Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How We Tax the Poor
How We Tax the Poor
Aug 28, 2026 7:17 AM

Imagine you’re a single mom with one child who receives $19,300 a year in government benefits. A local business offers to hire you full-time at an hourly rate of $15 an hour. At 2,000 hours a year (40 hours for 50 weeks) you would earn $30,000. Should you take the job or stay on the government dole?

The additional $10,700 a year certainly sounds enticing. But because you would lose your benefits and have to pay taxes, your disposable e would be about 31 percent less, around $20,700. By working full-time you’d only earn $1,400 a year more than when you were on welfare. That means you are working full-time to earn an additional 70 cents more an hour than when you were unemployed. Why bother?

That 31 percent is the effective marginal tax rate for low- and e workers will face, on average, in 2016. The marginal tax rate is the percentage of an additional dollar of earnings that is unavailable to an individual because it is paid in taxes or offset by reduced benefits from government programs. As the Congressional Budget Office points out in a statement of the obvious, that rate affects people’s incentives to work: “In particular, when marginal tax rates are high, people tend to respond to the smaller financial gain from employment by working fewer hours, altering the intensity of their work, or not working at all.”

As Robert VerBruggen notes, that marginal rate remains high well above the poverty line:

In general, once you hit the poverty line, you’ll face a flat tax of a bit above 30percent—at least until you reach 450 percent of poverty, which is where the data here end. (Roughly two-thirds of the populationfalls below that mark, which this year is about $109,000 for a family of four.)

And the situation will be very bad for some. Between 50 and 150 percent of the poverty level, more than 10 percent of workers will pay a marginal rate above50 percent.

The CBO report has an in-depth explanation of the marginal tax rate and its effect on the poor.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Video: William B. Allen on the Common Foundation of Christianity and Modern Politics
On Thursday, June 16th, it was a great pleasure to e William B. Allen – Emeritus Professor of Political Philosophy and Emeritus Dean of James Madison College at Michigan State University – as a plenary speaker at Acton University 2016, to deliver an address entitled “A Moral Surprise: The Common Foundation of Christianity and Modern Politics.” Allen used his address to argue that true political freedom requires freedom of conscience as its foundation – a freedom of conscience that cannot...
Why Churches Should Be Tax Exempt
Churches and other religious institutions in American are almost always exempt from federal, state, and local taxes. The justification for this policy is usually that such institutions provide vital charitable benefits to society. While that is undoubtably true the benefits argument is not the strongest reason to support tax exemption. A better reason is that we need to maintain a distinction between the state and the church. As Richard W. Garnett and Paul J. Schierl explain, the separation of church...
Community and Economic Development: Transforming Our Cities Through Love
Growing up impoverished in the Grand Rapids area himself, Justin Beene brings a unique perspective to his lecture on Community and Economic Development. He has seen first-hand the good intentions behind top-down investing to eliminate poverty and racial injustice, and the consequential damage wreaked upon munities. Urban cities have largely been developed through three forces: gentrification, pouring resources into them, munity development. Beene asserts that we need to cut off top-down funding and start supporting neighborhoods in solving their own...
Now Available: 92 Lectures from Acton University
We’re pleased to announce that we’ve added 92 lectures from Acton University 2016 to our digital download store! You can pick up the evening plenary lectures from Magatte Wade, Vernon Smith, William Allen, and Acton President Rev. Robert A. Sirico for free – and then select audio froma wide variety of speakers on a diverse range oftopics from the daily sessions, including addresses by intellectuals and experts like Michael Novak , Kim Tan, and Prof. Peter Kreeft, among others. Nobel...
What Would Happen If We ‘Forgive’ Student Loan Debt?
Student debt has e a hot issue this election season, with both Democratic candidates —Clinton and Sanders — offering proposals for forgiving student loans. But what would happen if the U.S. actually forgave student debt? Would the loans simply vanish? Would tuition prices decline? Economist Don Boudreauxexplains what really happens and why “debt forgiveness” merely transfers the debt to others. ...
Democratic Party Platform Draft Includes $15 Minimum Wage
Sometimes predicting the future is difficult (ask anyone who thought we’d have flying cars by now). But sometimes foreseeing what is going to happen — at least to a high degree of probability — is all too easy. For example, it’s fairly simple to ascertain that sometime in 2017 or 2018 we will see a huge spike in the unemployment for the working poor and increasing the replacement of low-skilled jobs with automation (i.e., robots). The reason: the $15 minimum...
Overproduction and stewardship
Overproduction, simply put, is supply in excess of demand. It is the production of more goods and services than those in the market would like to purchase.Overproduction, in a well functioning market economy, should be temporary.In a dynamic market driven by entrepreneurs,resources e allocated towards their most highly valued uses. If some clever entrepreneur makes a million shoes, but only sells two pairs, he will be unlikely to overproduce in the future. This is good, because the overproduction signals to...
How Kentucky Schools Are Rejecting the ‘College Readiness’ Cookie Cutter
Fueled by a mix of misguided cultural pressures and misaligned government incentives, college tuition has been rising for decades, outpacing general inflation by a wide margin. Yet despite the underlying problems, our politicians seem increasingly inclined to cement the status quo. Whether it beincreasedsubsidies for student loans or promises of“free college” for all, such solutions simply double down on our failedcookie-cutter approach to education and vocation, narrowing rather than expanding the range of opportunities and possibilities. Fortunately, despite such aninept...
For Girls, Sexual Abuse Is the Prison Pipeline
The current debate surrounding overcriminalization and juvenile incarceration is often centered around the male prison population. The debate increasingly overlooks the problems that face young girls caught in the prison pipeline to juvenile detention. New data in the past several years has shown that the prison pipeline for girls often includes a pattern of sexual abuse that is not present in cases involving male delinquents. A 2015 report published by Georgetown Law’s Center on Poverty and Inequality found that girls...
The School Suspension Quagmire
The harsh discipline policies at schools across the nation are now under close scrutiny. Last week, Secretary of Education John King criticized the ‘zero-tolerance’ discipline policies of many charter schools across the country. King claimed that plicated issues surrounding school discipline were being oversimplified into a binary process at many charter schools that led to a higher number of suspensions. This is a problem that exists across public, private, and charter schools around the country: students are suspended and expelled...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved