Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Bernie Sanders cares more about unions than he does his own workers
Bernie Sanders cares more about unions than he does his own workers
May 13, 2025 10:24 AM

Who would have predicted that the hottest labor dispute of the summer would be between the workers and management of Bernie Sanders’s presidential campaign?

Sanders is a long-time champion of raising the federal minimum to $15 an hour, so his campaign workers assumed they’d earn that level of pay too:

Campaign field hires have demanded an annual salary they say would be equivalent to a $15-an-hour wage, which Sanders for years has said should be the federal minimum. The organizers and other employees supporting them have invoked the senator’s words and principles in making their case to campaign manager Faiz Shakir, the documents reviewed by The Washington Post show.

Now that the media has exposed their apparent double-standard Sanders will take action to ensure his people get the higher pay, right? Well, no.

In a statement to the Washington Post, campaign manager Faiz Shakir sounds a lot like an executive at Wal-Mart, noting that the pay is petitive”—“We know our campaign offers wages and petitive with other campaigns, as is shown by the latest fundraising reports.” But the telling part is that he refuses to intervene on behalf of the workers: “Bernie and I both strongly believe in the sanctity of the collective bargaining process and we will not deviate from mitment to it.”

The Sanders campaign is being chastised for what appears to be a hypocritical stance. But I think that misses the point. What seems obvious is that Sanders cares more about unions than he does his own workers.

The reason many on the left support raising the minimum wage is not so that workers will earn more money but so that union labor will e more attractive. Four years ago, the unions were pressuring local and state governments to both raise the minimum wage to $15 and hour and to give unions an exemption from having to pay the higher wage.

… Rusty Hicks, who heads the county Federation of Labor and helps lead the Raise the Wage coalition, said Tuesday night panies with workers represented by unions should have leeway to negotiate a wage below that mandated by the law.

“With a collective bargaining agreement, a business owner and the employees negotiate an agreement that works for them both. The agreement allows each party to prioritize what is important to them,” Hicks said in a statement. “This provision gives the parties the option, the freedom, to negotiate that agreement. And that is a good thing.”

Union leaders may be arrogant, but they aren’t stupid. They understand that raising the minimum wage will kill jobs—they just don’t want it to be union jobs that disappear. They are more than willing to allow workers to be paid less than $15 an hour provided that a cut of the worker’s paycheck goes to pay their union salaries. They also realize that the mandatory wage increase will have an extortionary effect on employers: “Can’t afford to pay the high minimum wage? Well, if you e a union shop you can circumvent that pesky law. . .”

But notice also what the unions are saying: business owners and employees should have the “freedom” to negotiate an agreement that works for them both. The caveat, union leaders would add, is that this only applies for “collective bargaining.” It doesn’t seem to matter if employees are worse off than they would have been without the unions “help.” That’s why the Sanders campaign mitted to the “collective bargaining process” rather mitted to paying their workers $15 an hour.

If you want to work for the Sander’s campaign you have to join the union. And if you join the union then you have to accept the wages agreed to in the “collective bargaining process”—even if it is lower than the wage you joined the campaign to fight for.

Sander’s campaign is much better off while the employee is much worse off. What really matters—at least to the union leaders—is that the union is better off. They will be are able to keep dues-paying, voting bodies in their union so that other employees can negotiate a higher salary for themselves (and union leaders can continue to get paid).

Shakir says that, “Bernie Sanders is the most pro-worker and pro-labor candidate running for president.” But which side does he take when the interest of the workers and the union clash? We have the answer already. If Sanders was pro-worker he’d simply offer to pay them what he thinks is the “fair wage” (i.e., $15 an hour). But because he cares more about unions than workers, he is refusing to get involved and risk losing the support of Big Labor.

Sanders may not know much about economics, but he certainly understands how political incentives work.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A $1 Trillion Reminder That Welfare is Failing
If you are looking for good data to provide a reminder that America has lost the “War On Poverty,” Michael Tanner piled helpful information explaining the current state of the union in the study titled, “The American Welfare State: How We Spend Nearly $1 Trillion a Year Fighting Poverty — And Fail.” Tanner begins by noting that we are now at a point where annually, [T]he federal government will spend more than $668 billion on at least 126 different programs...
Government-Coerced Electric Car Demand
When progressive elites discover that the average free-thinking American does not live according to their sanctified vision for our lives, they will resort to using the power of government to coerce the rest of us into doing what they want. For example, currently there is virtually no market for electric cars because not many consumers want them. However, this fact means nothing to elite progressive in government. The elites have decided that we should be driving electric vehicles regardless of...
BBC: Should Religious Leaders Live a Modest Life?
Image Credit: BBC I had the opportunity today to take part in a discussion on the BBC program World Have Your Say, discussing the recent suspension by the Vatican of the Bishop of Limbu, Germany,Franz-Peter Tebartz-van-Elst, known in the German press as the “bishop of bling.” He is under investigation regarding expenditures of 31 million euros (roughly $41 million) for the renovation of the historic building that served, in part, as his residence. This story (which can be read here)...
Disestablishing Our Secular Schools
When es to public education, racial bias has not been acceptable for almost fifty years. So why is religious bias still tolerated? If we really want to promote religious liberty and educational reform, says Charles L. Glenn, we have toend the public school monopoly: [T]he rich diversity and energy that has been the glory of American religious life was, by the early twentieth century, largely suppressed in American K–12 schooling, though it continued at the collegiate level. This was not...
Cornerstone University Sues Feds Over HHS Mandate
, a Grand Rapids, Mich.-based Christian university, has joined the myriad of lawsuits against the HHS mandate requiring abortion-inducing drugs as part of employee insurance coverage. This filing is first and foremost an effort to preserve and protect our religious freedom as guaranteed by the First Amendment,” Cornerstone President Joseph Stowell wrote in an email Wednesday to donors and alumni. “Given our conviction that life begins at conception and mitment to the sanctity of life, we find the mandate to...
The Syrian Refugee Crisis: ‘Historic’
Recent events in Syria have created what The New York Times is calling an “historic” refugee crisis, with more than 2 million people leaving the country. In August, hundreds of thousands poured over the border to Iraq, describing “a campaign by jihadi fighters to destroy agriculture and cut power and water supplies in Syrian Kurdishareas.” Lebanon’s population has exploded by 20 percent due to Syrian refugees, and Jordan is trying to deal with over half a million people seeking refuge...
Oliver O’Donovan on the Secular-Spiritual Life
In a recent event co-sponsored by Christian’s Library Press, professor Oliver O’Donovanengaged in a robust conversation with Matthew Lee Anderson and Ken Myers on the topic of the Gospel and public engagement. The audio is now available via Mars Hill Audio. Sign-up is required, but is both simple and free. Anyone who has read O’Donovan is familiar with the weight and depth he brings to such matters. As was to be expected, this is a conversation filled with richness, nuance,...
We Don’t Need a ‘Third Way’, We Need More Non-Profits
The problem with advocating for third way economic system between capitalism and socialism is, as Matt Perman notes, there is no realistic third way. Fortunately, a third way isn’t needed since capitalism can do everything that so-called “third alternative” (e.g., distributism) want their system to do. For instance, one aspect of how capitalism can create a more “people-centered economy” is to increase the amount of capital that is dedicated to non-profits. When society reaches a point that we have a...
From Babel to Babylon: God’s Problem With Centralized Power
The Bible does not have a detailed plan for how the government of a modern nation of 300 million people should operate. If you’re looking for specifics on what the United States’ tariff policy with Finland ought to be, you’re plum out of luck. If you want canonical guidance as to the precise degree of control the filibuster should have over legislative proceedings in the U.S. Senate, you’re barking up the wrong tree. With plenty of issues in the socio-political...
When Life Has Killed the American Dream
When I talk about my time growing up in Los Angeles with my mother, I often describe her motivations for going to Hollywood like this: “She wanted to be a movie star…which means she was a waitress.” That’s a mon experience in an industry petitive and grinding as film. But increasingly these kinds of challenges are faced by women in less glamorous and more mainstream industries. As a recent BusinessWeek piece put it, “You Can Have Any Job You Want,...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved