Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Freedom and free stuff: How prudence preserves liberty
Freedom and free stuff: How prudence preserves liberty
Aug 26, 2025 2:04 AM

Is it possible for a government to respect economic freedom while also playing a more or less significant role in providing certain material goods to its citizens? Prudence provides an answer.

Read More…

What is the relationship between freedom and government redistribution? Can the two coexist?

Some believe there is a negative correlation between the two because free economies are often associated with less government intervention. Others might argue that freedom and significant state intervention go hand in hand, because a strong government is necessary to protect property rights and standards of social welfare increase as countries get wealthier (and countries that are economically free are typically wealthier).

It turns out that the answer is plicated.

For example, Singapore and the United States both consistently rank high on The Heritage Foundation’s Index of Economic Freedom, an annual review of sovereign states and their economic freedom based on 12 different indicators. In 2021, Singapore ranked first, with the United States close behind in 20th place.

Yet their approaches to the government’s role in health care coverage are significantly different.

Singapore has universal health care coverage through a three-pronged approach called the 3Ms. MediShield Life consists of basic health insurance, which covers costly medical bills. It is subsidized based on personal e and is mandatory for all citizens and permanent residents. MediSave offers an account for personal and employer contributions, which is used to cover out-of-pocket health care expenses. For those unable to cover their out-of-pocket health care expenses with MediSave, the government provides a safety net through MediFund.

The United States does not have universal health care coverage, but it does provide three programs to govern health care costs for select groups. Medicare offers universal free health care for the elderly (those above the age of 65). Medicaid offers free health care for the poor and disabled. The Children’s Health Insurance Program provides free insurance for children, specifically those whose families do not qualify for Medicaid.

What explains the difference in their approaches to health care, when these countries have very similar rankings on economic freedom? The answer is prudence.

In his book On Ordered Liberty, Samuel Gregg follows the thought of medieval philosopher St. Thomas Aquinas, arguing that mon good of the state “is instrumental inasmuch as it is directed to assisting the integral fulfillment of persons.”

“One way of prudentially discerning the role of State institutions in a given situation is to ask ourselves what the State can generally do well and what it cannot,” writes Gregg. “This may be determined by identifying the deficiencies of other groups and asking when no munity, save the State, is able to render the assistance that will remedy the deficiency until the wanting social organization can reassume its appropriate role.”

Differences in cultures and norms between different nations result in different situations, which, in accordance with the virtue of prudence, may mean that different entities (such as the state, employers, family, etc.) may contribute to providing material welfare for human persons in different ways. Governments can do this while still respecting the many aspects which are essential to the fulfillment of persons based on the natural law, and thus are essential to the mon good (e.g., private property rights sustained by the rule of law, which are a part of economic freedom).

Thus, it is possible for a government to respect economic freedom and human flourishing while also playing a more or less significant role in providing certain material goods to its citizens. The imperative to allow for the flourishing of persons necessarily rules out many kinds of regimes and policies which are patible with human nature, such munism or nationalist socialism.

However, there is a wide range of regimes and policies which patible with human nature, and these can be considered and adopted while still respecting human flourishing.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Unemployment as economic-spiritual indicator — January 2018 report
Series Note: Jobs are one of the most important aspects of a morally functioning economy. They help us serve the needs of our neighbors and lead to human flourishing both for the individual and munities. Conversely, not having a job can adversely affect spiritual and psychological well-being of individuals and families. Because unemployment is a spiritual problem, Christians in America need to understand and be aware of the monthly data on employment. Each month highlight the latest numbers we need...
Merkel makes her move: What will her coalition look like?
Four months after Angela Merkel won a fourth term as chancellor of Germany, her allies have announced they finally expect to form a governing coalition this weekend, which will spare the nation a potential political collapse. At Religion & Liberty Transtatlantic, Mark Royce removes the reader’s uncertainty about this confusing situation, as Merkel’s putatively Christian and free market party prepares to align itself with its more secular, petitor. The two parties have already enacted important economic, environmental, and immigration policies...
4 lessons on Christian vocation in politics from Gov. Bill Haslam
In our explorations of Christian vocation, the faith-and-work movement has been largely successful in reminding us of the meaning and purpose of our work, from parenting in the home to manual labor in the fields to teaching in a school to trading on Wall Street. But amid those discussions, there’s still an area we tend to forget and neglect: politics. Can an institution that wields such power really be seen through the lens of Christian calling? Sure, we may be...
5 Facts about National Freedom Day
In the United States February 1 is National Freedom Day. Here are five facts you should know about the annual observance: 1. National Freedom memorates the date (February 1, 1865) when President Abraham Lincoln signed a joint resolution that proposed the 13th amendment to the United States Constitution. The amendment states that “Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted, shall exist within the United States, or any place...
Religion & Liberty: Growing pains in the romance lands
For our first issue of 2018, the R&L editorial board wanted to put together a very special “green” issue. We traveled across the country and talked to many experts to bring you essays, interviews, reviews and more, focusing on the environment, good stewardship and the importance of property rights. “Marotz-Baden Ranch” by John Couretas For the cover story, Director of Communications John Couretas and I ventured to Bozeman, Montana, and Yellowstone National Park. In “Growing pains in the Romance Lands,”...
Book Review: ‘Courage to Grow, How Acton Academy Turns Learning Upside Down’
Book Review: Courage to Grow, How Acton Academy Turns Learning Upside Down by Laura A. Sandefer I arrived at Amtrak’s Union Station from Kansas City at exactly 6:45 a.m. and stood in line waiting to board the 7:45 train to Grand Rapids, Michigan. I stood behind a rather large Amish family with seven or eight children. They graciously moved over so I could sit beside them on the bench. Over the next half hour, we were informed through several announcements...
What would John Dewey do about automation?
“If you know the name John Dewey, you may associate him with the decline of American education,”says Winston Brady in this week’s Acton Commentary. “Many believe that the absence of intellectual rigor and the lack of responsibility in schools can be blamed on Dewey, who has been called the ‘father of progressive education.’” It’s easy for conservatives to dismiss someone described as the “father” of anything progressive, but it may be worthwhile to reconsider John Dewey (1859-1952) in light of...
4 freedoms that affect your right to vote (and 1 that doesn’t)
This week marks the 100th anniversary of women’s suffrage in the UK. Just before the centenary, the Foundation for the Advancement of Liberty evaluated each nation’s electoral system in its first-ever World Electoral Freedom Index. It found that four separate freedoms correlate with a nation having free and honest elections. The report analyzed ponents of electoral laws, broken down into four categories: a nation’s political development, freedom to vote, ability to run for office, and the extent voters could hold...
What we get wrong about technology
When asked to think about how new inventions might shape the future, says economist Tim Hartford, our imaginations tend to leap to technologies that are sophisticated prehension. But the reality is that most influential new technologies are often humble and cheap and new inventions do not appear in isolation: To understand how humble, cheap inventions have shaped today’s world, picture a Bible — specifically, a Gutenberg Bible from the 1450s. The dense black Latin script, packed into twin blocks, makes...
David Bentley Hart’s new testament to class envy
David Bentley Hart’s idiosyncratic translation of the New Testament has brought new scrutiny to his theological and economic views. Hart has written extensively of his rejection of Augustinian “election” – a view that, according to N.T. Wright, affects his rendering of the Christian Scriptures. However, Hart promotes a nearly Manichean dichotomy between rich and poor. In the pages of First Things, Hart has argued that the New Testament regards wealth – the abundance of creation – as an “intrinsic evil,”...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved