Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Bastion Magazine: Edmund Burke tempers libertarian individualism
Bastion Magazine: Edmund Burke tempers libertarian individualism
Oct 29, 2026 1:32 AM

I just was introduced to Bastion Magazine , founded by a group of young libertarians who have realized that in order to have a limited state, we also need strong civil and cultural institutions and especially strong families. I have only skimmed the site, but it looks well done.

As one of the founders, C. Jay Engel, the founder and publisher explained to me, they began to realize that insights from thinkers like Edmund Burke and Robert Nisbet about civil society, including their approval of tradition and various forms of authority as well as their critiquesof individualism, were not seriously addressed by many libertarians.

The magazine argues that much of the libertarian movement has moved increasingly toward progressivism and nihilism and theyare trying to re-examine arguments for political and economic liberty in light of Burke et. al. Engel writes: “Our move to Bastion Magazine is a revolt against libertarian nihilism.”

I think thisis an interesting and positive development. A revitalization of Burke is needed. His insights about the nature of liberty and his worry about abstract thinking divorced from tradition are essential. Burke recognized that liberty cannot endure without deep respect for tradition and predicted that cold, calculating hyper-rationality of the “economists, sophists, and calculators” would lead to terror. Burke is also important because unlike an increasing number of conservatives, he recognized the important role that a market economy plays in liberty.In fact, Adam Smith noted that Burke and he shared many of the same views.

I am also glad to see the interest in Robert Nisbet. His work munity, authority and individualism is relevant for our times. Following Tocqueville, Nisbet stresses the importance of civil society and multiple layers of authority for resisting centralization.

As Tocqueville made clear, individualism leads to centralization and the state has an interest in promoting individualism: “The tyrant does not care if you love him as long as you don’t love one another.”

One of the weaknesses of libertarianism is its tendency toward individualism, which in the long run leads not to a limited state, but to an intrusive one.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Folsom Prison Blues
I received an email today from the InnerChange Freedom Initiative, an independent outreach of Prison Fellowship Ministries. It seems the initiative is facing rising program costs due to legal battles over the legitimacy of its Christian makeup. And constant critics of the program, like Barry Lynn of Americans United for the Separation of Church and State, seem rather incredibly cold-hearted to the plight of today’s prisoner. The InnerChange Freedom Initiative is one of the few elements in prisoners’ lives that...
2005 Samaritan award winner announced
The 2005 Samaritan Award Grand Prize winner was announced today! If you are unfamiliar with the Samaritan Award, or the Samaritan Guide, information can be found here.The winner of the $10,000 award was the Lives Under Construction Boy’s Ranch Residential Treatment Program. This program, based in Lampe, Missouri, takes in boys with serious behavioural problems and turns their lives around. The program teaches the value of making right choices, emphasizing the importance of good work and instilling a sense of...
Sin is not cost effective
Dr. Jennifer Morse, a senior fellow in economics for the Acton Institute, argues in this week’s mentary that the key road-block to successful economic development in impoverished nations is the lack of good “moral qualities, like the even-handed enforcement of law, and the transparency of government.” Dr. Morse cites a report from the World Bank Institute detailing the extensive bribery that occurs in developing countries, a practice that is considered “normal” by just about everyone. While this may seem to...
The Post-Edisonian double eclipse
We’ve discussed textual interpretation a bit on this blog here before. Paul Ricœur, who is famous for his “attempt bine phenomenological description with hermeneutic interpretation,” passed away earlier this year. One of Ricœur’s important contributions involved an observation about the nature of textual interpretation in distinction to personal dialogue. He writes, for example in his book Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences, Dialogue is an exchange of questions and answers; there is no exchange of this sort between the writer and...
Interfaith statement on immigration
The US Conference of Catholic Bishops is among the groups endorsing an interfaith statement on immigration reform. Like the e tax system, it seems that everyone agrees the immigration system needs reform but there’s a lot of disagreement as to how to go about it. As with most such broad consensus statements, the points articulated tend toward the innocuous, but there are a few sound ideas: for example, expediting family reunification. In general, the statement seems to be consonant with...
War and religion
“I don’t think many of the conflicts I’ve covered were really about religion. It’s about territory. It’s about power. It’s about other things. It’s just broken down along religious lines.” James Nachtwey, war photographer, 56, New York City (Interviewed by Cal Fussman, Esquire, Oct 01 ’05) ...
New site for Catholic social doctrine
The Verona-based Van Thuan Observatory has recently launched its website, reports the Zenit news service. The Observatory’s namesake, the late Cardinal Van Thuan, was the recipient of the the Acton Institute Faith and Freedom Award in 2002. On first glance, I think this resource has a long way to go. The ‘sources and documents’ page links you to only two documents. I don’t quite know how to respond to assemblies like this. It seems to me that if one wanted...
Calvin and Hobbes draw the line
In case you missed it, the Washington Post did a fun review of the new three-volume art book on the Calvin and ic strip. For a parent who raised two daughters during the strip’s 10-year run from 1985 to 1995, it’s refreshing to learn that creator Bill Watterson rejected all attempts at mercializing the adventures and musings of the young boy and his stuffed tiger. It seems that every children’s flick and television series of the Calvin and Hobbes era...
Mr. Barroso’s wake-up call
Jose Manuel Barroso, the President of the European Commission, is calling on all “civilized and rational” people bat anti-trade populism of the sort that is designed to whip up fear and protectionism. In an interview with The Times (London), Barroso issued what he called a wake-up call: “If the signal we give to our children is ‘Protect yourself — hide under the table because there is globalisation, resist it’ — then we are nothing.” This week, European leaders are headed...
‘The Dignity of the Human Form’
Spurred on by the specter of miraculous cures to horrible diseases, Irving Weissman, director of Stanford’s Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine, is working on bining human brains and mice. The Stanford Daily reports that Dr. Weissman “has worked with the transfer of human neurons to the brains of mice for several years now. He has already bred mice whose brains posed of 1 percent human neurons, finding that transplanted human brain cells could successfully connect to a...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved