Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Acton Commentary: Obama Administration Leaves Human Trafficking Victims Out in the Cold
Acton Commentary: Obama Administration Leaves Human Trafficking Victims Out in the Cold
Feb 11, 2026 8:27 AM

“Most of us enjoy an economy where we can purchase with ease the things we need and enjoy. However, there is no moral justification for mercialization of some things; human beings are not products to be bought and sold,”writes Elise Hiltonin the latest Acton Commentary (published October 3).The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere.

Obama Administration Leaves Human Trafficking Victims Out in the Cold

By Elise Hilton

Imagine a teen girl: After a fight with her mom, she takes off. It happens a lot; maybe her mom drinks too much. The teenager’s winter afternoon walk leads nowhere in particular, until a man in a car stops. He asks if he can buy her something warm to drink, telling her she is too pretty to be out alone on a cold day. pliment is enough to get her in the car. She’s just e a trafficked person, snared into the sex trade.

Child or human trafficking is one of the fastest growing crimes in the world. The Department of Justice notes the average age of a child for entry into the sex trade is 12, and 300,000 American children are at risk annually for this crime.

Most of us enjoy an economy where we can purchase with ease the things we need and enjoy. However, there is no moral justification for mercialization of some things; human beings are not products to be bought and sold.

On September 25, President Obama launched a $6 million effort aimed at trafficking. “When a little girl is sold by her impoverished family — girls my daughters’ age — runs away from home, or is lured by the false promises of a better life, and then imprisoned in a brothel and tortured if she resists — that’s slavery,” he said. “It is barbaric, and it is evil, and it has no place in a civilized world.” He praised faith-based organizations bat trafficking.

There is a sick irony to this. Last year, the associate director for anti-trafficking services at the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops’ (USCCB) program, Hilary Chester, said her staff hoped that a strong record of aiding trafficked victims would keep federal funds flowing into the program. That was before the USCCB received an email stating that it would no longer receive government funds because the Catholic Church refuses to provide abortion, sterilization and artificial birth control to its employees or those the Church’s agencies serve.

The highly-regarded USCCB-administered program coordinated a network of organizations, many faith-based, overseeing $15 million in government funds, according to the National Catholic Register. Now, that money is gone. Maricella Garcia, of Catholic Charities in Little Rock, Ark., says her agency has stopped offering services to trafficked victims. “The grant that the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops had is that they provided direct assistance money,” she said. “That could help a victim pay for rent or help them pay for food. We don’t have that capability anymore.”

This is more than a bureaucratic decision to fund one agency over another. The Obama Administration is waging war against religious liberty, the HHS mandate its biggest gun. The mandate states that group health plans must cover “[FDA-]approved contraceptive methods, sterilization procedures, and patient education and counseling for all women with reproductive capacity. FDA approved contraception includes Plan B (morning after pill).” Organizations with moral objections to these procedures and medications face stiff financial penalties for pliance.

To date, more than 80 plaintiffs have filed suit against the mandate, not all Catholic. David Green, founder of the craft-store chain Hobby Lobby, joined the lawsuit, citing his evangelical Christian faith: “We simply cannot abandon our religious beliefs ply with this mandate.” Sixty-five Eastern Orthodox bishops have called for the rescinding of this mandate. Michael Milton, chancellor of Reformed Theological Seminary in North Carolina stated, “This is not a Catholic issue only. It is not a contraception issue. It is a religious liberty issue.”

Back to our teenage girl. Say she manages to escape a life that included beatings, starvation, imprisonment and prostitution. She will need counseling, a place to live, an education, means to support herself. Where can she turn? According to Obama’s new initiative, she can turn to a business-to-business network established to identify trafficking, or a research partnership at a university. Perhaps she’ll find help from the tourism industry where an awareness campaign has been promoted.

That’s absurd. The girl won’t find help from these places. The help she needs was to be found in the thousands of local and state agencies previously funded — now with nothing to offer. For many religious groups, there will be no more governmental funds to counsel her, help her get a GED, an apartment or put food in the cupboard. The Obama Administration has decided that above and beyond this care, there must be provisions for abortions, sterilization and artificial birth control. Although these agencies are closest to the problem, know the situation in their area, and are most familiar with how to help someone there, the HHS mandate says they can’t help at all, if they don’t offer services they find morally reprehensible. Unless the munity and private donors are able to fill in the substantial financial gap, most of these agencies that previously served trafficking victims will find themselves unable to offer help.

Where does that leave the girl? Just as vulnerable as she was before, walking down the street after a fight with her mother.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Milton Friedman, the School Choice Movement, and Moral Formation
July 31st marks the 100th birthday of the economist Milton Friedman. Celebrations planned by proponents of free-markets will take place across the country to recognize and pay tribute to his legacy and the power of his ideas. I am speaking at an Americans for Prosperity event in town on the topic of school choice on his birthday. mentary this week is on school choice. Nobody has influenced and shaped the school choice movement more than Friedman. In my piece, I...
Stopping the Young Business
A Holland, Mich., teenager is being stopped from opening a hotdog cart due to city zoning laws. It’s really disheartening when you consider the fact that this young person was trying to be responsible and work to help his family and build up savings for his future. In Work: The Meaning of Your Life, Lester DeKoster writes that work is a way in which we provide service to others—a service this teenager has been denied the chance to provide. The...
Are We Winning the War on (Spiritual) Poverty?
In America, too many of our citizens suffer from material poverty. But an even greater number suffer from spiritual poverty. Leon Kass asks, “How fares the struggle against our spiritual impoverishment? Are we Americans, despite our continuing freedom and prosperity, really losing the quest for meaningful lives?” It would be easy to argue that life in America is spiritually more impoverished than ever. As evidence, one might cite the rising respectability of public atheism and the falling off of religious...
A Jump on a Dark Knight
Last night, I went to see the newest “Batman” movie with my fellow Acton interns. I thought it was a great movie, and I mend seeing it and reading Jordan Ballor’s review of it. I also want to echo some of the themes that Jordan discussed in his piece. After the movie was done, it turned out that the people who had parked behind me were in need of a jump for their car. I didn’t know these people, but...
Samuel Gregg: The Economic Crisis and Europe’s Rule of Law Problem
Close attention to particular decisions by European institutions and governments, says Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg, suggests that many have significantly infringed the rule of law: Among the many non-economic factors shaping Europe’s current crisis, there is one which, despite its seriousness, has not yet received extensive attention: an emerging rule of law problem throughout the EU. Many will be taken aback by this claim. Isn’t Europe the continent where the very idea of the rule of law was first...
Rearranging the Deck Chairs on the Good Ship Liberalism
Over on the Library of Law and Liberty’s website, Acton Research Director Samuel Gregg reviews political philosopher John Tomasi’s new book Free Market Fairness: Rather than attempting a synthesis peting schools of liberal thought, Tomasi outlines what he is very careful to specify as a “hybrid” (87) political theory that draws upon classical liberalism and libertarianism on the one hand, and what he calls high or left liberalism on the other. Tomasi does not seek to somehow ground classical liberal...
ResearchLinks – 07.27.12
Call for Papers: “The Spirituality of the Heidelberg Catechism” June 21-22th 2013, an international conference will take place in Apeldoorn on The Spirituality of the Heidelberg Catechism. The Heidelberg Catechism has a characteristic spirituality, which will be explored from historical and theological perspectives, as part of memoration of the 450th anniversary of this Catechism. Call for Papers: “Scientiae 2013: Disciplines of Knowing in the Early Modern World” University of Warwick (UK), 18th-20th April 2013. The premise of this conference is...
Self-Appointed Nannys of the Nanny State
Economists have always been moralists, but since the mid-20th century many have also e wannabe technocrats—unelected experts who make public policy decisions based on specialized information rather than public opinion. A prime example is the new “libertarian paternalists” (a group that is definitely paternalistic but not very libertarian) who believe that government should attempt to influence the economic choices of affected parties in a way that will make choosers better off. In a review of Robert and Edward Skidelsky’s new...
Calming the Waters
In today’s “On the Square” over at First Things, Leroy Huizenga reflects upon “the technopoly” of our daily lives, where so much of our time is captivated by staring at puter screen, clicking links, reading posts, checking updates, and so on. Huizenga writes, I worry about ing a functional Gnostic, plugged into this new matrix, this new pixelated irreality. My reality easily es the screens, and the interactivity of hyperlinks means I can go where I will and create my...
Obama Erects Barriers to Business Growth
John Kennedy, President and CEO of Michigan-based Autocam, responded in an editorial to President Obama’s recent remarks regarding business owners and their success. Obama stated, “If you’ve got a business — you didn’t build that. Somebody else made that happen.” Kennedy responded: As a business founder, I particularly object to the claim, “If you’ve got a business – you didn’t build that. Somebody else made that happen.” I benefited from my dad, who helped instill the entrepreneurial spirit, when I...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved