Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY
/
Ethics and the job market
Ethics and the job market
Jul 2, 2025 1:04 AM

The job market e under pressure of late as the economic shake-up continues. We are reminded that the world of the past, in which workers held one job their entire lives and slowly ascended the corporate ladder until retiring plete security, no longer exists. This is probably a good thing to the extent that it represents a new economic vibrancy. In the world of economics, another name plete security is economic stagnation.

Still, changing jobs can introduce great challenges in a person's life. Internal family pressures increase, and there are many opportunities for despair and recrimination. This is where economics and ethics meet. So let's examine the nature of the wage contract to see what it is that people owe each other.

For an employee to force an employer to continue in a contract is not morally different from an employer who forces an employee to work against his or her will. We rightly look at the latter case as a form of servitude. Slave labor is something condemned by everyone all over the world. Well, the other side of the coin is that it is equally a form of slavery to demand that employers be forced to pay employees who are not contributing requisite value to the firm. Like dancing the tango, the employment contract takes two parties to make it happen in a way that is profitable for everyone.

There are good and bad ways to go about reducing the size of a firm's work force, just like there are good and bad ways to quit your job. It is customary to give two weeks notice, for example, and it makes good sense to prepare the way for your successor. Contracts must be kept. This is not only the decent thing to do; it is also good for the reputation of the employee for the future.

It is the same with employers. Wholesale firings do not take into account the well-being of the employees raise ethical concerns. They also hurt the reputation of the business firm. No one wants to work for a business that treats its employees callously. The forces for reputation are so powerful here that there is not a need for government regulation. Government regulations only end up reducing the flexibility of all parties and raise their own ethical issues.

What needs to be avoided is precisely what the law seems to encourage these days: acts of vengeance by the employee against the former employer. These can take the form of lawsuits, smears, attacks, and other attempts to somehow punish the employer for failing to continue the contract. These are not only counterproductive; they feed an inappropriate form of resentment that can be spiritually and psychologically injurious. We must remember that the work contract is one of mutual agreement. Both parties are benefactors of the other. In Dante's vision of hell, the people who are treated worst are those who betray their benefactors. This applies equally to the employer who betrays the employee, and the worker who would seek reprisal against the employer who trusted the worker to pursue the best interests of the firm.

Tight labor markets are more than a macroeconomic phenomenon. They profoundly affect human lives. Sadly, the conditions tempt people to impose coercive interventions to affect certain results. But we all have an interest in keeping labor markets fluid and free. This is what is best for everyone in the long run.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY
Bioethics and the Human Person: God in the Machine
Rebecca Brown begins a 2019 essay “Philosophy Can Make the Previously Unthinkable Thinkable” by explaining the Overton window of political possibilities. Joseph Overton proposed the idea that think tanks should be designed to question the received opinion in both academia and the public regarding certain public policy issues. Think tanks could shift the window of possibilities, making the unthinkable thinkable. Brown’s point is that philosophers should take a page out of Overton’s strategy. Philosophers are particularly situated to diagnose...
When Ideology Trumps Sound Scholarship
Some reviews are difficult to write. Responding to David Hollinger’s Christianity’s American Fate, I initially used a tone that was wholly mocking and sarcastic, because the book is, from so many points of view, a dreadful piece of work. I backtracked on that somewhat because I genuinely respect the author’s earlier writings and, moreover, the present book has some portions that are really thoughtful, which I will certainly be citing in future. Please appreciate my dilemma when I say...
Patrick Deneen’s Otherworldly Regime
It is mon habit of progressives to denounce various aspects of American history as racist, sexist, or in some other way bigoted. The U.S. Constitution, we are often reminded, had a “three-fifths clause” that counted blacks as less than whites—for purposes of congressional representation. The clause, rightly, is denounced as a stain on our founding charter. The missing context, however, is that it was the abolitionists who did not want blacks to be counted at all, while the slaveholders...
Robert Nisbet: Tradition & Community
“To the contemporary social scientist,” observed Robert Nisbet (1913–1996), “to be labeled a conservative is more often to be damned than praised.” Already evident when he published it in 1952, ment is even more accurate today. Surveys from the past decade have found that close to two thirds of undergraduate faculty call themselves far left or pared to about 13% who identify as conservative or far right. The disproportion is more pronounced at elite universities and in particular fields....
The Monarch and the Marxist
Queen Elizabeth II and Mikhail Gorbachev were born five years apart. They lived through a century of enormous change. Seven decades before either was born, Charles Dickens (1859) penned A Tale of Two Cities, a historical novel reflecting on the turbulence of the French Revolution. It opens with this famous paragraph: It was the best of times, it was the worst of times, it was the age of wisdom, it was the age of despair, it was the epoch...
Abortion: Violence Against Women
Abortion solves problems. This is what its advocates promised in the years leading up to the Supreme Court decision in Roe v. Wade, which invented a supposed constitutional right to abortion. This is what its advocates continue to argue today in the wake of the Court’s 2022 decision reversing Roe. Abortion is a solution. The history of abortion in America started not in the 20th century but virtually at the nation’s advent. It’s a gruesome tale that many have...
Christ Our Composer
Among the many wonders of user-created content on the internet, a person of angelic patience, able to separate the wheat from the chaff, can acquire an amateur education in most anything. Recently, I’ve been delving into music theory. I’m no musicologist, but I play a little piano and guitar, and I wanted to expand my understanding for creative purposes. The more I understand, the more I can do with my own music. The debate over the relation of God...
Boutique Marxism and the Critical Revolution
The title of this review may well seem unduly snide; regrettably, it is the most precise description of the account of critical history on offer in this book. From his earliest publications until now, Terry Eagleton has sought to shape a version of Marxist critical discourse thoroughly purged of such disagreeable features of actual Marxist regimes as the imposition of “social realism,” the intimidation of brilliant artists (Shostakovich, for instance), show trials, the gulag, five-year plans resulting in mass...
America in Debt: A Short History
On the website of the U.S. Department of the Treasury, there is a section entitled “Debt to the Penny.” It reports the total debt of the U.S. government on a daily basis. Every so often it attracts some attention, invariably when the debt level passes some significant milestone. We hear a lot about the national debt in figures that are unfathomable. But despite our “worry,” the American electorate seems unwilling to pressure their representatives in Congress to do much...
Conversation Starters with … Ian Rowe
In your video True Diversity: Ian Rowe’s Story, you describe the resegregation of your junior high school, in which an annex was created for white students. Your parents initially wanted you to go to this new a­nnex, but you insisted on staying at your predominantly black school, feeling that you did not have to be surrounded by white students to succeed. Your parents relented. How do you think your education, and your professional future, would have been different if...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved