Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
A Drug Price Jumped 5,000 Percent Overnight. Blame the Government, Not the Free Market
A Drug Price Jumped 5,000 Percent Overnight. Blame the Government, Not the Free Market
Dec 23, 2025 5:27 AM

In the early 1950s, the Nobel Prize-winning scientist Gertrude Elion developed the drug Daraprim bat malaria. Daraprim is now also used to fight toxoplasmosis, which infects people whose immune systems have been weakened by AIDS, chemotherapy and pregnancy. It’s such an important drug that it’s on the World Health Organization’s List of Essential Medicines, among the most important medications needed in a basic health system.

A single pill used to sell for $1, but the price was raised around 2010 to $13.50. Last week the price jumped 5,000 percent to $750 a tablet.

There was no shortage or other supply and demand factors that would justify the rapid price increase. Turing Pharmaceuticals had bought the drug from Impax Laboratories in August for $55 million and raised the price to cover their costs. Turing’s CEO Martin Shkreli said, “This isn’t the greedy pany trying to gouge patients, it is us trying to stay in business.”

The Infectious Diseases Society of America and the HIV Medicine Association disagree, saying “this cost is unjustifiable for the medically vulnerable patient population in need of this medication.”

Some people believe this incident is an example of the failures of free market capitalism, and claim this is why we need more government intervention. But the exact opposite is true: This is an example of government failure which the free market could solve.

The price system is one of God’s most under-appreciated creational norms. Prices provide an ingenious way for humans to distribute both knowledge and resources in a way that, on the whole, tends to increase human flourishing. This is why, generally speaking, we want to avoid distortions in the price system e with government intervention. In a free market that is free of distortions, the prices of products and services will shift as people clarify what values and priorities should take precedence in distributing resources.

But Daraprim is not sold in a free market. The pharmaceutical industry is largely a non-contestable market where a few large firms exist because of high barriers to entry, such as onerous government regulation. Added to this is the fact that Shkreli has a coercive monopoly on Daraprim, not because of patents (the patent on Daraprim expired long ago) but because few other firms want to make the drug since the government-imposed costs make it less than profitable.

What this means is that the prices of pharmaceuticals like Daraprim are not set by the free market. The free market isn’t the reason Shkreli was able to raise the price. In fact, if he had to sell his product in a truly free market environment the price would likely remain low. And even now, if he continued to keep the price high, some enterprising pany would start making Daraprim themselves, increasing the supply and lowering the cost.

But having other firms make the product is at best a long-term solution. What can be done about this situation now? Moral suasion appears to be the most effective solution. Public shaming can be a very effective tool, and it appears to have already caused Shkreli to agree to lower the price. He told NBC News his decision was a reaction to the public outrage:

“Yes it is absolutely a reaction — there were mistakes made with respect to helping people understand why we took this action, I think that it makes sense to lower the price in response to the anger that was felt by people,” Shkreli, 32, said.

Turing Pharmaceuticals of New York bought the drug from Impax Laboratories in August for $55 million and raised the price. Shkreli said Tuesday the price would be lowered to allow pany to break even or make a smaller profit.

Shkreli has the right to sell his product at a price that allows him to cover his costs and make a profit. But because he currently has a coercive monopoly in a non-free market, Shkreli also has a higher ethical duty to his customers. Additionally, he has an increased responsibility to correct for the price distortions that are caused by his holding a monopoly on the product.

Politicians and pundits will use this as an excuse to claim that the government needs to get more involved in correcting the price system—and in some ways they are right. In the long-term, if the federal government wants to lower the cost of pharmaceuticals it should reduce regulations that panies from creating drugs whose patents have already expired. But any short-term government action to “make sure this never happens again” will only result in harmful unintended consequences, such as further decreasing the creation of life-saving drugs.

In this situation, the government doesn’t need to step in at all. Even in the absence of free market pricing mechanisms the public square has found a way to distribute information and use moral persuasion to force Shkreli to lower the price of the drug.

To prevent these kinds of problems in the future, though, we need to increase access to free markets—not blame them for problems caused by the government.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Unlikely Mercenaries In The Fight Against Human Trafficking
A petite woman in pink, in a Filipino red-light district, is picked out by a “tourist” as a possible sex partner for the evening. A pimp panying him tells him she’s not a good choice. She’s a nun. The Mary Queen of Missionaries (MQHM) are a group of Catholic sisters who serve the sex workers in the Philippines. Their order was established solely for this purpose: To seek thestray and fallen away in the person of the victims of prostitution...
Upcoming Event: Common Grace in Business
Mark your calendars! On Friday, October 31, The Acton Institute and Calvin College’s Calvin Center for innovation in Business will present a Symposium on Common Grace in Business. This event will bring members of the faith, academic, and munities together to explore and consider Abraham Kuyper’s works mon grace and how it applies to various business disciplines. It will also celebrate the publication of the Acton Institute’s first translation of Kuyper’s works mon grace into English. It will take place...
The Fight Against Human Trafficking: Are Boys Being Left Out?
The face of human trafficking, for the public, is typically female and young. There is an assumption that females are the victims and males are perpetrators. But is this mindset keeping boys and young men from getting the help they need to escape human trafficking? The Juvenile Justice Information Exchange believes this is the case. While it appears that males make up about half of human trafficking victims, the numbers may be higher, especially for those involved in sex trafficking....
The Giver: Adding Color to a Monochromatic World
The Giver, a cinematic adaptation of Lois Lowry’s contemporary young adult classic, is great summer action-adventure entertainment. The film also serves as a terrific example for future moviemakers seeking to transfer themes of spiritual faith to celluloid without succumbing to preachiness and overwrought didacticism. Yes, The Giver is yet another dystopian sci-fi adventure story featuring handsome young protagonists rebelling against established A-list Hollywood stars portraying adult autocrats. But, unlike the silly, over-the-top political media and often disturbing ultraviolence of The...
Get a Free Rental of ‘For the Life of the World – The Church’
For the Life of the World: Letters to the Exilesisa 7-part series from the Acton Institute that seeks to examine the bigger picture of Christianity’s role in culture, society, and the world. The Gospel Coalition (TGC) ishighlighting an episode and sharing an exclusive codefor a free 72-hour rental of the full episode. Here’s the trailer for episode 7,The Church. Visit TGC to get thecode for the free rental(you have to apply the code today, but once you do the rental...
Customers More Forgiving of Businesses with Religious Affiliation
Whenever I get a craving for a chicken sandwich and waffle fries, it’s invariably on Sunday—the one day a week when Chick-fil-A is closed. Rather than e frustrated by the closure, though, I appreciate that Truett Cathy, the founder of Chick-fil-A, was motivated by his religious beliefs to give his employees a day of rest. It turns out I’m not the only one. “I am from the South and there is pany called Chick-fil-A, and they are known for their...
Why We Get Stewardship Wrong
Christians frequently talk about “stewardship,” but what do we mean when we use that term? And more importantly, what should we mean by it? At The Gospel Coalition, Stephen J. Grabill,director of programs and international for the Acton Institute, discusses what it means to havea holistic understanding of stewardship and what it means to “make the kingdom of God visible and tangible to the world”: Although Christians across denominational lines often use stewardship language to describe our calling to live...
Borger on FLOW: A ‘Visually Enjoyable’ and ‘Thoughtfully Inspiring’ Series
Over at Capital Commentary, Byron Borger offers some valuable reflections and rather extensive praise for the Acton Institute’s new educational DVD series, For the Life of the World: Letters to the Exiles. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen such a visually enjoyable Christian educational video curriculum,” he writes, “and I know I’ve never seen one so thoughtfully inspiring about a foundational Christian view of creation, culture, social life, and redemption.” Indeed, FLOW offers a peculiar blend of artistic beauty and...
Do Leaders of the Religious Left Really Care About Climate Change?
A few weeks ago I wrote about how some leaders of the religious left were supporting the EPA’s proposed new regulations on greenhouse gas emissions from existing fossil fuel-fired electric generating units. At the time I wrote, “While there may be some religious liberals who have been duped into thinking the new proposals will actually affect climate change, most are just signaling their allegiance to the Obama administration and the Democratic Party.” After I wrote that sentence I wondered if...
The Test of Self-Interest: Letting God Choose For You
“To draw near to listen is better than to offer the sacrifice of fools, for they do not know that they are doing evil.” –Ecclesiastes 5:1 Obedience to God is a fundamental requirement of the Christian life. With our constant recitations of “thy will be done,” it may seem a rather obvious point, but while many of us fortable with the basic aims and directives of the Gospel –feed the poor, serve the needy, steward your talents, love your enemies...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved