Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Donald Trump nominates Amy Coney Barrett to Supreme Court
Donald Trump nominates Amy Coney Barrett to Supreme Court
Oct 27, 2025 3:18 AM

President Donald Trump has nominated Amy Coney Barrett to the U.S. Supreme Court. The 48-year-old will fill the seat left vacant by the death of 87-year-old Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg on September 18.

President Trump called Barrett “a woman of unparalleled achievement, towering intellect, sterling credentials and unyielding loyalty to the Constitution,” as he introduced hthe nominee in a ceremony in the White House’s Rose Garden at 5 p.m. Eastern on Saturday.

He reminded the nation of the impact a new justice, his third appointment, would have on jurisprudence. “Rulings that the Supreme Court will issue in ing years will decide the survival of our Second Amendment, our religious liberty, our public safety, and so much more. To maintain security and liberty and prosperity, we must preserve our priceless heritage of a nation of laws,” he said.

“I love the United States and the United States Constitution,” Barrett said in her speech Saturday, adding she felt “humbled” by her nomination.

In a moment of great consequence, Barrett recognized former originalist Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia, for whom she clerked in 1998-1999, as “my mentor.”

“His judicial philosophy is mine, too,” Barrett said. “A judge must apply the law as written. Judges are not policymakers, and they must be resolute in setting aside any policy views they may hold.”

Members of Scalia’s family, as well as every member of Barrett’s own multiracial family, attended the announcement.

Barrett has earned the trust of conservative legal scholars with her outspoken support for interpreting the Constitution according to the original intent of the Founders. “Judge Barrett’s record demonstrates mitment to the Constitution’s text and its purpose,” said Kelly Shackelford, president of the First Liberty Institute. “Judge Barrett understands that government exists to protect the God-given rights of the people and the Constitution exists to prevent government from infringing on those rights.” Dr. Grazie Christie of The Catholic Association agreed that Barrett is “brilliant, plished, mitted to interpreting the text of the Constitution as written.”

Barrett, who is five years Neil Gorsuch’s junior, would be the youngest justice on the court.

Barrett has served on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit since 2017, when she faced bruising questions about her religious faith during contentious Senate confirmation hearings.

Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., seemed to imply that being a faithful Roman Catholic disqualified Barrett from serving on the court. “When you read your speeches, the conclusion one draws is that the dogma lives loudly within you. And that’s of concern,” she said. Sen. Dick Durbin, D-Ill., also probed Barrett about her view of what it means to be an “orthodox Catholic.” Legal scholars argued that the harsh criticism of Barrett’s Catholic faith came close to violating the U.S. Constitution, which bars officials from requiring a “religious test” of appointees (Article VI, Clause 3).

Ultimately, the Senate confirmed Barrett by a vote of 55-43 on October 31, 2017.

If confirmed, Barrett could tip the Supreme Court’s jurisprudence back to a strict constructionist reading of the Constitution absent since at least the Warren Court of the 1950s. Some are already bracing for another round of ugly personal attacks and inappropriate questions about the nominee’s traditional faith. Family Research Council President Tony Perkins condemned “the startling level of anti-Christian bias already on display against Barrett.” The Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights noted that mentators who are not at all friendly to Barrett or President Trump, have advised Senate Democrats against savaging Barrett over her religion:

S.E. Cupp advises Democrats that a repeat of the bigoted attacks on Barrett will only get Trump reelected. Bonnie Kristian, writing for Yahoo News, says that an attack on Barrett’s faith is the “wrong way” to go. Democratic Senator Joe Manchin flatly said, “It’s awful to bring in religion. It truly is.” Professor Jonathan Turley, who says he is “fervently secular” in his views, opined that Democrats should leave Barrett’s religious beliefs alone. … Brandeis University professor Eileen McNamara said it best: “Let’s keep the focus during this nomination and confirmation fight – whenever es – on the Constitution, not on the Baltimore Catechism.”

President Trump said that Barrett’s confirmation process should be “straight-forward and extremely prompt,” as well as devoid of “personal or partisan attacks.” The Senate Judiciary Committee could begin confirmation hearings the week of October 10, paving the way for a Senate confirmation vote by October 26, according to Sen. Mike Braun, R-Ind.

Thus far, the substantive opposition to Barrett’s nomination to the Supreme Court has focused on her criticism of Chief Justice John Roberts’ ruling on the Affordable Care Act, which recast the ACA’s individual mandate as a tax in order to maintain its constitutionality.

Today, President Trump nominated Judge Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court — a jurist with a written track record of disagreeing with the Court’s decision to uphold the Affordable Care Act.

Vote like your health care is on the ballot — because it is.

— Joe Biden (@JoeBiden) September 26, 2020

Sen. Durbin renewed his opposition to Barrett after her selection for the U.S. Supreme Court became public knowledge, saying, “It is nothing short of outrageous that they want to approve her in fewer than 30 days.” Since 1987, the average Supreme Court nominee has received a confirmation vote 30 calendar days after the first day of his or her Senate confirmation hearings. Justices Ginsburg, Stephen Breyer, and Chief Justice John Roberts were confirmed within 15, 18, and 17 days of their confirmation mencement, respectively.

“President Trump has chosen an absolute all-star in Judge Amy Coney Barrett to serve as our nation’s newest Supreme Court justice,” said Susan B. Anthony List President Marjorie Dannenfelser. “Amy Coney Barrett is a brilliant jurist in the mold of the late Justice Scalia.”

Both President Trump and Barrett took the opportunity to laud the late Justice Ginsburg, whom Barrett said “not only broke glass ceilings, she smashed them.” Barrett, a mother of seven, would break barriers of her own, ing the first woman on the Supreme Court to have school-age children.

Barrett promised to be “mindful of who came before me,” even as she potentially ushers in a new era of reverence for the Constitution and replaces the Supreme Court’s most reliable judicial activist.

“There is no one better,” President Trump told Barrett. ”You are going to be really fantastic.”

Photo / Alex Brandon.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Bulgaria embraces flat tax and freedom
The speaker for the Seventeenth Acton Institute Annual Dinner is former Estonian Prime Minister, Dr. Mart Laar. One of the economic reforms Laar implemented in Estonia was a flat tax. After what was described as a brilliant economic turnaround, other countries have followed Estonia’s lead on flat tax policies and free market policies in general. Russia, Ukraine, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovakia, Romania, and Macedonia also have flat taxes for e. The country of Bulgaria is now introducing a flat tax rate...
Romney’s Religion
Michael Gerson’s “What Matters About Romney’s Religion” in today’s Washington Post: There is a long tradition of American leaders who believe that religion is so personal it shouldn’t even affect their private lives. But this rigid separation between religious conviction and public policy lies outside the main current of American history. Abraham Lincoln’s theology, while hardly orthodox, was not his “own private affair.” “Nothing stamped with the divine image and likeness,” he asserted, “was sent into the world to be...
Debunking the ‘Eat Local’ Myth
An op-ed in today’s NYT by James E. McWilliams, “Food That Travels Well,” articulates some of the suspicions I’ve had about the whole “eat local” phenomenon. It seems to me that duplicating the kind of infrastructure necessary to sustain a great variety of food production every hundred miles or so is grossly inefficient. Now some researchers in New Zealand have crunched some numbers that seem to support that analysis: Incorporating these measurements into their assessments, scientists reached surprising conclusions. Most...
“We Doubt, We’re Out, Get Used to It”
Hey everybody, Richard Dawkins is selling T-shirts! Get ’em while they’re hot! One of my favorite bloggers, Allahpundit (who just happens to be an athiest himself), calls this “…a new stage in the transformation of ‘new atheism’ from rational argument to aggrieved identity group,” and has this to say about the t-shirts themselves Some of menters call this sort of thing evangelical atheism but a moron with a scarlet “A” on his chest really isn’t trying to convert you. He’s...
‘I Am Not Afraid of Death’
Alexander Solzhenitsyn Der Spiegel has published a far ranging interview with Alexander Solzhenitsyn in which the great writer “discusses Russia’s turbulent history, Putin’s version of democracy and his attitude to life and death.” It is very much worth the read. Once again, e away from an encounter with Solzhenitsyn’s thought and marvel at his courage, his dedication to his art, and the almost indestructible quality of this man, now 88. In the current Religion & Liberty, I reviewed the new...
Questions for Dr Gregg
Australian blogger Barney Zwartz, writing for the Australian newspaper The Age, tracks down intrepid research director Sam Gregg, who participated in a Melbourne book launching for Catholic Social Teaching and the Market Economy. After noting that “it seems counter-intuitive to me to consider market-theorist heroes such as Maggie Thatcher and Ronald Reagan friends of the poor,” Zwartz asks: Is Dr Gregg right? Is a market economy the primary tool for addressing poverty, are other economic approaches better, or are there...
Economics and Happiness
Chuck Colson locates the perennial problem of human unhappiness with the inability to perceive where happiness es from. There’s the economic argument that while “increased prosperity can’t make you happy, it can, ironically, contribute to unhappiness,” an argument which Colson says, “doesn’t tell us anything about what makes people happy in the first place. Thus, it can’t tell us why increased prosperity doesn’t translate into increased happiness.” As I’ve noted before, the economic argument is helpful for locating a source...
‘A Power Out Of Ourselves’
Enthusiastic atheists are on the offensive in an effort to tear down private faith, now that religion has increasingly lost influence in the public square. Richard Dawkins, author of “The God Delusion”, and Christopher Hitchens’s, “God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything” have sold hundreds of thousands of copies. The reason for this attack is because the atheists claim to mitted to justice, while people of faith, along with the divine itself, are and have been purveyors of injustice,...
Lord Acton on Literature
Picking up on the themes of the importance of narrative from recent weeks, I pass along this worthy saying of Lord Acton: “Government rules the present. Literature rules the future.” ...
The Transfiguration of Our Lord
Mt. Tabor In much of the Christian world today, the great feast of the Transfiguration of Our Lord memorated (Matt. 17:1-9). In the Eastern Church, as Fr. Seraphim Rose observed, it is customary to “offer fruits to be blessed at this feast; and this offering of thanksgiving to God contains a spiritual sign, too. Just as fruits ripen and are transformed under the action of the summer sun, so is man called to a spiritual transfiguration through the light of...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved