Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
5 reasons your local newspaper (probably) deserves your money
5 reasons your local newspaper (probably) deserves your money
Aug 27, 2025 4:06 PM

In the past five years, one out of every five newspapers nationwide has closed and half of all newsroom employees have been laid off, according to the University of North Carolina’s School of Media and Journalism. The question is why should you care? Everything takes its course, and then something else takes its place. In this case, social media and national television networks are running small, local newspapers out of business. But the truth is that these new media sources are feeding you more than news: They’re feeding you unprecedented amounts of cortisol and dopamine.

These modern news sources build their business model around keeping the users stuck scrolling their platform. To do this, they need to provoke strong emotions. Researchers have proved that the strongest emotion is anger. Hence, the more that news sources show you radical, polarizing, and anger-inducing news, the more you scroll.

These news outlets have rendered tremendous services, as well. They have brought the entire world’s news to the palm of your hand. But their triumph too es at the expense of local news outlets. Here are five reasons why local news outlets protect our democratic society.

1. Higher trust and accountability

Local journalists are usually from the munity as their readers. They and their families are involved munity social activities. Because they are sharing the news with – and about – their friends and family, they hold themselves to a higher standard of excellence and credibility. Last August, the Poynter Media Trust Survey found that 76% of Americans said they have a “great deal” or “fair amount” of trust in their local television station, while only 55% of Americans said they trusted the national news networks.

2. Subsidiarity

Local institutions and governments have greater insight about their region than those who live farther away. Hence, they are equipped to make better decisions – a concept known as subsidiarity. Local news outlets have local connections that give them access to information firsthand, far more than more distant media outlets. In a democratic society, we assure that our leaders make the right choices by learning about munity’s issues, following the local political process, and voting in each election cycle for the members of local bodies like city councils and school boards. This begins with trustworthy information about our cities and counties.

3. Comprehensive investigations

There’s ample reason to believe that local news outlets are the best and most prolific investigators in the country. Even though local news outlets make up 25% of the nation’s total media sources, they produce almost half of the nation’s original reporting, according to a study by the Duke University. A prominent example is the Jeffrey Epstein sex scandal, which was exposed by Julie Brown of the Miami Herald. The missioner mended her efforts. But even after exposing one of the biggest scandals in the country – and showing a stronger social and moral responsibility than larger media outlets – the Miami Herald is struggling financially.

4. Complete truth vs. selective reporting

Another important factor to consider when choosing your news source is it is giving you plete truth or selective reporting. As local news outlets shut down, Americans are relying more on national news media outlets to make political decisions. As these outlets have politicized their coverage, the nationalization of news sources has led to a substantial polarization, according to a study published by the Oxford University Press. Local news sources tend to be much less polarizing than national news outlets by presenting more facts and fewer opinions, the study found.

5. Protecting the future of democracy

Local news is vital to upholding democratic values. The problem is evident: Without local news you, the citizen, e less informed about the challenges in munity. Our leaders also get blindsided, because they do not receive feedback from their munity regarding the most immediate issues facing munity.

The death of so many news outlets means that people have fewer choices, and the points of view expressed e constricted. Congress charged the Federal Communications Commission with maximizing “the public interest, convenience, or necessity.” Losing the investigations, stories, and fact-rich reporting of local news poses a looming threat to our discussion of national and local issues – and the decisions that flow from those debates.

Social media and national news media outlets expose us to much information and news, but often at the risk of losing greater perspectives. Their business model relies on provoking anger and stimulating our natural tendency to react rather than to learn. This cortisol-producing news ultimately grounds us down to the mon denominator and does not give us the wisdom necessary for discernment.

The media should not be bailed out by the government. Instead, those of us who support local news outlets need to support them and help them help us.

domain.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
St. Joseph the Worker
Today is the feast of St. Joseph the Worker: Work is a good thing for man-a good thing for his humanity-because through work man not only transforms nature, adapting it to his own needs, but he also achieves fulfilment as a human being and indeed, in a sense, es “more a human being”. For the rest of this encyclical, Laborem Exercens, click here. ...
The iron law of unintended consequences
A report from the road: I’m in Colorado Springs this week, and I noticed this note taped to the wall of the bathroom in my spartan lodgings at the local Ramada Inn: Due to restrictions made by the City of Colorado Springs, the toilets have reduced water pressure and may not flush as well as you are accustomed to. In order to prevent the toilet from stopping up, please flush the toilet as frequently as possible while using it. Thank...
Alarmist profiteering
Remember when I said that I thought there is a dangerous incentive in climate change research to make things seem worse than they are? (If not, that’s OK. I actually called it an “analogous phenomenon” to the possibility that AIDS statistics are exaggerated.) Well, TCS Daily reports that a letter to Canadian PM Stephen Harper signed by over 60 scientists asks a similar question. Richard Lindzen, Sloan Professor of Atmospheric Science at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT), wonders, “How...
The morality of narrative imagination
While doing research for my ing lecture at the Drexel University Libraries’ Scholarly Communication Symposium, I ran across this excellent book by Janet H. Murray, Hamlet on the Holodeck: The Future of Narrative in Cyberspace (New York: Free Press, 1997). Dr. Murray at that time was a professor at MIT and is now at Georgia Tech. One of the interesting things that Dr. Murray discusses is the necessary element of what she calls “moral physics” in narrative worlds. She writes,...
Evangelicals and Earth Day
Check out my Detroit News column today, “Humanity’s creativity helps environment,” in which I give a brief overview of the conflicting evangelical views of environmental stewardship. ...
Economic turmoil in Zimbabwe
Where in the world would you pay $145,750 for a roll of toilet paper? According to an article in the New York Times, inflation in Zimbabwe is soaring higher than ever — about 900 percent since President Mugabe began seizing land from wealthy landowners in 2000. And inflation is climbing at unparalleled rates. What problems result from such rampant inflation? If inflation is climbing daily and you have $100 one day, it might be worth only $90 the next. People...
The ‘gospel’ of Judas
Over at OrthodoxyToday.org, Fr. Theodore Stylianpoulos demolishes the media driven speculation that the so-called Gospel of Judas might somehow turn traditional Christianity on its head. The Gospel of Judas is but another small window to Gnosticism, a hodgepodge of religious speculations that exploded on the scene during the second century. At that time, individual intellectuals or small and elitist groups around them, bothered by the basic story of the Bible, especially the violent God of the Old Testament and the...
Wanted: a Duke lacrosse team hero
Duke University is embroiled in a sensational scandal involving its lacrosse team and allegations of sexual assault of a stripper at a wild party. But, as Anthony Bradley points out, the case is really symptomatic of a much larger problem in American society. “Why is there no national outrage about the fact that two adult women subjected themselves to voyeuristic, live pornography?” he asks. “What kind of men do we raise in America that they would even want to hire...
How do you spell relief?
You may have heard about the debate in Washington that erupted late last week, as Senate Democrats and Republicans sought ways to respond to rising gas prices. According to Marketplace’s Hillary Wikai, the majority Republicans settled on “a $100 gas-tax rebate to be paid for by drilling in Alaska’s Wildlife Refuge.” Michigan Democrat Debbie Stabenow proposed “a $500 rebate but pay for it by cutting the tax breaks for panies.” She said, “We should instead put that money back in...
Acton scholars in the news
Several Acton scholars will be on network cable this weekend to speak about current affairs in the United States. Andrew Yuengert, author of the “Inhabiting the Land” monograph (pictured at left), and Fr. Paul Hartmann will be interviewed on Raymond Arroyo’s “The World Over” news show on EWTN at 8:00 p.m. EST, Friday, April 28. Anthony Bradley (pictured at right) will be on “Heartland with John Kasich” on Fox News at 8:00 p.m. EST, Saturday, April 29, to speak about...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved