Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
ICCR Proxy Resolutions Back Net Neutrality
ICCR Proxy Resolutions Back Net Neutrality
Mar 14, 2026 6:23 AM

Blurring the distinction between religious faith and totally unrelated political activism has attained new levels of absurdity during the 2013 proxy resolution voting season.

One needs look no further than the network neutrality proxy resolutions submitted to AT&T Inc. by a host of clergy and religious organizations for evidence. These groups assert that net neutrality – described in their resolution as “open Internet policies” – “help drive the economy, encourage innovation and reward investors” when nothing could be further from the truth on all three counts.

Instead, the only groups advocating for net neutrality are left-of-center organizations who wish to shackle the profitability of Internet providers and stifle the growth of what has e one-sixth of the nation’s economy over the past 20 years. Joining these organizations with the AT&T proxy resolutions are the following Interfaith Council of Corporate Responsibility members:

Benedictine Sisters of Mount St. Scholastica, Rose Marie Stallbaumer, OSB;Trillium Asset Management Corporation, Jonas Kron;Benedictine Sisters of Virginia, Sr. Henry Marie Zimmermann, OSB;Christus Health, Delia Foster;Congregation of the Sisters of Charity of the Incarnate Word, San Antonio, Carolyn Psencik;Nathan Cummings Foundation, Laura Shaffer Campos;Congregation of Benedictine Sisters, Boerne TX, Sr. Susan Mika, OSB.

The resolution filed by these groups reads: “AT&T expects mobile data traffic to grow more than eight times from 2011 levels.

“A critical factor in this growth is the open (non-discriminatory) architecture of the Internet. Non-discrimination principles monly referred to as ‘network neutrality’ and seek to ensure equal access and non-discriminatory treatment for all content.”

Keep in mind that Comcast sued the Federal Communications Commission over net neutrality regulations in 2010 – and won in a unanimous decision by the three judges on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. Despite this, the FCC voted 3-2 along partisan lines in December 2010 to adopt net neutrality regulations – despite possessing no authority whatsoever to do so as only Congress can make such laws. These regulations are being challenged by Verizon Communications Inc. in the same court that heard the original case.

So, who favors net neutrality besides the ICCR proxy shareholders listed above? In September 2012, Free Press, Public Knowledge and the New America Foundation’s Open Technology Institute – far-left liberal groups all – filed plaint with the FCC that accused AT&T of violating mission’s net neutrality rules. These staunch advocates of government-imposed net neutrality regulations are birds of a feather with the ICCR groups.

The left-leaning groups can be excused for holding a contrary point of view on any given number of topics, including net neutrality. Diversity of opinion, after all, is the American way.

However, the ICCR groups – most of them Roman Catholic in this instance – are squandering any religious authority they might possess on a liberal rather than theological issue.

Tito Edwards, editor of the Catholic Internet news aggregator The Pulpit and editorial contributor to The American Catholic Web site, told this writer in 2011 that clergy and religious champions of net neutrality “are violating free-market principles set out by the Catholic Church,” he said. “Controlling the Internet does no one any good as it is simply another step towards socialism munism, both condemned by the Church.”

It should be mentioned that net neutrality poses serious negative threats to the U.S. economy, potentially costing consumers more than 500,000 jobs and eliminating $62 billion from GDP over the next 20 years; increase consumer Internet bills by up to $55 a month; and significantly deter technological innovation.

How this benefits America’s poor and middle class or fulfills the ICCR promise to “drive the economy, encourage innovation and reward investors” is plete mystery.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
US to UK: Embrace ‘spirit’ of Declaration of Independence for Brexit
On this Fourth of July, the U.S. ambassador to the UK has written an op-ed encouraging the government to embrace the spirit of the Declaration of Independence. Robert Wood Johnson’s op-ed points to the special relationship that grew up following our Revolution to strengthen Theresa May’s flagging resolve as Brexit talks lumber forward. “Change calls for courage, conviction and confidence,” writes Ambassador Robert Wood Johnson in the Daily Mail. “And there is no finer example of that spirit in action...
Mexico begins its own road to hell
All Latin-Americans at some point ask themselves: Why is no Latin American country as well-developed as the United States? The answer is probably not related to our weather or a lesser disposition to work, as many have tried to claim. The answer is probably simpler: A socialist culture and a strong attachment to the left. Venezuela, Bolivia, Ecuador, and Argentina are all countries that suffered or are suffering devastating economic, political, and social crises. They are all examples of countries...
A blueprint for a free Islamic society at Acton University
In post-9/11 America, the Islamic faith appears to many to be patible with freedom. What we know of the Muslim world consists largely of oppressive terrorist groups ruling their own fiefdoms with an iron grip, stifling the free market and political liberty. However, in his Acton University lecture, entitled “Islam, Markets, and the Free Society,” Mustafa Akyol argued that this is not the whole story. During his talk, he took a deep dive into the history of the Islamic world,...
First Reformed: The toxic mess of syncretism
There’s a lot to process in Paul Schrader’s latest film, “First Reformed.” The first half of the film sets up as a powerful, even brilliant, study of spiritual desolation and the cross-currents of modern idolatry and traditional religion. It is possible to sympathize with the protagonist, even as Rev. Ernst Toller’s desperation spirals deeper into darkness. The plot revolves around the recurring question: Can God forgive us? That is, can God forgive us for our myriad sins of omission mission?...
How does Catholic social teaching apply to public unions?
Last week the Supreme Court ruled in the case ofJanus v. AFSCMEthat government employees who are represented by a public sector union to which they do not belong cannot be required to pay a fee to cover the costs of collective bargaining. The ruling overturned a forty-year-old precedent first set inAbood v. Detroit Board of Educationthat allows government agencies to mandate union dues or agency fees as a condition of employment. Catholic social teaching has a lot to say about...
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez: Catholic spokeswoman?
The day after she bested a 10-term congressman by 16 points in a Democratic Party primary, Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez made an unlikely literary debut: She published an article in a Jesuit magazine burnishing her Catholic bona fides. The story, titled, “Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez on her Catholic faith and the urgency of a criminal justice reform,” appeared in America last Wednesday. The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) member’s blog offers a personal reflection about an incarcerated relative, cites U.S. incarceration statistics as proof...
5 Facts about Independence Day
July 4, 2018will be America’s 242nd Independence Day, the day Americans celebrate our Declaration of Independence from Great Britain. Here are five facts you should know about America’s founding document and the day set aside for memoration. 1. July 4, 1776 is the day that wecelebrate Independence Dayeven though it wasn’t the day the Continental Congress decided to declare independence (they did that on July 2, 1776), the day we started the American Revolution (that had happened back in April...
Acton University: Why Fair Trade isn’t fair
Imagine: You are in the grocery store, searching for the perfect bag of coffee- not too expensive, but still rich in flavor and good quality. As you are turning away with the coffee you have just chosen, there on the shelf is a bag of coffee with the Fair Trade logo. After an intense internal debate, you return the first bag of coffee to its shelf and take the Fair Trade coffee with a sense of contentment. The coffee farmers...
Mini-Review: Advice to a Desolate France
Gene Fant, president of North Greenville University, recently attended Acton University as a presidential fellow. He, like many of us, has a bunch of summer reading lined up, and this includes the short treatise from the sixteenth century, Advice to a Desolate France, by Sebastian Castellio. Fant had this to say about Castellio’s argument: Castellio was a 16th-century scholar who was writing in a time of literal cultural wars, the battles and shameful dehumanizations of the French Wars of Religion...
Hayek is the prophet of cryptocurrencies
Even among freedom minded individuals, classical liberalism gives way to conservative resistance on the issue of money. The view prominent on the right and the left is that money is the exclusive right of the state, rather than private initiative. Thus, the dominant view is that the monetary policy should be the sole responsibility of central banks. They have a monopoly on the volume of money in circulation, credit and interest rates. In 1978, Friedrich August von Hayek presented the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved