Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How to make America smart again
How to make America smart again
May 22, 2025 8:25 PM

Over the past week America has been fascinated and appalled by the latest college admissions cheating scandal. Much of the attention has been focused on the bribing of coaches to get kids into school with fake athletic credentials. But the even more absurd part of the scandal is that parents were paying between $15,000 and $75,000 per test to help their children get a better score on the SAT.

The parents seem to believe that the SAT was a mere hurdle to be e by whatever means necessary. Once the child was admitted to the college, they would be swept along into a life of wealth and prestige. That’s not entirely wrong, of course. As economist Bryan Caplan says, “If you can get your less-than-brilliant, less-than-driven child admitted, he’ll probably get to impersonate a standardly awesome Ivy League graduate for the rest of his life.”

It’s true there’s a correlation between scoring well on the SAT and getting into a good college, as well as a correlation between a college degree and social mobility. But the cheating parents seem to think there is a direct line between “score well on the SAT” and “economic security.” The reality is the test is a mere proxy. As the psychologist John Carroll once observed, the verbal SAT is essentially a test of “advanced vocabulary knowledge.”

Seven years ago the renowned educator E. D. Hirsch, Jr. pointed out that the “correlation between vocabulary size and life chances are as firm as any correlations in educational research.” As Hirsch adds,

Of course, vocabulary isn’t perfectly correlated with knowledge. People with similar vocabulary sizes may vary significantly in their talent and in the depth of their understanding. Nonetheless, there’s no better index to accumulated knowledge and petence than the size of a person’s vocabulary. Simply put: knowing more words makes you smarter.

We tend to equate “smart” with having a high IQ and assume it’s an innate and unchangeable characteristic. But the type of “smart” Hirsch is talking about—one that leads to economic success and general flourishing—can be increased though effort.

Rather than point to research that confirms this point, let me try to persuade you based on a natural experiment where I was the subject.

In January 1987, during my senior year of high school, I took the SAT and scored 620. While it was above the national average (507 at the time) it was well below what I needed to get into my preferred school (University of Texas). After graduation I went to the University of North Texas and—as my SAT score predicted—I floundered. After my first year, I dropped out and joined the Marines.

Thirteen years later I ended up taking the SAT test again. I was encouraging a few of my junior enlisted Marines to apply for missioning program, which required a qualifying score on the SAT. A few of the Marines were hesitant so to encourage them I agreed to help them study and take the test myself. When the results came back I found my math score was the same (terrible) but I had scored a perfect 800 on the verbal section.

Getting that score as a 31-year-old in his last year of college was less impressive than it would have been as a 17-year-old high school student. But it was still a drastic change. My IQ had not increased so what accounted for the difference? The answer, as Hirsch would say, was that the SAT was measuring my vocabulary, which had significantly expanded because I had read considerably more than I had in high school. While I had been an infrequent reader in my teens I became a voracious reader in my twenties (mostly out of boredom in the pre-Internet age).

Improving my score on the SAT didn’t help my life es. But the knowledge I acquired from reading allowed me to achieve considerably more with my modest intellect than would have otherwise been possible. Could the same process help others?

Hirsch believes it can, though it takes work. Those looking for a shortcut might think that vocabulary flashcards will lead to these cognitive gains. But Hirsch explains why a large vocabulary results not from memorizing word lists but from “acquiring knowledge about the social and natural worlds” and occurs through a method called “content-based instruction.”

The advantages of content-based instruction are enormous. One is that the topic itself is interesting, so the student has a strong motivation to understand what is being said or written. But an even more important advantage is that immersion in a topic provides the student with a referential and verbal context that is gradually made familiar, which encourages correct guesses of word meanings at a much more rapid pace than would be possible in an unfamiliar context. Psychologists refer to certain skills as being “domain-specific,” so perhaps a better name for content-based language acquisition would be “domain immersion.” The idea is to immerse students in a domain long enough to make them familiar with the context—and thus able to learn words faster.

This will be an unsurprising finding to any adults who have developed a field of expertise in their occupation or their hobbies. It also reveals why we don’t learn that much from our college experience: we simply aren’t immersed in a domain enough to understand its context.

Schools that do immerse their students in a subject improve their life es.Hirsch notes that the success of Catholic schools in raising all students, rich or poor, to high levels of achievement is largely attributed to their strong focus on subject-matter knowledge. “Many other factors were at work: discipline, focus, expectations, all the plexities that help determine school es,” says Hirsch. “But at the heart of the matter were the lessons themselves, which, in these Catholic schools, followed a cumulative sequence. The schools employed domain immersion avant la lettre.”

Hirsch concludes that by saying that it isn’t overstating the case to say that the “most secure way to predict whether an educational policy is likely to help restore the middle class is to focus on the question: Is this policy likely to expand the vocabularies of 12th-graders?”

Even if you’re well past 12 grade, you can still do your part to make America smarter. And you don’t need to wait for a change in educational policy to begin. You just need to do more reading.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
How Shall the Godly Respond to Passing on Affluence?
I love those who love me, and those who seek me find me. With me are riches and honor, enduring wealth and prosperity. My fruit is better than fine gold; what I yield surpasses choice silver. I walk in the way of righteousness, along the paths of justice, bestowing a rich inheritance on those who love me and making their treasuries full. Proverbs 8:17-21 The biblical wisdom literature makes it abundantly plain, as does the rest of the entire Bible,...
Biotechnology, Morality, and Human Dignity
I watched the 2006 film The Prestige (based on the 1995 book of the same name) over the weekend. The film does an excellent job of portraying plex relationship between the two main characters, Robert Angier (Hugh Jackman) and Alfred Borden (Christian Bale). These two men are stage illusionists or magicians (the name of the movie derives from the terms that the author gives the three essential part of any magic trick: the setup (pledge), the performance (turn) and the...
Free Trade: Latin America’s Last Hope?
Costa Rica’s voters ratified the Central American Free Trade Agreement, a sign of hope against a rising tide of populist, anti-trade sentiment in Latin America — and the United States. “In short, this is not the time for Latin America to abandon free trade agendas,” Gregg says. Read the mentary here. ...
WARC: Globalization is ‘Pernicious Form of Human Enslavement”
Related to Sam Gregg’s Acton Commentary today, “Free Trade: Latin America’s Last Hope?” I pass along this ENI news item: “Growing rich-poor gap is new ‘slavery’, say Protestant leaders.” Globalization and free trade are the causes of a new class of worldwide slavery, say the ecumenical officials. Citing the foundational 2004 Accra Confession, Rev. Clifton Kirkpatrick, the president of the World Alliance of Reformed Churches, says that “an even more pernicious form of human enslavement is being wrought on millions...
Gandalf in Brussels?
French president Nicholas Sarkozy has mended the formation of a “Council of the Wise,” which would have the task of “elaborating proposals for the future development of Europe.” A recent survey by the Bertelsmann Foundation finds a lot of support for the idea in France, the UK, and Germany. I suppose there are various ways to read this. One, hinted at by the survey story linked above, is that people in the EU are uneasy about the direction Europe is...
Karl Barth and the Jewish Question
Just over a year ago an article of mine was published, “The Aryan clause, the Confessing Church, and the ecumenical movement: Barth and Bonhoeffer on natural theology, 1933–1935,” Scottish Journal of Theology 59 (2006): 263-280. In this piece I argue that the basic theological disagreement between Karl Barth and Dietrich Bonhoeffer has to do with the former’s radical denial of natural theology. One of the three cases I examine is the exchange between the two theologians when the Aryan clause,...
Environmental Stewardship News Round-Up
The following items appear in the Cornwall Alliance for the Stewardship of Creation Newsletter, October 24, 2007: Cornwall’s Beisner and Care of Creation’s Brown Speak at Proclamation PCA The Cornwall Alliance’s Dr. E. Calvin Beisner and Care of Creation’s Rev. Ed Brown spoke as a panel on creation stewardship at Proclamation Presbyterian Church (PCA) in Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania, Sunday evening, October 14. Rev. Brown focused on theological foundations for creation stewardship. Dr. Beisner expressed wide agreement with those and then...
The Greenest Elephant
I’m endorsing Mike Huckabee for president over at The Evangelical Ecologist thanks to statements from him like this: There has been a perception that conservative Republicans do not care much for the environment or the protection and preservation of natural resources. I remind people that the very word “conservative” means that we are all about conserving things that are valuable and dear. Few things are more valuable to us than the natural resources that God created and gave to us...
Debate: Is Christianity the Problem?
On Saturday, October 27, at 7 p.m., BookTV (C-SPAN2) will air a taped Intercollegiate Studies Institute (ISI) cosponsored debate on the topic, “Is Christianity the Problem?” The debate (which occurred Monday) will feature the author of the book What’s So Great About Christianity, by Dinesh D’Souza, and Christopher Hitchens. Hitchens is the author of God is not Great. The debate will be moderated by Marvin Olasky, who is the editor in chief of WORLD magazine and a senior fellow at...
Bill Cosby Is Right, Again
Anthony Bradley offers a rave review of the new book published by Bill Cosby and Dr. Alvin Poussaint of Harvard Medical School, Come On People: On The Path From Victims to Victors. “Cosby and Poussaint remind us that black America’s hope for escape from abysmal self-destruction is moral formation — not government programs or blaming white people,” Bradley writes. Read the mentary here. ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved