Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Amy Coney Barrett could save America
How Amy Coney Barrett could save America
Mar 28, 2026 11:53 AM

Although Amy Coney Barrett has only been a Supreme Court justice for a matter of days, she has the potential to act as the harbinger of a renewed America. She is not only potentially a new role model for working women, but she may also serve as the apostle who introduces Americans to a refreshingly positive view of their own Constitution. In the process, she may reverse the nation’s headlong rush to embrace socialism.

With her unassailable credentials, personal popularity, and winsome persona, Justice Barrett (as we may now call her) represents what Noam Chomsky calls “the threat of a good example.” Such a respectable individual may induce impressionable young minds to entertain less-than-hostile thoughts about the U.S. Constitution – a document that then-Professor Barack Obama told public radio“reflectedthefundamental flaw of this countrythat continues to this day.”

“Nothing threatens the progressive project more than the existence of a Supreme Court that adheres to the Constitution,” wrote David Harsanyi at National Review. “It’s really that simple.” By definition, the Constitution necessarily forecloses efforts to “fundamentally transform America.” It rules out sweeping, top-down government programs financed by massive wealth redistribution. Thus, it – and its supporters – must go.

When allegations that ACB is a charismatic fanatic seeking to outlaw contraception fell flat, her opponents attempted to poison the well about her judicial philosophy: originalism. Sen. Angus King, an independent who caucuses with the Democrats, implied that originalism would outlaw interracial marriages (presumably like that of the court’s most prominent originalist, Clarence Thomas). Former Labor Secretary Robert Reich hinted that originalism considers “Black Americans to be 3/5 of a white person” – a libel as dated as it is erroneous. But no one equaled the rhetorical gales of Sen. Ed Markey, D-Mass., who fulminated:

Originalism is racist. Originalism is sexist. Originalism is homophobic. For originalists, LGBT stands for, “Let’s go back in time.” … Originalism is just a fancy word for discrimination.

Perhaps most ironically, Sen. Markey stated that originalism “has e a hazy smokescreen for judicial activism by so-called conservatives to achieve from the bench what they cannot plish through the ballot box.”

Amy Coney Barrett's nomination is illegitimate.

I vote no. /PHQZhbPduX

— Ed Markey (@SenMarkey) October 26, 2020

His words are the mirror image of reality. The secularization of U.S. public education, nationwide abortion-on-demand, redefining fundamental relationships, amending the 1964 Civil Rights Act to mercial activity involving sexuality or gender identity – none of these passed, or could have passed, Congress. “For the past 50 years, the Supreme Court has almost e an unchallengeable, unreviewable super-legislature,” said Tony Perkins, president of the Family Research Council, shortly after Barrett’s ascension to that court.

Recasting justices’ policy preferences as constitutional law is precisely what originalism seeks to prevent. As Barrett explained on the second day of her confirmation hearings:

I interpret the Constitution as a law, that I interpret its text as text and I understand it to have the meaning that it had at the time people ratified it. So that meaning doesn’t change over time. And it’s not up to me to update it or infuse my own policy views into it.

This is the interpretive method the founders expected their successors to use. As James Madison wrote, “In the exposition of laws, and even of Constitutions, how many important errors may be produced by mere innovations in the use of words and phrases, if not controlled by a recurrence to the original and authentic meaning attached to them!”

A predictable, stable, and impartial administration of the rule of law undergirds any successful nation. If the meaning of the law depends on whim, or is subject to deviation with each iteration of the court, chaos follows. Of what consequence is the legal doctrine of stare decisis if the Constitution itself remains infinitely elastic?

The sight of a woman being sworn in by an African American, however, proves our founding document is not inflexible nor wedded to discriminatory views of the past. The Constitution contained a self-correcting mechanism. The amendment process allowed the American people to create “a more perfect union” through the democratic process – one that requires a supermajority specifically to prevent a paper-thin majority from suppressing minority rights. In time, the American people recognized African Americans’ and women’s right to vote. They further swept artificial barriers into the dustbin of history by allowing more people to offer their God-given talents in a system of free and mutually beneficial exchange.

Generations of Americans have been denied this appreciation of America’s constitutional order. Academia ritually denounces our system as irredeemably racist, sexist, and corrupt. And recent surveys show that an overarchingly negative view of the United States correlates with a high level of support for socialism and Marxism.

The carefully chosen words that Amy Coney Barrett offered after she took her oath of office powerfully perforated our nation’s masochistic consensus. “I love the Constitution and the democratic republic that it establishes,” she said. “And I will devote myself to preserving it.”

At Notre Dame Law School, Barrett won the “Distinguished Professor of the Year” awardthree times. Her greatest teaching opportunity lies in front of her.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Rev. Sirico: Does Social Justice Require Socialism?
Acton Institute President and Co-Founder Rev. Robert A. Sirico recently delivered a talk on social justice and socialism at St. Thomas More Academy in Raleigh, N.C. The school’s mission is “dedicated to continuing the vital tradition of Catholic education by integrating the very best academic curriculum with the deepest spiritual wisdom of Catholic Christianity.” Rev. Sirico’s talk was part of the school’s Robert L. Luddy Speaker’s Series. Father Sirico at STMA from Randy Luddy on Vimeo. ...
NIV Stewardship Study Bible an ECPA Christian Book Award Finalist
Earlier this week the Evangelical Christian Publishers Association announced that the NIV Stewardship Study Bible was one of five finalists in the Bibles category for the 2010 Christian Book Awards. If you are like me, the question begs, “Exactly how many new Bibles are published every year?” That question is quickly followed by another, “How many Bibles does the Christian world need anyway?” You may or may not be surprised to know that there is a Bible for just about...
The Science of Stewardship
In this week’s Acton Commentary I examine some of the issues surrounding concern for our planet’s growing human population. In “The Science of Stewardship: Sin, Sustainability, and GM Foods,” I argue that increased food production, augmented by advances in genetic modification, has a key role to play in meeting the needs of future generations. And in this panies like Monsanto have contributed greatly to our ability to address the need for increased yields. They have done so in great measure...
Health Care Rights, and Wrongs
A mentary from Dr. Donald Condit. Also see the Acton Health Care resource page. +++++++++ Health Care Rights, and Wrongs By Dr. Donald P. Condit As Speaker Nancy Pelosi promoted passage of Sunday’s health care reform bill, she invoked Catholic support. However, those who assert the right to health care and seek greater responsibility for government as the means to that end, are simply wrong. This legislation fails port with Catholic social principles. Claiming an entity as a right requires...
Anthony Bradley interview: Tea Parties, Health Care, Black Liberation Theology
CBN News interviews Acton Research Fellow Anthony Bradley on “Theology, Politics & the African-American Community.” His new book, Liberating Black Theology — The Bible and the Black Experience in America, is now available from the Acton Book Shoppe. ...
Review: When Hell Was in Session
“We can add our testimony to that of great heroes like Solzhenitsyn and Sakharov, who have vividly related what Communism is really about.” – Admiral Jeremiah A. Denton, Jr. World Net Daily Books has republished the classic When Hell Was in Session, the chilling account of Admiral Jeremiah Denton’s almost eight years as a prisoner of war of the North Vietnamese (1965-1973). The book, cowritten with Ed Brandt, was reissued in November 2009 with a new epilogue. A naval aviator,...
Unbiblical Social Justice?
In a mentary, “Beck Vs. Wallis,” Acton Research Fellow Marvin Olasky takes another look at the dispute between Glenn Beck and Jim Wallis over the meaning of social justice. Olasky, provost at The King’s College in New York, offers suggestions on how to respond to those who would define social justice as merely the expansion of the welfare state. I can understand Glenn Beck’s frustration. As the Beck-Wallis tempest swirled on March 11, I spent 3½ hours in a long-arranged...
Orthodoxy & The Public Square
Over at Koinonia, Father Gregory Jensen looks at Frank Schaeffer’s vicious, bigoted attack on Robert George in Huffington Post. And George’s response in “Natural Law” and “far right Reconstructionist extremism!” on the Mirror of Justice blog. Fr. Gregory: As George argues in a 2006 essay, (Public Morality, Public Reason) like “devout Catholics, Protestants, Jews, and other believers,” Orthodox Christians find ourselves in a “contest of worldviews . . . against secularist liberals and those who, while remaining within the religious...
Psalm 94
During Holy Week many Christians supplement their religious observances. Some, continuing in a denial that marks Lent; and others choosing to add something to their life in Christ’s worship and ministry. One of the things one can add that for many is sadly not a staple of their daily life is morning and/or evening prayer. In the prayer book that Anglicans use there are many prayers and thanksgivings but on Wednesday I was drawn again to the one “for our...
Health Care ‘Reform’ And Unintended Consequences
Now that President Obama has signed into law the massive health care overhaul legislation that was passed by the House of Representatives on Sunday night, it’s time to start noting what will no doubt be a fantastic series of unintended consequences of the legislation. Granted, I could probably turn this into a regular feature on the PowerBlog, akin to my series of Global Warming Consensus Alert posts. But I have a feeling that documenting the ongoing degradation of the health...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved