Tutti is a familiar mixture of dubious claims, strawmen, genuine insights
One of the first things that will strike readers of Pope Francis’s new social encyclical Fratelli Tutti is its sheer length. At about 43,000 words in English (including footnotes), that’s more than the Book of Genesis (32,046) and three times the size of the Gospel of John (15,635). Despite its length, there’s little in this text that we have not heard Francis say before in one form or another. But whether the subject is capital punishment or his theme of...
FAQ: What is Sukkot, the ‘Feast of Tabernacles’?
The Jewish feast of Sukkot lasts seven (or eight) days – in 2020, from sundown on Friday, October 2, to sundown on Friday, October 9. Here are the facts you need to know. When is Sukkot? Sukkot – also known as the Feast of Tabernacles, Feast of Booths, Feast of Ingathering, or simply “The Feast” – always begins on the fifteenth day of the seventh month of the Jewish calendar (Tishrei). Thus, it begins five days after Yom Kippur, the...
COVID-19 and crony capitalism
Who wins in the COVID-19 economy? In some cases, outright fraud allows businesses to prosper. In other cases, political connections enable businesses to collect revenue from the federal government. Crony capitalism is defined by the Mercatus Center as “an economic system in which the profitability of firms in a market economy depends on political connections.” Large-scale bailouts and interventions have increased cronyism during the pandemic. The more government funds that are available for individuals and businesses to capture, the larger...
Everything that’s wrong with Dick Costolo’s tweet in 1,531 characters
Woke capitalism went into overdrive on Wednesday, when a former Twitter CEO seemingly endorsed the full-scale liquidation of entrepreneurs who refuse to bring politics into the workplace. Dick Costolo served as COO of Twitter before ing its CEO from 2010 to 2015. On September 30, he replied to a tweet about woke capitalism from venture capitalist Paul Graham. Graham shared a statement from the cryptocurrency exchange platform Coinbase, which vowed to “create a sense of cohesion and unity” by emphasizing...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved