Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
ICCR Proxy Resolutions Back Net Neutrality
ICCR Proxy Resolutions Back Net Neutrality
Jul 4, 2026 12:21 AM

Blurring the distinction between religious faith and totally unrelated political activism has attained new levels of absurdity during the 2013 proxy resolution voting season.

One needs look no further than the network neutrality proxy resolutions submitted to AT&T Inc. by a host of clergy and religious organizations for evidence. These groups assert that net neutrality – described in their resolution as “open Internet policies” – “help drive the economy, encourage innovation and reward investors” when nothing could be further from the truth on all three counts.

Instead, the only groups advocating for net neutrality are left-of-center organizations who wish to shackle the profitability of Internet providers and stifle the growth of what has e one-sixth of the nation’s economy over the past 20 years. Joining these organizations with the AT&T proxy resolutions are the following Interfaith Council of Corporate Responsibility members:

Benedictine Sisters of Mount St. Scholastica, Rose Marie Stallbaumer, OSB;Trillium Asset Management Corporation, Jonas Kron;Benedictine Sisters of Virginia, Sr. Henry Marie Zimmermann, OSB;Christus Health, Delia Foster;Congregation of the Sisters of Charity of the Incarnate Word, San Antonio, Carolyn Psencik;Nathan Cummings Foundation, Laura Shaffer Campos;Congregation of Benedictine Sisters, Boerne TX, Sr. Susan Mika, OSB.

The resolution filed by these groups reads: “AT&T expects mobile data traffic to grow more than eight times from 2011 levels.

“A critical factor in this growth is the open (non-discriminatory) architecture of the Internet. Non-discrimination principles monly referred to as ‘network neutrality’ and seek to ensure equal access and non-discriminatory treatment for all content.”

Keep in mind that Comcast sued the Federal Communications Commission over net neutrality regulations in 2010 – and won in a unanimous decision by the three judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. Despite this, the FCC voted 3-2 along partisan lines in December 2010 to adopt net neutrality regulations – despite possessing no authority whatsoever to do so as only Congress can make such laws. These regulations are being challenged by Verizon Communications Inc. in the same court that heard the original case.

So, who favors net neutrality besides the ICCR proxy shareholders listed above? In September 2012, Free Press, Public Knowledge and the New America Foundation’s Open Technology Institute – far-left liberal groups all – filed plaint with the FCC that accused AT&T of violating mission’s net neutrality rules. These staunch advocates of government-imposed net neutrality regulations are birds of a feather with the ICCR groups.

The left-leaning groups can be excused for holding a contrary point of view on any given number of topics, including net neutrality. Diversity of opinion, after all, is the American way.

However, the ICCR groups – most of them Roman Catholic in this instance – are squandering any religious authority they might possess on a liberal rather than theological issue.

Tito Edwards, editor of the Catholic Internet news aggregator The Pulpit and editorial contributor to The American Catholic Web site, told this writer in 2011 that clergy and religious champions of net neutrality “are violating free-market principles set out by the Catholic Church,” he said. “Controlling the Internet does no one any good as it is simply another step towards socialism munism, both condemned by the Church.”

It should be mentioned that net neutrality poses serious negative threats to the U.S. economy, potentially costing consumers more than 500,000 jobs and eliminating $62 billion from GDP over the next 20 years; increase consumer Internet bills by up to $55 a month; and significantly deter technological innovation.

How this benefits America’s poor and middle class or fulfills the ICCR promise to “drive the economy, encourage innovation and reward investors” is plete mystery.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
When bookshops were miraculous, romantic places
Not even Amazon can put the original “Shop Around the Corner” out of business. Now, as for the remake … Read More… I began a series of essays on Christmas movies last week with The Bishop’s Wife (1947), a story about church, munity of the faithful, and spiritual responsibility. This week, I’m writing about a less lofty subject, munity of the workplace and the life merce, but a much better movie, The Shop Around the Corner (1940), one of the...
Pro-democracy activist Jimmy Lai found guilty over Tiananmen Square Massacre vigil
Lai and two co-defendants were convicted on charges related to their participation in the annual Tiananmen Square Massacre vigil, another Beijing-inspired blow to free speech and free assembly in Hong Kong. Read More… Hong Kong media tycoon and outspoken pro-democracy activist Jimmy Lai has been convicted for his involvement in a memorating the Tiananmen Square Massacre. On Dec. 9, Lai, along with two other prominent Hong Kong activists, Gwyneth Ho and Chow Hang Tung, were found guilty of incitement and...
What the Kyle Rittenhouse trial taught America about assumptions, keeping peace
While questions of police brutality, persistent racism and criminal justice reform should concern all citizens, we must realize that violence and disorder provide no path to a more just future. Read More… On Nov. 19, Kyle Rittenhouse was found not guilty on all charges related to the fatal shooting of two men and the wounding of another on the third day of widespread rioting and civil unrest in Kenosha, Wisconsin, in August last year. The trial had for many Americans...
Hong Kong drops 62 places in “press freedom” by country
The effects of the National Security Law are being felt by journalists in Hong Kong, as the city suffers a terrible slide into a totalist state to match China’s. Read More… Reporters Without Borders (RSF) released this year’s World Press Freedom Index, ranking countries based on press freedom, from the most to the least press. In 2002, for example, Hong Kong was ranked 18th. This year, it fell to 80th out of 180 countries, while China landed at #177, only...
Advent lifts the veil of judgment and mercy in the divine economy
Christians in the marketplace are motivated by more than profit. They seek also to be worthy of the public trust so as to avoid divine judgment. Read More… One of the more disturbing aspects of the way the market economy works is the ability of, at least some, participants to avoid responsibility for their decisions and actions. The manner in which this works is through the concepts of corporate personality and limited liability. The corporation is deemed to have a...
The problem of the atheist economist
Entrepreneurs, to be truly successful, must know more than basic economics. They must also have a higher purpose, one not reducible to mere productivity. Read More… There is much in the classical liberal economist that I find attractive. By classical liberal, I do not mean the sort of political liberalism that defaults to certain presumptions of big government. Rather, I mean one who adheres to a more libertarian adoption of free market principles. Yet the classical liberal economist without faith...
Inflation is real and we’re experiencing the costs and consequences
Don’t believe that increasing the money supply or jacking up federal spending costs nothing. Blaming corporate greed for rising prices is just a diversion from poor economic policy. Read More… Generally, the topic of inflation is considered dry and uninteresting, but it is one that has garnered much attention and debate over the past year. There peting narratives as to what inflation is and why it matters, and even whether the U.S. economy is experiencing inflation or not. Inflation is...
The social responsibility of business is still to its business
Do corporations have an obligation to address the needs of the larger society? Or was Milton Friedman right, that their only clear obligation is to their shareholders? Read More… Most people have intuitions about moral issues of consequence, but we often find it difficult to put these intuitions into words. Something seems to us to be right or wrong, but we struggle to express our ideas accurately and to explain why our intuitions are reasonable pelling. As Peter Drucker used...
China and Russia don’t know why they were excluded from the “Summit for Democracy”
Should you tell them or should I? Read More… Presidential summits tend to focus on PR rather than substance. The Biden administration’s “Summit for Democracy” looks no different. Its objectives were worthy. Asthe State Departmentexplained it, President Joe Biden planned to “bring together leaders from government, civil society, and the private sector to set forth an affirmative agenda for democratic renewal and to tackle the greatest threats faced by democracies today through collective action.” However, most of the topics probably...
Christmas 1991: The birth of freedom in the death of the evil empire
Whether the work of Providence, a pope and a president, or the inner contradictions of a bankrupt ideology, the collapse of the USSR meant hope of a free and democratic Russia. Has that hope been fulfilled? Read More… “You can have a very quiet Christmas evening,” wished Soviet President Mikhail Gorbachev to American President George H. W. Bush. “I am saying good-bye and shaking your hand.” It was a long-distance handshake, done via telephone. And it came on Christmas Day,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved