Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Arthur C. Clarke’s Inhuman Trade-Off in ‘Childhood’s End’
Arthur C. Clarke’s Inhuman Trade-Off in ‘Childhood’s End’
Oct 17, 2026 3:12 AM

The fears of the past resonate in the present, and it’s no wonder humanity sometimes grasps desperately for answers in response to a frightening and unknowable future. Sometimes these e to us through literature and film which may allow us to dispense with the worst of them, given enough time.

The Overlords of Arthur C. Clarke’s Childhood’s End – a classic 1953 science-fiction novel that serves as the basis for a Syfy network miniseries beginning Dec. 14 – turn out to be a very mixed bag for their underling humans. On the one hand, the aliens’ presumed benevolence ushers in a utopian era of peace and prosperity where armed conflict and atomic warfare are effectively abolished, and no person goes hungry or suffers illness long. On the other hand, the Overlords’ munificence generates intellectual sloth and cultural stagnation. To some, abandoning free will and flushing centuries of human plishments down the loo poses benefits far outweighing the costs. To others, it means sacrificing all that it really means to be human. Additionally, the Overlord “Supervisor” Karellen issues an edict – similar to the warning given Pandora by Zeus about opening a box – prohibiting humans from exploring space, which places profound limitations on human free-will.

According to Clarke, the trade-off is precursor to the next step of human evolution, rendering corporeal existence and Earth itself moot on the path to attaining a higher plane of being for ensuing generations. Humankind has to persevere, however, through the perils of the Atomic Age first, and the only way to avert a nuclear war is through intervention of the Overlords. However, as Clarke shows us, even the Overlords are devoid of free will after they are eventually revealed as performing the bidding of the next layer of galactic bureaucracy, the Overmind.

Childhood’s End appeals to the fears of political upheaval and nuclear annihilation in the decade immediately following World War II and beyond. Our Age of Anxiety, in the apt title of a work by W.H. Auden, begs for easy answers when even the plex responses inherently were doomed to fall short. Readers will recall 1953 also marked the publication of Ian Fleming’s Casino Royale, a novel featuring the debut of 007 Secret Service Agent Bond, James Bond. Today is no different; the latest incarnation of Bond continues to obliterate baddies on movie screens more than 50 years after the demise of Fleming, and cinematic superheroes are boffo box office whether solo or collectively protecting the world from mischief makers. Television presents humanity struggling to survive in numerous dramas depicting various visions of a zombie apocalypse where even the stoic resilience of The Walking Dead’s Rick Grimes may not be enough to ensure his own survival much less survival of the human race.

[spoiler alert] Clarke’s novel is divided into three sections: Earth and the Overlords, The Golden Age, and The Last Generation. The first section details the arrival of the alien Overlords, who hover their gigantic spacecraft over Earth’s cities. It seems the planet, as usual, is in such turmoil that it is perceived necessary to draft a World Constitution, which, presciently enough is scheduled to take place in Paris – coincidentally the city hosting the 2015 United Nations Climate Conference later this month. The Overlords’ presence, however, inaugurates what many think to be a Golden Age, which in reality is a period of cultural decadence albeit one without disease and war. The final section depicts the realization of the Overlords’ purpose, which is to shepherd the human race toward a more enlightened evolutionary phase.

Lest readers unfamiliar with Childhood’s End conclude Clarke was nothing more than an advocate for secular, scientific solutions for the eternal problems confronting humanity, rest assured he understood that culture is based on the religious notion of “cult” from whence derives the best of human endeavors. Unfortunately, the novel depicts the realization of these efforts meaningless in the grand scheme of the universe when it’s revealed the Overlords merely are midwives to the next stage of human development, finally departing Earth while humankind’s last generation drifts away as cosmic snowflakes.

Further, the story goes, the Overlords’ satanic appearance and malignant reputation are merely archetypal misinterpretations imprinted on the memory of the human race. The maturation promised in the book’s title winds up negating such pinnacles of human plishment as the Bible, the Sistine Chapel, the Cathédrale Notre Dame de Paris, bined works of Dante and Shakespeare, and positions of Bach, Beethoven and the Beatles. Resistance to this cosmic puberty is futile as the planet’s last progeny develop telekinetic and telepathic abilities in the manner of the children in Lewis Padgett’s 1943 classic short story “Mimsy Were the Borogroves.” The adults in Clarke’s novel resign themselves to the Void and the world ends with neither a bang nor a whimper, but instead “a soundless concussion of light…. For a little while the gravitational waves crossed and re-crossed the Solar System, disturbing ever so slightly the orbits of the planets.”

Clarke possessed a brilliant scientific mind and a remarkable literary and visionary talent, but lacked insight into human resiliency and resourcefulness. Additionally, he was a bit premature in his negative assessments of the human race. As it turns out, we’ve endured the past 60-some years without help from the extraterrestrial Karellen and fellow Overlords, and we’ve largely avoided catastrophe while exceeding many of Clarke’s predictions for technological advancements, curing diseases and eradicating poverty without centralized supervision and other government schemes.

Most important, humanity retains access to those permanent things reified by the poets T.S. Eliot and David Jones and other Christian Humanists such as Christopher Dawson, Jacques Maritain, Russell Kirk and – notably referenced in Childhood’s End – Lord Acton and G.K. Chesterton. Civilization thrives wherever ordered liberty is enjoyed, absolute power abjured and the moral imagination blossoms. Our race may remain children in the opinion of Arthur C. Clarke’s Overlords, but we persist as God’s humble children, flourishing because we implement self-restraint in the exercise of our gift of free will.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Global warming and population control
From the “we had to destroy the village to save it” department, check out this item from the Huffington Post by Dave Johnson, “A Global Warming Suggestion: Fewer Babies.” It’s pretty indefatigable logic: if there are no people to be affected by environmental catastrophe, then the problem has been avoided. Johnson writes, “Yes, hundreds of millions of people will face water shortages and starvation by 2080 — but only if those hundreds of millions of people are alive in the...
“The university is totally ignoring diversity of thought”
Coming soon to a theater near you (hopefully) – Evan Coyne Maloney’s Indoctrinate U. From the film’s website: At colleges and universities across the nation, from Berkeley and Stanford to Yale and Bucknell, the charismatic filmmaker uncovers academics who use classrooms as political soapboxes, students who must parrot their professors’ politics to get good grades, and administrators who censor diversity of thought and opinion. With flair and wit, Maloney poses tough questions to America’s academics and university administrators — who...
Adam Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments
Kevin noted earlier this week that the UK has issued a paper bill featuring Adam Smith. I also received notice this week that the Adam Smith Review is planning a conference in January of 2009, celebrating the semiquincentennial (250th) anniversary of the publication of Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments. The conference announcement notes that scholarship has e to appreciate the importance of Smith’s moral philosophy for his overall intellectual project.” For more on just how Smith’s Theory of Moral Sentiments...
Google minds the gaps in statistical analysis
Google recently announced that it has purchased the Trendalyzer software from Gapminder, a Swedish non-profit (HT: Slashdot). Trendalyzer is the brain-child of professor Hans Rosling, who was lecturing on international development “when it struck him that statistics were an underexploited resource, often presented in an prehensible fashion. To solve the problem he developed – along with his son – a new kind of software.” One interesting aspect of this purchase is that the software’s inventor won’t profit from its sale,...
Private education and global health
Check out the links from this piece by Joe Knippenberg at No Left Turns, which make the case that “small-scale support for private slum schools—through scholarship programs, backing for school-voucher schemes, or subsidized microfinance—might do far more good than a big aid push directed at government-run education.” Combine that with the insights from this recent NBER paper, “The Effects of Education on Health,” which examines the “well known, large, and persistent association between education and health,” and you could reach...
‘Great Firewall’ not great enough
According to published reports, China is planning on adding new censorship regulations covering blogs and webcasts (HT). President Hu Jintao says the government needs to take these steps to “purify” the Internet, leading to “a more healthy and active Internet environment,” according to the Xinhua news agency. Estimates put the number of Internet police manning the “Great Firewall of China” at 30,000-40,000. To see if those cops are looking at a particular website, test it at GreatFirewallOfChina.org. You can also...
Evangelical environmentalism’s moral imperative
In this week’s Acton Commentary, I examine recent events surrounding the conflict amongst evangelicals over global warming political activism. In “Evangelical Environmentalism’s Moral Imperative,” pare the shape of the argument to the debate over the last decade on the topic of poverty. In the same way that conservatives were accused of not caring for the poor because they opposed an expansive welfare state, critics of climate change politics are being portrayed as not caring for the environment. To the extent...
Turnabout is fair play?
The nation which hosted a large conference ing Holocaust deniers last year is now full of righteous indignation over historical inaccuracies in the film ‘300’. As Azadeh Moaveni reports from her daily travels in Tehran, “Iranians buzzed with resentment at the film’s depictions of Persians, adamant that the movie was secretly funded by the U.S. government to prepare Americans for going to war against Iran.” (HT: Disorganizational Behavior) No word yet on whether the Athenians are upset over being called...
Adam Smith, the British Grant (or Jackson)
The title of this post is not intended to imply anything by way parison between Smith and the American gentlemen. It is only to report that the United Kingdom has launched a new 20£ note sporting the visage of the Father of Economics. Peter Heslam spins the news to good effect in a ment on Smith’s moral sensibility. To investigate that issue more thoroughly, see James Halteman’s 2003 article in the Journal of Markets & Morality. ...
EU conflicts of interest
The nearly decade-long battle between the European Union and Microsoft took another turn earlier this month, as the EU Commission offered a fresh threat to Microsoft: Submit to our demands or face stiff new penalties. The item at issue is an aspect of the 2004 ruling against Microsoft, in which “the Commission fined Microsoft and ordered it to provide petitors with information allowing them to develop workgroup server software interoperable Windows desktop operating system.” That ruling is still under appeal...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved