Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Finally, A Monument to Calvin Coolidge
Finally, A Monument to Calvin Coolidge
Jun 7, 2025 9:44 AM

Today, career politicians are out of fashion. In light of Washington’s dysfunction and a hyper partisan culture, the words of politicians offer little reassurances. Their deeds even less. One career public servant is finding his popularity on an upswing exactly eighty years after his death. I asked my grandfather, who turns 97 in July, to rank America’s great presidents? He immediately answered Ronald Reagan, almost reflexively. And then paused for a few moments and declared, “That Calvin Coolidge fellow was good too.”

To remember Coolidge is to remember an altogether different America. One that was rapidly modernizing but still deeply connected to rural life and its foundations. But even for his era, John Calvin Coolidge was a throw back, a man who emerged deep from within Vermont’s rugged hills. The symbols of his humble origins were magnified after the unexpected death of President Warren G. Harding in 1923. Coolidge, awakened in Vermont, was immediately sworn in to the greatest office in the world by kerosene lamp by his father, a public notary.

Oft forgotten or lampooned as a “simpleton,” there are no grand monuments for America’s 30th president. He certainly wouldn’t have sought such recognition. But in Coolidge by Amity Shlaes, she offers a kind of monument not just to Coolidge’s economic heroism, but his character.

Coolidge governed and taught from the deep well of America’s Founding and eschewed the material for the spiritual, declaring, “The things of the e first.” He was leery of progressive schemes saying, “Men do not make laws. They do but discover them.” He added, “If we wish to erect new structures, we must have a definite knowledge of the old foundations.”

Coolidge began his career from the humble origins befitting him, as a small town country lawyer. He studied for the bar in a law office, not a law school, which were surging in popularity during his time. But he would go on to dedicate himself to a lifetime of public service as a mayor, state legislator, Lt. Governor, Governor, and President. He understood power and continually warned against its corruption, much like Lord Acton, as Shlaes points out in her biography with a Coolidge quote. “It is difficult for men in high office to avoid the malady of self-delusion. They are always surrounded by worshipers. They are constantly, and for the most part sincerely, assured of their greatness,” said the president.

Coolidge is chiefly known for his deft handling of the Boston Police Strike in 1919, his government cutting, pro-growth, and tax slashing policies as president, and for his moniker “Silent Cal.” One of the misconceptions Shlaes puts to rest in her book is the perception that Coolidge slept away the presidency or was a disinterested overseer. He was famously derided by H.L. Mencken with the line, “Nero fiddled, but Coolidge only snored.” Coolidge’s effort to limit government, by shrinking it, was deeply deliberative and a constant battle. It has not been done since. His speech was deliberate too, much of what he said and plished was silenced by his detractors with the tidal wave of progressivism and the centralization of federal power that soon followed.

In the first sentence of her book, Shlaes declares, “Debt takes its toll.” The connection of where we are today and the debt that hampered America after World War I are obvious. Debt has taken its toll on America, and worse, we have yet to truly feel the looming pain and bankruptcy of America’s overspending. We lack leaders of character willing to rectify the crisis and ambivalence among the American people monplace. Debt is now a permanent way of life for most Americans. Old time thrift and its virtues are nostalgic and for many just another romanticized value from America’s forgotten past.

Perhaps one of the biggest indictments upon our society today is the quick assumption that the old way of doing things is stale or inferior. Coolidge reminds us so often of the fallacy of that line of thinking. On the progressive dream to reshape society he believed it was impossible to progress beyond America’s founders. “Their ideas are not more modern, but more ancient, than those of the Revolutionary fathers,” declared Coolidge.

Shlaes offers a rich look at the life of a leader who charted a far different course for our economic crisis and ills. Coolidge left office at the peak of his popularity. His popularity is surging today because even though he spent a lifetime in government, he did not enrich himself from it or cling to power. He spoke with an almost unusual but refreshing clarity about America and its ideals. While Americans face massive centralization of power, debt, and looming economic bankruptcy, Shlaes most importantly, in telling Coolidge’s story, reminds us it doesn’t have to be this way.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Audio: Gregg on the Modern Papacy, Miller on Conscience Protection
A couple of Acton radio appearances to let you know about: First of all, Acton’s Director of Research Dr. Samuel Gregg joined host Al Kresta yesterday to discuss the modern papacy on Kresta in the Afternoon. He focused on the social and political thought of Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI. You can listen to the interview by using the audio player below: [audio: Additionally, Acton’s Director of Media Michael Matheson Miller provided some mentary on the controversy surrounding...
More on Obamacare and the Catholic Bishops
Following my blog post and Acton News and Commentary piece “Obama vs. the Catholic Bishops,” I’d like to draw your attention to two Wall Street Journal editorial page articles in today’s edition that also criticize the bishops for their political and economic naivete. WSJ columnist Daniel Henninger writes: Politically bloodless liberals would respond that, net-net, government forcings do much social good despite breaking a few eggs, such as the Catholic Church’s First Amendment sensibilities. That is one view. But the...
‘Comprehensive Reflection on the Human Good’
Joe Knippenberg raises a couple of important points over at the First Things site in response to my post earlier today about the relationship between conservatism and libertarianism. First, he questions the validity of my “distinction between political philosophy and worldview.” Second, he questions “the place of liberty as our highest political good.” I’ve posted ment over there that deals with, in part, Lord Acton’s identification of liberty as man’s highest political end. Check out Joe’s post and the ongoing...
Bruce Springsteen’s Charity Bawl
While reading the Wall Street Journal not so long ago, I came across an article and two opinion pieces that, each in their way, told a story far different than one rendered in Bruce Springsteen’s ing album, Wrecking Ball. At first listening, Springsteen’s “We Take Care of Our Own” chugs along with some of the best of the Boss’ rock anthems. But the song’s lyrics convey a deeply cynical despair about our nation’s charitable nature. Springsteen says we in the...
Report: Economic experts blast revised HHS mandate
On Jan. 20, Health and Human Services (HHS) Secretary Kathleen Sebelius ordered most employers and insurers to provide contraceptives, sterilization, and abortifacient drugs (the “morning after” pill) free of charge under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act. Yesterday, President Obama — reacting to a firestorm of criticism that this new mandate violates freedom of religion and conscience protections — announced promise that shifted the cost of the mandate to insurers. That, however, has done little to allay fears about...
A Receding Voice: A Century of Methodist Political Pronouncements
Methodism was once the largest denomination in America. The faith grew rapidly from America’s beginning and has traditionally been characterized by aggressive evangelism and revival. It has carried a vibrant social witness, too. Methodist Church pronouncements once garnered front page headlines in The New York Times. Its high water mark undoubtedly came during prohibition, the greatest modern political cause of the denomination. Methodists even built and staffed a lobbying building next to Capitol Hill believing a dry country could remake...
Catholic High School Honor Roll – an announcement
The Catholic High School Honor Roll, a biennial list of America’s top 50 Catholic high schools, will now be sponsored by The Cardinal Newman Society, beginning with the 2012-13 Honor Roll application period. The Acton Institute, which has sponsored the Honor Roll since its inception in 2004, is turning the program over to The Cardinal Newman Society. “It has been gratifying to see how the Catholic High School Honor Roll has grown to be a reliable standard for faithful Catholic...
The Future of Fusionism
As promised in the context of yesterday’s discussion here and at First Thoughts, my piece on the future of fusionism is up over at the Comment site, “Small is Beautiful (Except When it Isn’t.)” I take my point of departure in the “crunchy” or munitarian” conservatism of Rod Dreher, recently profiled by the NYT’s David Brooks. My basic point is that the social munitarian conservatives generally have a great deal to learn about economics and the way that economic development...
Daniel Hannan’s Caveat to America
Daniel Hannan, aBritish Member of the European Parliament, issued a strong warning to conservative Americans worried about their country’s future in a speech he delivered at the CPAC rally last week in Washington. The self-proclaimed Euroskeptic and author of The New Road to Serfdom,warned U.S. political conservatives not to follow in Europe’s tragic footsteps by allowing their governments to seize too much power and create dependency on mismanaged socialized government programs — the very Welfare State culture that has a...
Libertarianism and the Conservative Movement
Yesterday AEI hosted a lively discussion between Jonah Goldberg and Matt Welch on the question, “Are Libertarians Part of the Conservative Movement?” I’ve got a piece appearing tomorrow at Comment that will discuss the “fusionist” project and the relationship between so-called economic or “market” conservatives and social or munitarian” conservatives. At this point, though, I’ll simply point out a distinction I’ve made in the past between libertarianism as a political philosophy and libertarianism as a world-and-life view. The former, I...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved