Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
‘Dual-Status’ Youths: Broken Kids, Broken System
‘Dual-Status’ Youths: Broken Kids, Broken System
May 16, 2025 6:35 PM

“Status.” Webster’s defines it as “high position or rank in society.” Yet for many young people, this could not be further from the truth. In the language of social workers and court systems, “dual-status” youths are young people who are involved in the juvenile justice system and child welfare system. Case in point:

She was born to an incarcerated mother. She was repeatedly abused by relatives with whom she spent much of her early life.

By the time she turned 10, she had been sexually abused by an older brother, a pimp, who forced her into prostitution.

She didn’t last long at foster homes and ended up living in group homes in the Northern California area. She ran away from placements dozens of times and continued prostituting herself.

Perhaps not surprisingly, Alicia — whose real name is being withheld to conceal her identity — repeatedly landed in juvenile detention on solicitation or related charges.

One of the biggest problems for these kids are that the adults in their lives who are most positively involved – social workers and probation officers – rarely, if municated. Even more concerning, probation officers are only involved if and when a child has trouble with the law, and a probation officer’s main concern is to make sure the child doesn’t end up in trouble again … but not necessarily fixing the issue that landed the child in trouble in the first place.

Dual-status children face huge issues:

Their cases typically present enormous challenges: Many of the children are chronic runaways who have suffered from severe physical or emotional abuse, neglect and abandonment. And they e from troubled homes often beset by domestic violence, substance abuse and mental illness.

It’s hard to say how many children e entangled in both the juvenile justice and child welfare systems, partly because of the historical bureaucratic divides between the two systems.

These children have plex needs. Even when they do have caring adults in their lives (a teacher, a social worker, a foster parent), they often have a difficult time trusting or bonding with them. Frankly, most of these kids have been “taught” not to trust. And many of these children have no stable home life, and face plex labyrinth of social services and courts on their own, or with whatever lawyer happens to be available at the time.

Neha Desai, an attorney who serves as policy adviser for the fledgling Dually Involved Youth Initiative in Santa Clara County, talks about what these kids face:

What happened with this youth, and with so many youth who fall into this, is the child welfare worker feels like there’s nothing for this kid: ‘We have placed her over and over again. She runs from every placement. She’s involved in dangerous activities, and we can’t protect her, and she’s going to get killed out on the streets and she needs to have the intervention of the juvenile justice system in order to keep her safe.’

The juvenile justice system says, ‘Are you kidding me? This is absolutely not a youth that belongs in the juvenile justice system. That would be criminalizing a kid for being a victim. I mean, they’re being sexually exploited, and you’re saying that they need to be detained in order to keep them safe, but that’s punishing them for being a victim.’

Then, there’s the cost. Placement for just one juvenile in a treatment facility can run into the tens of thousands of dollars in just a few short months.

Omaha, Nebraska, like many places, are trying to find ways for courts and social workers to work together, get children the services they need, keeping them out of the juvenile justice system and in school.

The Omaha reform effort emphasizes sharing data between the juvenile justice and child welfare systems and bringing together representatives of both systems, along with parents or foster parents and, in this case, school officials, to improve prospects for crossover youths.

Thus, the county attorney, the boy’s foster father, social workers, school staff and a probation officer who had worked with the youth came together with an eye toward finding a solution that would keep him from being prosecuted for fighting.

The result: a written agreement that the youth would avoid fighting, attend school regularly, return to therapy for anger management and attend a program designed to help him resist the temptation to join a gang.

The agreement specified the assault charge would be dropped if the boy — an African-American, like a heavily disproportionate share of dual-status kids plied with all requirements by the end of the 2013-14 school year.

He did. Now, he’s doing well in school and has a good shot at going to college.

Reform is necessary, and it isn’t easy. Adults often don’t see the value of shifting priorities and roles in either the social service sector and juvenile justice. The children involved are tough to work with: they’ve been hurt over and over again, they are often lacking social and educational skills, and they don’t have many successful role models. This is yet another area munities, churches and families can ask, “Where can we help? What can we do?”

No one should be a “dual-status” kid. They should be someone’s beloved child.

Read “‘Dual-status’ kids endure another kind of double jeopardy” at The Center for Public Integrity.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Supreme Court Will Re-Examine Prayer at Government Meetings
Even before America became a republic, Americans have opened public meetings with prayer. The Supreme Court even acknowledged this fact thirty years ago in the case of Marsh v. Chambers. Writing for the majority, Chief Justice Burger said, “From colonial times through the founding of the Republic and ever since, the practice of legislative prayer has coexisted with the principles of disestablishment and religious freedom.” But the “ever since” may soon ing to an end. After two residents Greece, New...
Bruce Edward Walker: ‘Shutting down discourse is justice denied’
Bruce Edward Walker recently wrote mentary for The Tampa Tribune entitled, Shutting Down Corporate Speech in the Name of Social Justice. He says that: Corporate boardrooms arebeing caught up ina newwave of religious fervor sparkedbyclergy andmembers ofreligious ordersin search ofsocial justice. Alas, this movement is only superficially about the spirit.In truth,corporate directors pany executives are facinga very worldlymissionary effort bypriests, pastors, nuns and laypersonsarmed withproxy shareholder resolutionsthat advance politically liberal dogmas, including attempts to undermine the Supreme Court’sCitizens United ruling....
Q&A: Neighborhood Film Company on Transforming the Broken Through Business
Ricky Staub and Anders Lindwall were on a steady path to success in the film industry. Ricky was working for a big producer and Anders was freelancing as mercial director. Then, God called both of them to leave their jobs and start pany of their own — one focused on leveraging the process of filmmaking toward whole-life transformation for adults in recovery. Creating a unique business model founded on a concept called “family ratios,” NFCo melds for-profit with non-profit to...
Paying For College By Selling Yourself
There is no doubt that higher education is costly. Textbooks alone can run $1000 a semester for some undergraduates. Waiting tables and flipping burgers won’t cover those costs. With many parents just as strapped for cash as their children, how does one pay for a college diploma? For some young women, the answer is to sell themselves. There are websites that offer “matching” services for “mutually beneficial relationships”; that is, a young woman signs up for a “sugar daddy”. He...
Churches Mobilize Professional Response for Oklahoma
One of the powerful scenes after Hurricane Katrina was church organizations cutting their way through the roads with chainsaws so they could set up hot meal tents the very next day. Church responders have transformed into “well oiled machines” and are being praised by The Red Cross and federal agencies. Because of Katrina, and tornadoes like the ones that decimated parts of Tuscaloosa, Ala. and Joplin, Mo., churches in munities can offer a level of expertise to the local houses...
Commentary: Recruiting for Big Government: Food Stamps Run Amok
The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), the federal government’s “food stamp” program, is symptomatic of America’s current view of the role of government, says Elise Hilton. It is there to take care of our every need. Hilton notes that the government is actively recruiting people for SNAP, in a heady mix of money, entitlement, and big government. The full text of her essay follows.Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere. Recruiting for Big Government: Food...
Religious Persecution: Syrian Christians Are ‘Exhausted’
The plight of Syrian Christians is well-documented, and includes the kidnapping of two Syrian bishops. In an address to the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland this week, Dr. Mary Mikhael of the National Evangelical Synod of Syria, said Syrian Christians are “exhausted” from the strain of life in that nation. She said there was no Arab Spring for the people of Syria but ‘only a stormy dark winter’. In particular, she expressed concern that there would soon be...
If Only Women Ran The World….
My persuasion can build a nation Endless power With our love we can devour You’ll do anything for me -Beyonce, “Run the World (Girls)” That’s the apparent fantasy of Democratic Congresswoman Jan Schakowsky of Illinois. She recently hosted her annual fundraising luncheon, with guest speaker, Planned Parenthood’s Cecile Richards. Schakowsky said, “humanity is at a crossroads on this small planet and that our survival as a species is dependent on women taking charge, taking the world in our own hands.”...
‘God’s Love with Work Gloves’
After a disaster strikes, very few organizations have the vast resources and expertise to feed so many people as Southern Baptist Disaster Relief. They have received praise from countless victims and organizations, including The American Red Cross. After Katrina, they were the first to have hot food tents up and running, feeding tens of thousands three meals a day in munities along the Gulf Coast. Most state Baptist Conventions have their own disaster relief agencies that in many instances have...
‘The USDA of Europe?’
Tim Burrack, vice chairman and board member of Truth About Trade & Technology, recently wrote mentary for the Washington Times about the agriculture industry in the U.S. and how it is ing more and more European. He says there is fear of a “growing bureaucracy that is smothering freedom and innovation.” Burrack goes on to explain that the U.S. Department of Agriculture has taken an unfortunate step toward Europeanization when it delayed the approval of two crops that will help...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved