Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
‘Global trade is not a gunfight at the O.K. Corral’
‘Global trade is not a gunfight at the O.K. Corral’
Jul 3, 2025 8:11 AM

Some mental images are especially vivid. One phrase stands out in the war of words preceding the brewing U.S.-EU trade war. “Global trade is not a gunfight at the O.K. Corral,” said French finance minister Bruno Le Maire last Thursday, after President Trump imposed new tariffs on steel and aluminum.

The most famous shoot-out in the Old West has been immortalized in the 1957 film of the same name, as well as numerous other Hollywood vehicles. To my mind, none captured the sheer brutality of the firefight as well as Doc, starring Stacy Keach (who gave a captivating performance in what was an otherwise middling film). The massacre lived up to Hobbes’ view of life: nasty, brutish, and short.

We may hope the trade war with the EU and our NAFTA trading partners will likewise be brief. In March, President Trump imposed 25 percent tariffs on imported steel and 10 percent on aluminum on the grounds of national security, largely aimed at Chinese excess capacity. Last week, he extended the import taxes to the EU, Canada, and Mexico.

Le Maire pledged that the European response would be “united and firm.” The EU and Canada will place reciprocal tariffs – and then some – on U.S. imports beginning no later than July 1; Mexico already has retaliated.

“We will also impose import tariffs,” said European Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker in March. “This is basically a stupid process – the fact that we have to do this – but … we can also do stupid.”

Others have picked up Le Maire’s martial metaphor. “Guns should be pointed at enemies, not at allies,” said Obama’s ambassador to the EU, Anthony Gardner.

One of the leading arguments offered for freer trade is that lower trade barriers lessen other international tensions. Calling a truce in the trade wars decreases the chance of shooting wars. “[T]rade motives are essential to avoiding wars and sustaining stable networks,” wrote Stanford professor Matthew O. Jackson and Stephen Nei.

If nations pursue parative advantage and goods move across borders with relatively little friction, the argument goes, then nations will see one another as partners and think twice before launching a war that will cost them imports and e. “[T]he larger the trade gains, the larger the opportunity cost of a war and therefore the more useful a FTA [free trade agreement] is to secure peace,” wrote European scholars Philippe Martin,Thierry Mayer, and Mathias Thoenig in 2010.

A few have even connected trade to the most cherished rule of Christianity. Condy Raguet, a U.S. diplomat to Brazil under President John Quincy Adams, said the golden rule applies to international trade as much as to interpersonal conduct.

“It is to us one of the most prehensible things that so many persons, who profess to be advocates of religion and good will to man, should be the disciples of a philosophy which teaches that the selfish principle is paramount to the principle of neighbourly love,” he wrote.

He continued:

Now what does the restrictive philosophy teach? Why, that individuals, pursuing particular branches of industry, should consult their own interests, without any regard whatever to the interests of their neighbours; that sections or districts of country should unite together in a scheme calculated to render others tributary to them; and, carrying the principle still further out, that nations should study their own selfish interests, without regard to the interests of other nations. The consequences of such a course of conduct cannot be other than to produce private enmities and heart-burnings between those who benefit and those who suffer, as is visible, every day, to our own eyes – civil war between different sections of the same country, as we may see before another year – and foreign wars of which we have witnessed an abundance within the last half-century, growing out mercial restrictions. If it were true that the Christian religion enjoined one sort of duty from man to man, and another sort of duty from nation to nation, there might be some ground for the adoption of one rule as applicable to one case, and another rule as applicable to the other. But no distinction is made between them, and peace on earth, and good will to men, are every where inculcated.

One can hope all weapons in the trade war will be holstered soon, and the transatlantic may e pacific again.

Silvercloud. CC BY-SA 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Careful what you wish for….
Via Drudge, Australia is joining none other than China in censoring the internet. Here’s a surprising endorsement/justification the writer uses to bottom line the article: The Australian Christian Lobby, however, has ed the proposals. Managing director Jim Wallace said the measures were needed. "The need to prevent access to illegal hard-core material and child pornography must be placed above the industry’s desire for unfettered access," Mr Wallace said. I’m not endorsing porn. But earth to Mr. Wallace: Scan up a...
Birth of Freedom Shorts Series: Is it appropriate to consider the religious views of political candidates?
Acton Media’s latest Birth of Freedom short video is a timely message in the face of tomorrow’s election. In this video, William B. Allen, Professor of Political Science at Michigan State University, discusses how faith, “the pelling part of one’s existence”, ought to fit in when evaluating a political candidate. Check out more Birth of Freedom shorts, learn about premieres in your area, and discover more background information at . ...
Doctoral Work on Religion and Philanthropy
I received this notice via H-Net last week: THE LAKE INSTITUTE ON FAITH & GIVING THE CENTER ON PHILANTHROPY INDIANA UNIVERSITY DOCTORAL DISSERTATION FELLOWSHIP The Lake Institute on Faith and Giving at the Center on Philanthropy, Indiana University will offer a one year doctoral dissertation fellowship of $22,000 for the academic year 2009-2010. This doctoral dissertation fellowship will be given to a scholar whose primary research focus is in the area of religion and philanthropy or faith and giving. The...
Why Not Learn Some Economics First?
According to a report from the Zenit News Service, Cardinal Renato Martino, president of the Pontifical Council of Justice and Peace, recently insisted that the “logic” of the market be changed. He said that the logic “was till (sic) now that of maximum gain, and therefore the most investments possible directed toward obtaining maximum benefit. And this, according to the social doctrine of the Church, is immoral.” This is because, according to the Cardinal, the market “should be able to...
Left Behind
Obama won’t get the mainlineEvangelical vote. Will McCain? I doubt it. UPDATE: More here. EPILOGUE: Here’s an astute observation from a progressive blogger last week. One underdiscussed scenario in this election is the one wherein Republican base turnout is relatively low. Although this has generally been an engaging election with engaging candidates, the base remains considerably less enthusiastic about John McCain than it was about George W. Bush, and McCain is also lacking Bush’s ground game. While the natural assumption...
Busted
The lyrics to “Busted,” written by Harlan Howard, and made famous as performed by Johnny Cash: My bills are all due and the babies need shoes, But I’m Busted Cotton’s gone down to a quarter a pound And I’m Busted I got a cow that’s gone dry And a hen that won’t lay A big stack of bills Getting bigger each day The county’s gonna haul my belongings away, But I’m Busted So I called on my brother to ask...
Update: Acton Video Short Gathers Attention
First posted on the PowerBlog by Brittany Hunter, and picked up by a number of other prominent blogs, the “How Not to Help the Poor” Acton video short has collected over eight thousand YouTube hits. The video has only been on the YouTube site for just over a couple of weeks. The clip is from the Acton Institute’s Effective Stewardship Curriculum titled “Fellow Man.” Andrew Sullivan at The Daily Dish also posted mented on “How Not to Help the Poor”...
Election Preaching
The election day sermon was an important institution in colonial New England. It was one delivered by Samuel Danforth in 1670 that furnished the venerable Puritan concept of America as an “errand into the wilderness.” (For more, see Nathan Hatch, The Democratization of American Christianity.) One need not share the Massachusetts colony’s view of church-state relations (one of the chief tasks of government was the suppression of heresy) to recognize that the election day sermon served a useful purpose. The...
Future Farming Facts
From the latest issue of Wired… Illustration by Dan ...
Baby Stepping Toward the Nanny State
Is Senator Obama a closet socialist waiting for inauguration day, at which time he and a Democratic Congress will immediately pursue a massive increase in the size and power of government in our lives, panied by massive tax increases and massive redistribution of wealth? Or is he really a moderate pragmatist, a canny politician who when he was getting started in politics used his radical contacts from his ultra-leftwing Hyde munity, but now is in a position to use more...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved