Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
How Amy Coney Barrett could save America
How Amy Coney Barrett could save America
Jul 3, 2026 1:52 AM

Although Amy Coney Barrett has only been a Supreme Court justice for a matter of days, she has the potential to act as the harbinger of a renewed America. She is not only potentially a new role model for working women, but she may also serve as the apostle who introduces Americans to a refreshingly positive view of their own Constitution. In the process, she may reverse the nation’s headlong rush to embrace socialism.

With her unassailable credentials, personal popularity, and winsome persona, Justice Barrett (as we may now call her) represents what Noam Chomsky calls “the threat of a good example.” Such a respectable individual may induce impressionable young minds to entertain less-than-hostile thoughts about the U.S. Constitution – a document that then-Professor Barack Obama told public radio“reflectedthefundamental flaw of this countrythat continues to this day.”

“Nothing threatens the progressive project more than the existence of a Supreme Court that adheres to the Constitution,” wrote David Harsanyi at National Review. “It’s really that simple.” By definition, the Constitution necessarily forecloses efforts to “fundamentally transform America.” It rules out sweeping, top-down government programs financed by massive wealth redistribution. Thus, it – and its supporters – must go.

When allegations that ACB is a charismatic fanatic seeking to outlaw contraception fell flat, her opponents attempted to poison the well about her judicial philosophy: originalism. Sen. Angus King, an independent who caucuses with the Democrats, implied that originalism would outlaw interracial marriages (presumably like that of the court’s most prominent originalist, Clarence Thomas). Former Labor Secretary Robert Reich hinted that originalism considers “Black Americans to be 3/5 of a white person” – a libel as dated as it is erroneous. But no one equaled the rhetorical gales of Sen. Ed Markey, D-Mass., who fulminated:

Originalism is racist. Originalism is sexist. Originalism is homophobic. For originalists, LGBT stands for, “Let’s go back in time.” … Originalism is just a fancy word for discrimination.

Perhaps most ironically, Sen. Markey stated that originalism “has e a hazy smokescreen for judicial activism by so-called conservatives to achieve from the bench what they cannot plish through the ballot box.”

Amy Coney Barrett's nomination is illegitimate.

I vote no. /PHQZhbPduX

— Ed Markey (@SenMarkey) October 26, 2020

His words are the mirror image of reality. The secularization of U.S. public education, nationwide abortion-on-demand, redefining fundamental relationships, amending the 1964 Civil Rights Act to mercial activity involving sexuality or gender identity – none of these passed, or could have passed, Congress. “For the past 50 years, the Supreme Court has almost e an unchallengeable, unreviewable super-legislature,” said Tony Perkins, president of the Family Research Council, shortly after Barrett’s ascension to that court.

Recasting justices’ policy preferences as constitutional law is precisely what originalism seeks to prevent. As Barrett explained on the second day of her confirmation hearings:

I interpret the Constitution as a law, that I interpret its text as text and I understand it to have the meaning that it had at the time people ratified it. So that meaning doesn’t change over time. And it’s not up to me to update it or infuse my own policy views into it.

This is the interpretive method the founders expected their successors to use. As James Madison wrote, “In the exposition of laws, and even of Constitutions, how many important errors may be produced by mere innovations in the use of words and phrases, if not controlled by a recurrence to the original and authentic meaning attached to them!”

A predictable, stable, and impartial administration of the rule of law undergirds any successful nation. If the meaning of the law depends on whim, or is subject to deviation with each iteration of the court, chaos follows. Of what consequence is the legal doctrine of stare decisis if the Constitution itself remains infinitely elastic?

The sight of a woman being sworn in by an African American, however, proves our founding document is not inflexible nor wedded to discriminatory views of the past. The Constitution contained a self-correcting mechanism. The amendment process allowed the American people to create “a more perfect union” through the democratic process – one that requires a supermajority specifically to prevent a paper-thin majority from suppressing minority rights. In time, the American people recognized African Americans’ and women’s right to vote. They further swept artificial barriers into the dustbin of history by allowing more people to offer their God-given talents in a system of free and mutually beneficial exchange.

Generations of Americans have been denied this appreciation of America’s constitutional order. Academia ritually denounces our system as irredeemably racist, sexist, and corrupt. And recent surveys show that an overarchingly negative view of the United States correlates with a high level of support for socialism and Marxism.

The carefully chosen words that Amy Coney Barrett offered after she took her oath of office powerfully perforated our nation’s masochistic consensus. “I love the Constitution and the democratic republic that it establishes,” she said. “And I will devote myself to preserving it.”

At Notre Dame Law School, Barrett won the “Distinguished Professor of the Year” awardthree times. Her greatest teaching opportunity lies in front of her.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Why Europe’s churches are under attack
For many people of faith, especially Catholics and Orthodox Christians, churches are sacred places. An older cathedral, for example, is not a museum nor merely a relic of the past, but rather a place where it is believed that grace is given through sacraments, a place where God dwells. But, as Samuel Gregg argues in Spectator USA, Europe has lost respect for places of worship, a loss felt tangibly by the Church. “In 2017 alone, according to France’s Interior Ministry,...
Acton Line podcast: Behind China’s drive for global domination
During Christmastime in China in 2015, 1,700 churches were torn down or vandalized, a result of the Chinese government growing increasingly hostile to Christianity. In 2018, The Chinese government raided and shut down churches ahead of Christmas and detained pastors and members caught celebrating. From reports of labor camps in the country to growing surveillance through technology, China is increasingly cracking down on freedom. This is all laid out in a new book, titled Deceiving the Sky: Inside Communist China’s...
The musical entrepreneurship behind the ‘Hallelujah’ Chorus
Although it was intended to be an position, the “Hallelujah” Chorus from Handel’s Messiah has e the musical diadem of the Christmas season. It has already in early January vanished from the radio, because the modern West pre-celebrates all its holidays. (The Christmas season traditionally spans the “12 days of Christmas,” from December 25 until the feast of Epiphany on January 6.) However, it never would have graced the most joyous season of the year without the entrepreneurial spirit of...
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: the universality of the Nativity scene
Some weeks ago I met with a priest named Fr. Mike at his office in the local Curia. He is a well-trained lawyer who is now in charge of civil legal affairs for one of the largest Catholic dioceses in Europe. His work deals with donations, inheritances, real estate, and the like. Several ideas from that conversation are still fresh in my mind. One of aspect of our conversation dealt with Fr. Mike’s workload. When I saw the pile of...
Gertrude Himmelfarb (1922-2019): The historian of moral revolution
I just heard some devastating news. Gertrude Himmelfarb, historian, moralist, wife, and mother, has passed. David Brooks has written a touching obituary detailing the life and legacy of this fascinating woman: Economists measure economic change and journalists describe political change, but who captures moral change? Who captures the shifts in manners, values, and mores, how each era defines what is admirable and what is disgraceful? Gertrude Himmelfarb, who died at 97 last night, made this her central concern. She was...
Did Domino’s exploit you by selling $30 pizzas on New Year’s Eve in Times Square?
New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio began 2020, the year he intended to e president, by asserting that Domino’s Pizza “exploited” New Year’s Eve revelers in Times Square by selling pizzas for $30 apiece. But was the mayor’s hot take on the extra dough fresh? In his first original tweet of the year, Mayor de Blasio referred to a New York Post story about this franchise’s 15-year-old tradition of delivering pizzas to the crowd. “Jacking up your prices on...
10 economic lessons from ‘Emmett Otter’s Jugband Christmas’
Jim Henson’s beloved Emmett Otter’s Jugband Christmas first entered the hearts of Canadian children in December 1977 and made its U.S. debut on HBO one year later. The musical Muppet adventure tells the story of widow Alice Otter and her tenderhearted son, Emmett, who decide the only way they can afford Christmas presents this year is to win a petition – with an exacting entrance fee. Aside from its entertainment value – including a posed by songwriter Paul Williams –...
The state of human freedom in 2019
Did liberty increase or decrease in each nation, and globally, in 2019? How has the last decade impacted freedom around the world? The Cato Institute measures the freedom of each nation in the world and publishes the results. “The Human Freedom Index 2019,” written by Ian Vásquez and Tanja Porčnik, ranked 162 countries – and the results are mixed. “The jurisdictions that took the top 10 places, in order, were New Zealand, Switzerland, Hong Kong, Canada, Australia, Denmark and Luxembourg...
Star Wars and self-interest
Recent installments in the Star Wars universe directly raise the theme of self-interest, and specifically the formation or deformation of the self. These instances help us ask the important question, “Who puts the ‘self’ in self-interest?” [Mild spoilers: If you are not current on The Mandalorian or haven’t seen The Rise of Skywalker, you may want to flag this post e back later.] In the season finale of The Mandalorian, we get a pretty full introduction to Moff Gideon, the...
The gift of the Incarnation
All of life is God’s gracious gift. This graciousness applies not only to ourselves and our neighbors, each of whom is made in His image and likeness, but applies as well to the whole of creation which was entrusted to the human family’s care and cultivation (Gen. 1:26-31). This gracious gift, both of ourselves and the creation, was marred by our own disobedience, born of ingratitude, and resulted in our separation from that gracious Giver. Sin and death are the...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved