Islamic World
Trial exposes Turkey's 'deep state'
Trial exposes Turkey's 'deep state'
May 30, 2024 10:00 AM

  Turkey has always been a country haunted by conspiracy theories – and not without reason.

  Western powers nearly succeeded in dividing Turkey between themselves at the end of the Ottoman Empire ... and after the rise of the Soviet Union, new Nato member Turkey was on the frontline of the Cold War.

  Conspiracy literature is a huge industry there: Books postulating improbable links between regional powers - even one series claiming Recep Tayyip Erdogan, the Turkish prime minister, is "secretly Jewish and doing Israel's bidding" - are best sellers.

  But even by Turkish standards, the events unfolding in a special courthouse in Besiktas, central Istanbul, beggar belief.

  49 very senior military figures, some retired and some - and this is a new and significant development - still on active duty, have been brought before special prosecutors to answer charges of involvement in a plot to destabilize the country and pave the way for another military coup.

  The alleged plan for achieving this takeover involved a systematic exploitation of Turkey's history of antagonism and suspicion towards its ethnic and religious minorities, and a bombing campaign designed to cause significant numbers of civilian casualties.

  It seems this was to be blamed on "Islamic terrorism", with the intention of showing up the government as being "soft" on the issue, and leading to a public outcry calling for the return of military rule.

  The "threat" posed by neighbor Greece was also to be invoked, with a proposal to provoke a Greek airstrike on a Turkish fighter jet.

  Leaked documents

  The principal "plot" which is the centre of the prosecutions there – called Balyoz or Sledgehammer – has not come out of the blue.

  It was published by a fiercely independent Turkish newspaper, Taraf, on 20 January this year, and came in the wake of revelations in the same publication last December of another plot called Kafes, or Cage, that had even more detailed schemes for the re-establishment of military rule.

  But Taraf reports were chiefly the product of a hefty series of leaked documents – the "plot literature".

  The military has not denied they are theirs, but says they are merely hypothetical – the sort of "crisis scenarios" that security forces deal in.

  The question is: Who leaked them? And: Why now?

  Turkey is already in the midst of the most significant prosecution of supposed coup-plotters in its history.

  Known as the "Ergenekon Trial", there have so far been nearly 200 hearings since October 20, 2008.

  The evidence that forms the basis for this judicial process has been piling up since 2001, but only gained momentum in 2007 when - after a tip off - a small arms cache was discovered in the Istanbul suburb of Umraniye which - it is claimed - was linked to the "deep state".

  Turks have always known they have many parallel actors in its government and security services, not all of which were legitimate or even widely known.

  Bulent Ecevit, a former prime minister, broke the silence on the deep state in the 1970s, acknowledging that there were secret paramilitary operations working "within the government".

  He much later admitted that even in office he was in the dark about what some of them were.

  The investigations following the 2007 tip off has so far resulted in three sets of multiple indictments - with another one believed to be pending - hundred of arrests, and media-promoted revelations from sources such as tapped private phones.

  The fact that some of these were of only tangential relevance to the prosecution, and that some of the evidential facts have been publicly disputed, has not helped maintain public confidence in the legal process.

  Secret operations

  The guiding philosophy of Turkey's secret operations was to maintain the strength of the country's secular state as founded by Mustafa Kemal Ataturk in the 1920s.

  The means included many extrajudicial killings, assassination of people regarded as ideological or political threats, and the waging of numerous counter-terrorist operations against groups like the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK) who were viewed as a threat to the integrity of the Turkish nation.

  Few, if any, of the orders and powers behind these actions have ever been examined in the public domain – or brought to justice.

  There have been some official investigations, but few real conclusions and fewer prosecutions.

  This is despite many campaigns by human rights groups and families of the victims.

  The European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg, France, has in fact made more rulings on these cases than the Turkish courts.

  At the same time, the continuity of Ataturk's legacy was one of the justifications for the four military-led overthrows of the Turkish government since 1960.

  The military have – to their supporters – been seen as a "reset button" to be activated when Turkish politics drifted too far from what it is believed Ataturk intended.

  'Islamic threat'

  Increasingly in recent years, battle lines have been drawn between the secular/nationalist legacy of Ataturk and what some see as the rise of political Islam, embodied in its most successful version under the ruling AK Party, which was first elected in 2002.

  The secular axis in Turkish politics – which in the past was led by the military – has tried repeatedly to limit what they see as a potential "Islamic threat".

  Their ability to do this has diminished as Turkey's tolerance for military coups has waned with modernization, and the ideal of religious and cultural freedom as something positive has grown.

  But an attempt in 2008 to close down the government using the court system on the grounds that it was undermining Turkey's secular constitution, after it tried to lift the ban on women wearing head scarves in public institutions, only narrowly failed.

  The government was instead "fined" $20m by the constitutional court.

  Now it looks as if the tables are turning, and the civilian government in Ankara may be gaining the upper hand for the first time.

  General Ilker Basbug, Turkey's military chief, accused the government in December 2009 of waging "asymmetric psychological warfare" against the military.

  One AK Party deputy, Avni Dogan, declared on 20 February that "they blacklisted us for 40 years, now we are blacklisting them".

  Seismic events

  What seems to have changed is that the government has sufficient allies in the civil service and the police, perhaps even now in the military, to run its own investigations into the activities of the deep state, and its perceived antagonists in the armed forces.

  The Turkish public is deeply divided about what to believe.

  The country is split between those who believe the Ergenekon investigation is a long overdue clean-up of the deep state, and a move in the direction of a properly functioning democracy - while others are equally convinced it is a "plot to overturn the legacy of Ataturk and establish an Islamic state" in its place.

  The Sledgehammer prosecutions – to them – are merely another stage in this process.

  Even the country's judiciary is at odds over how to conduct these investigations – or even whether they should be conducted at all.

  But by any reckoning, the events of the past week are politically seismic.

  It is the first time that there have been large-scale arrests of such senior figures in the Turkish military, including not only retired officers who might otherwise be portrayed as belonging to another era of governance, but also serving members.

  Prosecutors also appear to feel that in the shape of the Sledgehammer plot, they have something "actionable" – a tangible signed document that leads directly to senior military figures.

  And the possibility that these documents came from military sources, may demonstrate a push for reform from within, as well as from outside.

  It is entirely possible that the Turkish military command is no longer completely aware of what is going on within its own ranks.

  Turkey is in new and unpredictable political territory.


  Marchers outside Istanbul denouncing the Ergenekon conspiracy. Banner features images of some suspected members. Banner caption reads "The plot will be foiled, U.S.A will lose, Turkey will win".

  Source: Aljazeera.net

Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
Islamic World
Mohamed Morsi: An Egyptian tragedy
  by Abdullah Al-Arian   The death of former President Mohamed Morsi is only the latest in a series of untold tragedies that have afflicted Egypt since the spark of revolution flickered more than eight years ago. His unlikely rise to the presidency reflected the aspirations of millions of Egyptians for a...
One year after battle for Mosul, a city lies in ruins
  One year ago, Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi stood in front of cameras in Mosul and declared the city recaptured after three years of being occupied by ISIL, also known as ISIS.   Clad in a black uniform and flanked by army commanders and heads of security forces that were involved...
Who is bombing hospitals in Syria?
  And why is the UN not naming the perpetrators?   by Rashed al-Ahmad   My name is Rashed al-Ahmad. I'm a pharmacist originally from Kurnaz, a small village in the countryside of Syria's Hama province. I fled my home years ago to avoid being detained or killed by the regime for providing...
Yemen: First bombs, soon a coronavirus epidemic
  At a time when the world is scrambling to respond to COVID-19 and ensure that hospitals can treat all patients, Yemen has entered the sixth year of a war that has all but decimated its healthcare system.   The new threats of the virus will complicate an already disastrous and entirely...
Jerusalem and Al-Aqsa: The Cause of Every Muslim
  Author: IslamWeb   Today’s discussion revolves around Palestine, Jerusalem, and Al-Aqsa, focusing on the plight of our Muslim brothers and sisters there. They endure atrocities such as killings, missile strikes, house demolitions, and displacement amidst daily obstinacy, insults, abuses, aggressions, and betrayal.   Based on the principle that those who do not...
'War crimes' committed by Russia, Assad gov't in Syria: Amnesty
  Amnesty report documents 18 attacks on clinics and schools in violations that amount to war crimes.   Acts that amount to "war crimes" have been committed by Russian-backed Syrian government forces in northwest Syria over the past year, according to an Amnesty International report.   The UK-based rights group said on Monday...
Coronavirus outbreak in the time of apartheid
  As the world calls for solidarity, Palestinians expect none from their occupiers.   by Osama Tanous   As the number of infections and deaths from COVID-19 multiply by the day, there have been increasing calls across the world for people to show solidarity and care for each other. Yet for the Israeli...
The October Arab-Israeli War of 1973: What happened?
  It has been 45 years since the start of the 1973 War between Israel, Egypt and Syria.   The war, known to Israelis as the Yom Kippur War, and to Arabs as the October War, ushered in a new reality in the Arab world and changed the face of US foreign...
Gaza killings constitute 'war crimes': Amnesty
  The attacks on Palestinian protesters by Israeli forces on Monday are “willful killings constituting war crimes,” the Amnesty International said.   “This is another horrific example of the Israeli military using excessive force and live ammunition in a totally deplorable way. This is a violation of international standards, in some instances...
Israel 'moving rapidly' towards annexation: UN envoy
  New settlement in Hebron seen as reaffirmation of Israel's intent to remain permanently in occupied West Bank.   The Ewaiwe family home in Hebron's H2 district has been heavily fortified to protect them against the settlers living just next door in the illegal Avraham Avinu settlement.   Rubbish thrown by settlers hangs...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2024 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved