Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
America’s Prison System Doesn’t Work: Can We Fix It?
America’s Prison System Doesn’t Work: Can We Fix It?
Jun 29, 2026 4:14 AM

The numbers are discouraging: 1 in 28 American children has at least one parent in prison. Even though crime rates have dropped, our prison population has quadrupled; there are now about 2.4 million adults behind bars. It is costing us $80 billion a year to maintain our prison system. At one point, society thought that prison was about reform. We’ve all but dropped any pretense of reform; we’re just warehousing people.

Can we fix this?

One organization is trying. Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) would like to see changes in harsh mandatory minimum sentencing laws, many of which involve drug cases.

In 1990, Julie Stewart was public affairs director at the Cato Institute when she first learned of mandatory minimum sentencing laws. Her brother had been arrested for growing marijuana in Washington State, had pled guilty, and — though this was his first offense — had been sentenced to five years in federal prison without parole. The judge criticized the punishment as too harsh, but the mandatory minimum law left him no choice.

Motivated by her own family’s experience, Julie created Families Against Mandatory Minimums (FAMM) in 1991. Though her brother has long since left prison, has a beautiful family and a good job, Julie continues to lead FAMM in the fight for punishments that fit the crime and the offender.

Two senators, Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) and Mike Lee’s (R-Utah), would like to pass the Smarter Sentencing Act, aimed at giving judges more discretion in sentencing for drug cases, such as the one described above. FAMM wants to educate people as to how mandatory sentencing works. Congress, not judges, have created mandatory sentencing laws. Judges literally use a manual to figure out what sentence must be handed down.

The FAMM website highlights several individuals that they believe are suffering from overly-harsh sentences. FAMM does not claim that any of these people are innocent, but that they have been given sentences that do not fit the crime, and in each case, the judge’s hands were tied.

Mandy Martinson is serving 15 years in federal prison for helping her dealer-boyfriend in exchange for feeding her methamphetamine addiction. Mandy’s judge, unable to go below the mandatory minimum, expressed his objection to the sentence stating: “The Court does not have any particular concern that Ms. Martinson mit crimes in the future.” Mandy was able to achieve sobriety and get her old job back before her trial. Nevertheless, taxpayers are spending $420,000 to incarcerate the first-time, nonviolent offender for the mandatory 15 years – 3 years longer than the boyfriend will spend behind bars.

[T]he judge was forced to give Mandy a mandatory minimum of 10 years for the conspiracy and possession charges, and a mandatory five-year consecutive term for the gun charge, for a total sentence of 15 years behind bars.

Since her conviction, Mandy has pleted numerous additional treatment courses and remained drug free. She has been certified to operate heavy equipment, is taking a horticulture class, and is teaching a course onThe Purpose Driven Life. Mandy was selected to be panion to prisoners on suicide watch. “It is very frustrating to think I may have so many years left in prison,” says Mandy. “I am making the most of my time here, though. I know change ing. There are just way too many people like me incarcerated for way too long.”

Are sentences like this just and moral? Is prison reform something we are willing to take seriously? If our aim is to have a just society, there must be justice for all.

Read “The moral and political case for reforming the criminal justice system” at The Washington Post.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Dangerous To Be An American Woman? Not If We Take Responsibility For Ourselves, Each Other
Vox is telling us that it’s “dangerous to be a woman in America.” (The news is delivered in a creepy video where statistics are displayed via writing on a woman’s body. No objectification there…) They also want us to know that it may take a “nuclear option” to tackle sexual assault on college campuses. Enough. In the U.S., 1 out of 6 women will suffer some sort of sexual assault during her life. 73 percent of the time, she will...
6 Quotes: Roger Scruton on Conservatism
During student protests in Paris in 1968, Roger Scruton watched students overturn cars to erect barricades and tear up cobblestones to throw at police. It was at that moment he realized he was a conservative: I suddenly realized I was on the other side. What I saw was an unruly mob of self-indulgent middle-class hooligans. When I asked my friends what they wanted, what were they trying to achieve, all I got back was this ludicrous Marxist gobbledegook. I was...
The FAQs: The World’s Deadliest Environmental Problem
What is the world’s deadliest environmental problem? Householdair pollution. According to the World Health Organization’s latest report air pollution is now the world’s largest single environmental health risk, and the main cause is entirely preventable: Around 3 billion people still cook and heat their homes using solid fuels (i.e. wood, crop wastes, charcoal, coal and dung) in open fires and leaky stoves. Most are poor, and live in low- and e countries. Such inefficient cooking fuels and technologies produce high...
Russell Moore on Why Religious Liberty Matters
One of the most profound ironies in our current debates over religious liberty is the Left’s persistent decrying of business as short-sighted and materialistic even as it attempts to preventthe Hobby Lobbys of the world fromheeding their consciences and convictions. Business is about far more than some materialistic bottom line, but this is precisely why we need the protection for religious liberty. If we fail to promote religious liberty for businesses, how can we ever expect the marketplace to contribute...
Welfare, Work, and Dignity
Christians not only have a duty to work for virtue in their souls and the production of material goods in the world, writes Acton’ Dylan Pahman at Humane Pursuits, but also to encourage and enable others to fulfill this mandment. One might object that locating our self-worth in our work, even if only in part, is misguided. Our American, capitalist culture is overworked and work-obsessed, or so the story goes. We work so much and overvalue it to the point...
Don’t Buy The Lie: ‘Freedom To Worship’ Not The Same As Religious Liberty
It seems such a subtle distinction: “freedom to worship” as opposed to “religious freedom.” The phrase, “freedom to worship,” started appearing in 2010, and in 2013, President Obama made the following remarks in his address for the annual Proclamation for Religious Freedom Day: Foremost among the rights Americans hold sacred is the freedom to worship as we choose.” He then refers to the history of this right. “Because of this protection by our Constitution, each of us has the right...
Rule Of Law: Not Flashy, But Essential
It’s interesting to debate and share idea like freedom of speech, religious liberty or entrepreneurship. Helping folks in the developing world create and sustain businesses if exciting. Watching women who’ve been victimized by human trafficking or their own culture find ways to support themselves and their families is wonderful. But none of this happens without rule of law. Rule of law is not “sexy.” It doesn’t get the press of a brilliantly successful NGO. There are no great photo ops...
The Famine Remembered: Lessons from Ukraine’s Holodomor and Soviet Communism
This November marks the 25th anniversary of the fall of the Berlin Wall. This momentous occasion symbolizing the decline of Soviet Communism is sure to be met with joyous celebration, not only in Germany, but around the world. While November signifies Soviet Communism’s decline it memorates one of its darkest, most horrendous hours. Annually on the fourth Saturday of November, Ukrainians remember the brutal, man-made famine imposed on their country by Joseph Stalin and his Communist regime in the 1930s....
Reverend Robert Sirico: Why Liberty?
The Cato Institute, as part of this year’s recognition of Constitution Day, offers a series of videos featuring prominent scholars, educators and entrepreneurs answering the question, “Why Liberty?” Each has a different and personal perspective on the meaning and importance of liberty, both in the U.S. and abroad. Below, the Rev. Robert Sirico offers his answer to the question, “Why Liberty?” ...
How Economies Die
Samuel Gregg, Director of Research at Acton, recently reviewed Niall Ferguson’s latest, The Great Degeneration: How Institutions Decay and Economies Die. In the book, Ferguson discusses the symptoms of a decaying society and explains what causes rich economies to decline. Though the book is a short one and written for a nonspecialist audience, Ferguson develops a very strong case to illustrate how the hollowing out of the rule of law, the deterioration of representative government into soft despotism, the increasingly...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved