Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
BBC’s ‘Years and Years’: Economic progress causes the apocalypse
BBC’s ‘Years and Years’: Economic progress causes the apocalypse
Feb 11, 2026 7:03 AM

Scanning bookshelves crammed with titles like Divergent,The Hunger Games, and countless imitators, this is the literary era of dystopian fiction. BBC One entered the genre with its “woke” TV series “Years and Years,” which offered UK viewers the unique analysis that technological progress and economic freedom triggered the apocalypse.

This synopsis includes spoilers.

“Years and Years” follows a family from the year 2019 until 2034, tracing world events along the way – and the political message could scarcely be less subtle. One family member has her life shortened when the newly re-elected President Donald Trump drops a nuclear weapon on China. Unbridled capitalism wipes out another couple’s savings.

The key villain is Viv Rook (Emma Thompson), a celebrity businesswoman turned populist politician who rises to prominence by proclaiming she does not “give a [expletive]” about the Middle Eastern conflict. She starts the Four Star Party, with a neo-fascist style insignia reminiscent of the National Alliance’s symbol. Rook holds the balance of power in a hung parliament until she can topple the government, seize power, and erect concentration camps. Innocent homosexual migrants are shipped to certain death in backward, Orthodox Christian nations in Eastern Europe for violating irrational immigration regulations. Perhaps most egregiously, she closes the beacon of truth, the taxpayer-funded BBC.

In the final episode this season (season one, episode six), matriarch Muriel Deacon tells her family they are responsible for “everything … the banks, the recession, America, Mrs. Rook, everything single thing that’s gone wrong – it’s your fault.” She explains:

We blame these vast, sweeping tides of history, you know, like they’re out of our control, like we’re so helpless and little and small. But it’s still our fault.

You know why? It’s that £1 t-shirt. A t-shirt that cost £1. We can’t resist it, every single one of us. We see a t-shirt that costs £1 and we think, “Ooh, that’s a bargain. I’ll have that,” and we buy it. … And the shopkeeper gets five miserable pence for that t-shirt, and some little peasant in a field gets paid 0.01 pence, and we think that’s fine – all of us. And we hand over our quid and we buy into that system for life.

I saw it all going wrong when it began in the supermarkets, when they replaced all the women on the till with those automated checkouts. … [Y]ou didn’t do anything, did you? Twenty years ago, when they first popped up, did you walk out? Did you write letters plaint? Did you shop elsewhere? No! You huffed, and you puffed, and you put up with it. And now, all those women are gone. And we let it happen.

And I think we do like them, those checkouts. We want them. Because it means we can stroll through, pick up our shopping, and we don’t have to look that woman in the eye – the woman who’s paid less than us. She’s gone, got rid of her, sacked. Well done.

So, yes, it’s our fault. This is the world we built. Congratulations. Cheers, all.

A video of the scene is embedded in this tweet.

“It’s our fault. This is the world we built. Congratulations, cheers all.” #YearsAndYears /rCfqGq93sl

— BBC One (@BBCOne) June 18, 2019

The story is less Orwellian than Julian, as in the end all is well and will be well. Ultimately, Rook’s camps are exposed, and she’s condemned by the world. The BBC opens anew. And cinema’s approved form of technological progress – transhumanism – mimics eternal life.

Thanks to its bringing received opinion to life, “Years and Years” currently enjoys an 88 percent rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics singled out Deacon’s diatribe for plaudits, with Michael Hogan of The Telegraph calling it “one hell of a speech.”

Many scripts tell us more about how cultural elites see the majority of their country than anything about the nation or its citizens themselves. Collette Wolfe’s speech to Charlize Theron in Young Adult (language warning) set the standard here. “Years and Years” joins “The Newsroom” in this category.

But Muriel Deacon’s speech amounts to little more than demanding her benighted viewers share the writers’ Luddite aversion to technological progress.Applying the underlying principle to real history shows its ings.

Blacksmiths, whose contributions to village life were once so significant they passed into verse, are no more; they have been sacked.

Wheelwrights, the gentle yeomen shaping wood strong enough to hold a covered wagon and stand the pull of four horses, have closed up shop.

“Ah,” the other side may say, “but those were skilledprofessions. Skilled people have the ability to learn a new expertise. But what about the unskilled laborers?”

Certain unskilled professions have winnowed down over the decades, even during my own (relatively) brief lifetime.

Just a decade ago, 71 percent more phone operators waited at the other end of the dial tone.

Not so long before ago, a full-time attendant greeted everyone who pulled into a gas station, filled your tank (with regular gasoline), washed your windshield, and offered to check your oil. Today, this persists only in New Jersey and more populated areas of Oregon – and only due to special interest legislation enacted to shield existing stations from petition.

Windows full of bank tellers who stamped your bank book with each transaction gave way to automated teller machines.

Loggers are following Paul Bunyan into the sunset, replaced by harvesters and forwarders.

Paperhangers see their work permanently erased puterized billboards that make their contributions redundant.

Movie theater projectionists will see their numbers shrink over the next 10 years, as on-demand streaming services allow people to watch the movie of their choice at home.

All of these jobs, while socially important, required only a rudimentary set of skills and are gradually disappearing.

The waning of these occupations has not created a long-term economic wasteland. Quite the contrary.

When employers no longer have to pay people to perform a given task, they can reinvest the savings into more productive lines of work. Machines often serve us infinitely faster, better, and more accurately than human beings. They yield greater abundance. More goods are produced, and innovation creates new professions, sometimes whole new industries. The resulting surge of creativity introduces new job opportunities for those left behind to make a longer lasting contribution.

And these technological improvements fuel research for the next breakthrough. The closing of lower skilled positions frees more human energies to participate in higher order jobs.

This not only benefits consumers and technological progress in general, but it has a greater significance. According to one of the writings of the Second Vatican Council, Gaudium et Spes, it helps the human race and the individual affected participate pletely in his divine calling.

The human intellect “shares in the light of the divine mind,” it teaches. “When man develops the earth by the work of his hands or with the aid of technology, in order that it might bear fruit and e a dwelling worthy of the whole human family … he carries out the design of God manifested at the beginning of time, that he should subdue the earth, perfect creation, and develop himself.” The added efficiency generated by new technology multiplies his “service of his brethren.”

That leads to a destination far different than the one mapped out by the BBC’s writers. Economic history indicates which set of prophecies we should believe.

Makarenko/. Editorial use only.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Alejandro Chafuen in Forbes: Change afoot in Uruguay’s elections?
Alejandro Chafuen, Acton’s Managing Director, International, has lectured during two visits to Uruguay this year, and today in Forbes he presents an examination of various candidates and policies in the lead-up to the country’s presidential elections this October. Uruguay, the most secular country in Latin America, also ranks highly in such categories as rule of law, confidence in government, low perceptions of corruption and crime, and so forth. Political culture and society in Uruguay are also marked by strong currents...
Compulsory vote and populism — an urgent problem in Latin America
In the United States there is a significant amount of criticism on the political left towards the Electoral College Voting System. The ones making this argument normally state that the “winning takes all” measure creates a bias against minorities, destroying the country’s popular vote. Critics use the 2016 election as an example, when President Trump lost the popular vote but got elected by the Electoral College. What some Americans do not know is that some countries adopt pulsory voting system,...
What does politics have to do with virtue?
One of the highlights of my summers working at the Acton Institute is leading discussions with our interns over major ideas, thinkers, and issues. This afternoon we had a spirited and thought provoking discussion about conservative critiques of liberalism. We discussed Patrick Deneen’s Why Liberalism Failed (Helpfully discussed in this Econtalk podcast), a critical review, and a couple of related blog posts. In these discussions I usually like to keep my cards close to my chest to better facilitate the...
2019 G20 Summit: Tariffs and forbearance
As world leaders from a select group of the largest national economies meet in Osaka at the end of this week, they face increasing volatility and uncertainty around some of the basic principles and institutions that bring together their various peoples in the global marketplace. The World Trade Organization may undergo serious reform in the face of hints from President Trump that the United States might withdraw amid broader dissatisfactions. The ongoing tariff battles between China and the United States...
State Department releases latest report on international religious freedom
A wide range of U.S. government agencies and offices use the reports for such efforts as shaping policy and conducting diplomacy. The Secretary of State also uses the reports to help determine which countries have engaged in or tolerated “particularly severe violations” of religious freedom in order to designate “countries of particular concern.” Secretary of State Mike Pompeo and Ambassador at Large for International Religious Freedom Sam Brownback discussed the report at a special briefing. “This mission is not just...
Nisbet and Dalrymple on community, authority, function and tattoos
In his must-read book, The Quest for Community, Robert Nisbet discusses the relationship munity and authority. Communities provide human connection and sense of belonging, but they e with limitations. They make demands up us to do certain things, to hold fast to certain beliefs. You can’t simply do whatever you want and still remain part of munity.
 Community without authority is not munity. This is of course one of the tensions of contemporary life. We all munity, but we don’t...
Daily Caller reviews Samuel Gregg’s new book
Samuel Gregg, director of research at the Acton Institute, released a new book titled, Reason, Faith, and the Struggle for Western Civilization. In his book, Gregg discusses the dangers that an unbalanced relationship between faith and reason imposes on a society. The Daily Caller, a widely read news and opinion outlet, reviewed Gregg’s new book in an article titled, “New Book Emphasizes the Importance of Faith and Reason for Western Civilization.” The article provides a brief synopsis of the book...
Acton Line podcast: Hong Kong’s freedom coming to an end? SCOTUS takes on regulatory state
Update (Aug. 6): Writing at The National Interest, Gordon C. Chang says “it’s now a revolution.” In an especially tone-deaf press conference Monday, Lam, standing next to eight grim-faced ministers, made no further concessions, either symbolic or substantive, as she struck all the wrong notes if she was trying to calm the situation in her embattled city. Her stern and sometimes ominous words—Lam warned the territory was on the “path of no return”—seemed aimed at an audience of one: Communist...
The Laffer Curve vindicated…in Canada
On September 14, 1974, economist Arthur Laffer and three friends had the most productive cocktail discussion in U.S. history. On that day, Laffer famously sketched his U-shaped theory of taxation on a cocktail napkin. It came at the height of the Keynesian ascendancy, just three years after President Richard Nixon proclaimed, “I am now a Keynesian in economics” and as his successor proposed a tax increase. Laffer argued that higher tax rates produce higher tax revenues, but only up to...
Common grace, community, and culture
Earlier this year I had the honor of moderating a panel discussion, “Common Grace, Community, and Culture,” at the Kuyper Conference at Calvin College and Seminary. The discussion featured J. Daryl Charles, with whom I have the pleasure of coediting the Common Grace volumes in the Kuyper series, Vincent Bacote of Wheaton College, and Jessica Joustra of Redeemer University College and TU Kampen. It was a wide-ranging and substantive discussion. The video is now available and mend it to you:...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved