Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Buying Babies: The Rise of Surrogacy In The U.S.
Buying Babies: The Rise of Surrogacy In The U.S.
Aug 25, 2025 9:38 AM

I’m sure Willie Nelson was not thinking about surrogacy issues when he wrote “If You’ve Got The Money, Honey,” but it’s applicable. $100,000? Check. 9 months? Check.

If you’ve got the money honey I’ve got the time

We’ll go honky tonkin’ and we’ll have a time

We’ll have more fun baby all way down the line

If you’ve got the money honey I’ve got the time

While surrogacy is a huge industry in India, it’s ing a growing business here in the U.S. now. In Austin, Texas, one couple from New Jersey awaits the birth of their children via a surrogate:

A nurse spread gel on Nicole Benham’s pregnant belly and slowly moved a sonogram wand over it, describing the images on nearby monitors. This scene, in which parents get an early glimpse of baby, is played out many times a day in medical offices across America, but this plot has a twist.

Benham is carrying twins, but they are not her babies. They belong to Sheila and Kevin McWilliams, a New Jersey couple who lost their firstborn and can’t have another child together. They provided the eggs and sperm, and they will bear all costs, which average $75,000 to $100,000 and include fees to the surrogate, the matchmaking pany and lawyers for both parties, experts said.

Despite such costs, U.S. surrogate births have jumped 250 percent in eight years, and experts expect them to continue rising because of advances in reproductive technology, increasing numbers of same-sex marriages and growing acceptance of surrogacy.

The U.S. is one of only a handful of countries – like India – that allow for paid surrogacy. That means big business. Other countries allow for “altruistic” surrogacy: a woman might carry a baby for a sister or brother, but there is no profit made. Those receiving the baby only pay medical expenses, for instance. Abby Lippman, an emeritus professor at McGill University in Montreal who studies reproductive technology, says making a profit on making babies makes for bad business.

Just like we don’t pay for blood or semen, we don’t pay for eggs or sperm or babies. There’s a very general consensus that paying surrogates modify women and their bodies. I think in the United States, it’s so consumer-oriented, mercially oriented, so caught up in this ‘It’s my right to have a baby’ approach, that people gloss over some big issues.”

Germany is another nation that has thus far stayed away from paid surrogacy.

Ingrid Schneider of the University of Hamburg’s Research Center for Biotechnology, Society and the Environment said it is in children’s best interest to know that they have just one mother.

“We regard surrogacy as exploitation of women and their reproductive capacities,” Dr. Schneider said. “In our view, the bonding process between a mother and her child starts earlier than at the moment of giving birth. It is an ongoing process during pregnancy itself, in which an intense relationship is being built between a woman and her child-to-be. These bonds are essential for creating the grounds for a successful parenthood, and in our view, they protect both the mother and the child.”

That ideal is a long way from “gestational carrier” agreements “IPs” (Intended Parents) and clinics charging tens of thousands of dollars for services. The U.S. is now a destination spot for would-be parents. Again, if you’ve got the money…

International would-be parents often pay $150,000 or more, an amount that rises rapidly for those who do not get a viable pregnancy on their first try. Prices vary by region, but surrogates usually receive $20,000 to $30,000, egg donors $5,000 to $10,000 (more for the Ivy League student-athlete, or model), the fertility clinic and doctor $30,000, the surrogacy agency $20,000 and the lawyers $10,000. In addition, the intended parents pay for insurance, fertility medication, and incidentals like the surrogate’s travel and maternity clothes.

I’ve written here before about modification of humans in the surrogacy business, and the threat surrogacy poses to women, especially poor and vulnerable women. A baby has e a deserved item, a right, rather than a gift from God in Judeo-Christian thought. Want a baby? Buy a baby. Want a boy baby? A baby with certain hair or eye color? Don’t want to take time off from your career or ruin a nice figure? If you’ve got the money…

We have no business being in the baby business. Surrogacy harms women and children. While surrogacy may appear to be altruistic, it’s bottom line is money. Rather than being a “perfect solution” for infertile or gay couples who desire a child (or Heaven forbid, a woman who wants a baby but also wants to keep her size 0 figure), it takes what should be a moment of co-creation with God and turns it into a business transaction. It preys on the most vulnerable: the infertile, the poor, the baby, taking a family relationship and creating a contractual obligation. Babies aren’t business.

Read “Coming to U.S. for Baby, and Womb to Carry It” at The New York Times.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Natural law and targeting whirlybirds
Psychiatrist and author Theodore Dalrymple has published a brilliant essay in the National Review highlighting the importance of the rule of law. He takes as a case study the looting in the wake of Hurricane Katrina: “New Orleans shows us in the starkest possible way the reality of the thin blue line that protects us from barbarism and mob rule,” writes Dalrymple. The essay questions whether such barbarism is inherent in human nature in crisis or if there are elements...
The mandate to work
Check out this editorial from the current issue of Christianity Today, “Neighbor Love Inc.” The editorial focuses on the importance of work and labor in the Christian life: “Business for the Christian is a form of neighbor-love, a way to fulfill the second Great Commandment.” The entrepreneurial calling is one that should be affirmed within a biblical framework by Christian leaders. CT recognizes that “the church has spent enormous energies on guiding our sexuality, but done little at the congregational...
The welfare trap
In Tuesday’s Wall Street Journal, Brendon Miniter notes that many of those stranded in New Orleans after the levee breaches were literally caught in a trap set by government “assistance”: We still only have anecdotal evidence to go on, and we can be hopeful as the death toll remains far below the thousands originally predicted. But it’s reasonable to surmise that Sen. Kennedy is correct about those who wanted to leave: Most people who could arrange for their own transportation...
Low Marx for poor memory
Samuel Gregg writes on a recent BBC Radio listeners poll that ranked Karl Marx as the greatest philosopher in history. Gregg reflects on the evils and atrocities that mitted by the political heirs of Marx’ philosophy menting that the materialist view of Communism removes any possibility of fulfilling the two mandments; loving God and loving our neighbors. Above all, Gregg wonders how people have forgotten what Marx stands for: “Why is Marxism’s red flag not treated with the same contempt...
Comet-busting lasers: A response to Andy Crouch
Andy Crouch was kind enough to respond to my article on climate change (which itself was penned in reply to Crouch’s original piece), and I’ve included a response of my own. His words are in the large blocks of italics below: While I’m disappointed that you don’t even try to engage the work of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, by far the most extensive and diligent effort I’m aware of to evaluate the science of global warming, In my...
Five marks of a Catholic school
Deal W. Hudson of the Morley Institute reports on an address by a Vatican official. The story is also reported here: Vatican Official Explains What Makes a School Catholic His name is one you should know. Archbishop J. Michael Miller is the Secretary of the Congregation for Catholic Education in the Vatican. That means he helps oversee Catholic education from kindergarten to college and graduate school throughout the world. I met with the self-effacing Archbishop over breakfast before his lecture...
State of nature redux
I’ve finally had a chance to respond to this piece on Tech Central Station, “The State of Nature in New Orleans: What Hobbes Didn’t Know” (Tech Central Station no longer active). In this article, TCS contributing editor Lee Harris takes George Will to task for his citation of Hobbes, to the extent that, as Harris writes, “my point of disagreement is with Hobbes’ famous and often quoted characterization of man’s original state of nature as one in which human life...
Top Catholic high schools
The Acton Institute’s Catholic High School Honor Roll has released its annual list of the Top 50 Catholic High Schools in the United States. About half are repeat winners and half are new honorees. See the Honor Roll web site for more information. ...
Katrina: A chance to escape the welfare trap?
The Wall Street Journal editorializes today that President Bush has a chance to encourage a more free-market oriented approach to rebuilding the gulf coast: Instead of channeling more cash through the same failed bureaucracies, he should declare the entire Gulf Coast region an enterprise zone, with low tax rates for new investments and waivers for any regulatory obstacles to rebuilding. The Journal goes on to note that this event may be an ideal time for Bush to put a new...
Rebuilding civil society in New Orleans
Check out this piece by Dr. Jennifer Roback Morse, an Acton senior fellow, in which she argues “that marriage is the cornerstone of civil society. And the images of Katrina demonstrate this, if we are willing to see.” ...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved