Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Welfare Spending Equals $47,000 and a Ford Fiesta Per Family
Welfare Spending Equals $47,000 and a Ford Fiesta Per Family
Oct 30, 2025 11:25 AM

When es to proving support for those in poverty, a significant number of economists, politicians, and pundits support direct transfer of money—just giving the poor cash.

There are many moral and practical reasons I think that option is a suboptimal means of aiding the poorest of our neighbors. But it does have one substantial benefit: It’d be much cheaper and efficient than current welfare programs.

As Daniel Halper at The Weekly Standard points out, the Senate Budget Committee finds that the amount of money spent on welfare programs equals, when converted to cash payments, about “$168 per day for every household in poverty.”

According to the Senate Budget Committee:

parison, the median household e in 2011 of $50,054 equals $137.13 per day. Additionally, spending on federal welfare benefits, if converted into cash payments, equals enough to provide $30.60 per hour, 40 hours per week, to each household living below poverty. The median household hourly wage is $25.03. After accounting for federal taxes, the median hourly wage drops to between $21.50 and $23.45, depending on a household’s deductions and filing status. State and local taxes further reduce the median household’s hourly earnings. By contrast, welfare benefits are not taxed.

At the current rate, we could give every family on welfare $61,320 a year (and that would be tax free). The federal poverty threshold for a family of four (two parents, two children) is only $23,550. If we just gave them cash we could give every family on welfare twice the amount needed to bring them out of poverty and still have enough left over to give each family a new Ford Fiesta Sedan (MSRP: $13,995) every year.

Obviously, I don’t think direct cash payments are the most effective form of poverty relief since they provide significant disincentives to work (at $47,000 and new car a year, I might be tempted to go on welfare too). But it highlights just how inefficiently our government is at poverty reduction. If we truly care about the poor, we should find a more effective—and efficient—means passion.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
The Manchurian Candidate Is a Neglected Masterpiece
Whether it truly caught the zeitgeist or was merely an entertaining, star-filled thriller, the original adaptation of the Richard Condon novel munist infiltration of the government bears revisiting, although not remaking. Read More… In 1959, when Richard Condon published his political thriller The Manchurian Candidate, he took a topical idea and ran amok with it. The idea was that during the Korean War a platoon of GIs had been captured by the Chinese, brainwashed (“not just washed, but dry-cleaned”), and...
USC Squanders an Opportunity to Form Fraternities
In responding to reports of sexual misconduct on campus, the University of Southern California had a choice to make in regard to the moral formation of its young men. They blew it. Read More… Eight fraternities recently disaffiliated from the University of Southern California following the university’s response to allegations of horrible sexual assaults on campus in 2021. During the fall semester of 2021, there were several reports of girls being drugged and sexually assaulted at fraternity events. USC delayed...
The Inflation Reduction Act Won’t Reduce Inflation
But you knew that already. Read More… President Biden has signed the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), his attempt at delivering on his campaign promises of new investments bat climate change, improve healthcare, and impose “fair” corporate taxes. The IRA is a revival of the now defunct and unpopular Build Back Better (BBB) Act, ushered in at a whopping $3.5 trillion. Penn Wharton estimates that the IRA will reduce cumulative budget deficits by $264 billion over the 10-year budget window. The...
Free Enterprise Is Saving African Lives
The statistics are clear: It’s oft-maligned capitalism that’s given Africans a near-miraculous increase in life expectancy. Read More… For years, Africa has dominated the podium in the “bad healthcare” Olympics. For reference, the average cost for an established patient and Medicare recipient to make one visit to a family practice in Pennsylvania (where I live) is approximately $88—the cost of less than a week’s worth of groceries. Yet for years, men and women living in most Sub-Saharan African countries couldn’t...
Progressives Remember COVID but Refuse to Learn from It
A new book by NPR’s education correspondent looks at the baleful effects of the COVID lockdowns on kids and their families, yet has no one to blame but…you guessed it. Read More… There are three ways to look back at the first year of the COVID pandemic. The first is to learn from the whole experience. Recall the fear, pain, and misery brought on by lockdowns, mask mandates, and social distancing, as well as the deaths that could have been...
Our Lady of the Artilects Makes AI Catholic Cool
A new novel does more than just hint at the transcendent: It introduces explicitly Catholic themes and history into a tale of man’s godlike attempt to create new life. Read More… The idea of personal identity and sentience in artificial intelligences (AI) is not exactly new territory for the science fiction genre: from Neuromancer to Westworld, writers frequently contemplate the ideas of agency and moral status in close-to-human, artificially engineered agents and environments. Those themes, in fact, are almost pelling...
The Anarchists Is a Case Study in the Decadence of Autonomy
A new HBO Max series takes a look at the tragic implosion of munity of self-described anarchists who “escaped” statist America for freedom in Mexico. Tragedy ensues. Read More… I have a reasonably high tolerance for fortable television and movies, maybe a higher tolerance than I should, but the first thing I would say about the HBO Max seriesThe Anarchistsis that it is not for the faint of heart. In this case, though, the tough stomach required is not due...
How Cars Can Keep Us Human
Does technology have its own moral code? And if so, does it influence ours? Why agency and action are essential to remaining fully human. Read More… Truck drivers are cowboys. I work at a food warehouse. Truckers show up with 40,000 pounds of primal-cut beef, equivalent to maybe 50 head of cattle, driven from Nebraska, by a team of horses, bit, bridled, and reined by bustion. I don’t actually spend a lot of time around these guys, but it’s pretty...
North Korea Crushes Its People as Nuclear Capacity Expands
A new report delivers brutally frank details about the extent of North Korea’s systemic human rights abuses. The West’s focus on the DPRK’s nuclear program is understandable, but can the Kim dynasty be stopped from getting away with murder? Read More… North Korea’s chief notoriety is its nuclear program. Another nuclear test is expected soon.The Rand Corporation and Asan Institutepredictthat by 2027, the North “could have 200 nuclear weapons and several dozen intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) and hundreds of theater...
Godard Is Dead. Is Cinema?
One of the founding filmmakers of the French New Wave enraptured, confounded, and infuriated audiences, critics, and filmmakers. But no one was better at capturing the nihilistic moment of the late ’60s. Read More… Jean-Luc Godard died on September 13, 2022, and the news in the world of cinema and culture was received as confirmation that cinema itself was dead. Godard had a remarkable influence on cinema in the ’60s, but his fame went beyond that. He replaced the aged...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved