Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Should credit-card interest be capped at 15%?
Should credit-card interest be capped at 15%?
Nov 17, 2026 12:18 AM

Democratic presidential primary contender Senator Bernie Sanders and Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez have unveiled a plan to cap credit-card interest rates at 15%:

Under the “Loan Shark Prevention Act,” the annual percentage rate applicable to any extension of credit would not be allowed surpass 15% on “unpaid balances, inclusive of all finance charges” or “the maximum rate permitted by the laws of the State in which the consumer resides.”

Consumer debt, and credit card debt in particular, is something many Americans struggle with and both the amount of total debt as well as the interest rates have escalated in recent years:

The median credit-card interest rate was 21.36% as of last pared with 12.62% a decade ago,according to . Meanwhile, Americans collectively hold more than $1 trillion in credit-card debt,according to the Federal Reserve.

Many churches have sought to help those struggling with debt. Recently City Church in Evansville, Indiana has helped pay off $1.5 million in medical debt for families at or below the poverty level. Countless churches have hosted programs educating their congregations munities about strategies to get out of debt and attain financial independence such as those from Dave Ramsey and Crown Financial Ministries. Should the government have a role?

Voters of both parties seem to think so:

Nearly 70% of Republican primary voters and 73% of Democratic primary voters said they either support or strongly support the proposal to cap rates at 15%, according to a new INSIDER poll. Just over 60% of respondents who don’t plan to vote in the 2020 presidential primaries also said they support the bill, known asthe Loan Shark Prevention Act.

It should be noted that there is a long tradition in mon and positive law of the government intervening when debt es unmanageable, bankruptcy. In his book For God and Profit, Sam Gregg describes the process :

Bankruptcy is the process by which an insolvent person pany is declared by law to be unable to meet his financial obligations. As a result, the bankrupt’s property is vested in the courts or some other designated legal trustee who has the responsibility to divide it among the bankrupt’s creditors. Bankruptcy law also normally prevents seizure of things that bankrupts require to earn e or to maintain their families.

Bankruptcy law seeks to reconcile two principles. The first is that, as far as possible, people receive what they are owed in light of the inability of others to pay back all that they owe. The second is that no fulfillment of promises obliges any party to the contract to accept conditions that violate human dignity.

Bankruptcy is a process designed to balance the interests of debtors and lenders when debt es unmanageable. There is also a long Christian tradition of prohibition on usury,the charging ofexcessive interest. Just what constitutes excessive interest is a difficult prudential question. The difficultly is even acknowledged in the Loan Shark Prevention Act itself:

The bill would also give the Federal Reserve flexibility to allow lenders to charge higher rates if it’s determined the federal cap “would threaten the safety and soundness of financial institutions.”

So it is a cap… except when the soundness of lenders are determined to be threatened. It attempts to do what bankruptcy does through long established procedures and precedence in a juridical context… except on the fly and determined by lenders and regulators. This seems like a recipe for crony capitalism, regulatory capture, and rent seeking.

If those risks could be avoided, and that’s a big IF, a cap on interest rates would certainly benefit consumers that carry credit card debt and large banks and firms which are better able to leverage economies of scale. Consumers who use credit cards but do not carry credit card debt would see less enticing “Rewards” programs as margins tightened and smaller banks and firms, less well positioned to reduce their margin, would reduce their lending or exit the credit market entirely.

I am generally against the use of credit and believe government has distorted incentives to increase credit usage, so I am sympathetic to some lending restrictions. At the same time I currently benefit from the system as constructed. I use a credit card which charges above the median rate on which I do not carry a balance. I get 10 cents off every gallon of gas and periodic gift certificates which I use for groceries. The card is branded as the retailer’s but is actually that of a third party bank. Is the relief some would receive at rates of 14.99% worth the trade off of a potentially less open petitive lending market? Would large firms use their considerable resources to influence regulators to allow them to go over the cap?

These are tough questions which I am not certain Senator Sanders and Representative Ocasio-Cortez have thought through. Their proposal, however, is a e invitation to do so and they are right that American consumers seem to be in a perilous debt spiral. In the mean time, we can all begin taking some baby steps to achieve our own financial security and independence.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Tag, we’re all it!
The book tag meme has made the rounds of the blogosphere, and here I was sitting, eagerly awaiting someone to tag me. This will have to do. Thanks to Jimmy Akin for tagging “all the bloggers reading this who haven’t already been infected by the meme.” Total number of books I own: In the hundreds. We just moved so many are still in boxes, and I haven’t counted recently. But I tend not to get rid of a book if...
Where are Matt and Brandon?
In response to the title of this post, you might reply: “Who cares?” I’ll tell you why you should perhaps care who these guys are and where they are. Matt and Brandon are two Michigan natives who mitted to running across the continental U.S. These two Christians (Brandon is a freshman at Cornerstone University in Grand Rapids, and Matt teaches at Montego Bay Christian Academy in Jamaica) are making the run for charity, Water for Children Africa. I’ve never heard...
A report from symposium
The first Acton Institute Summer Symposium was held last week, and John H. Armstrong, president of Reformation & Revival Ministries, gives a report. Here’s an excerpt: The group I am attending is titled, “Business, Faith and Ethics.” It is part of Acton’s Center for Entrepreneurial Stewardship. I have been in a room with twenty-five successful business entrepreneurs and one other mission related person, a leader in the Christian Reformed Church. This is not my normal venue so it has been...
Aid to Africa
With the G8 countries preparing to cancel $40 billion in debt owed by several African countries, a fresh start is promised. But what has really changed? Check out mentary related to African aid and debt forgiveness at blog.acton.org. Here you can find an interview with the Rt. Rev. Bernard Njoroge, bishop of the diocese of Nairobi in the Episcopal Church of Africa, and a member of the Constitution of Kenya Review Commission, and Chanshi Chanda, chairman of the Institute of...
Day and Sirico: Common Ground?
This post at a blog hosted by the Ratzinger Fan Club, Against the Grain, gives a brief overview of the “preferential option for the poor” in Catholic Social Teaching. In the process, Christopher writes, Fr. Robert Sirico’s approach strikes me as being suprisingly close to Dorothy Day’s — at least in spirit, if not in policy. Browse through her extensive writings and you’ll encounter a strong believer in personal responsibility and self-empowerment, highly critical of state-sanctioned welfare and handouts which...
Gifts that keep on giving
Having been tagged by Kathryn at Suitable for Mixed Company, I duly submit my list within the guidelines of the following (and pledge not to repeat any placed on my initial list): Imagine that a local philanthropist is hosting an event for local high school students and has asked you to pick out five to ten books to hand out as door prizes. At least one book should be funny and at least one book should provide some history of...
Running the numbers
Recent news about debt relief for poor African nations might give the impression that governmental corruption, inefficiency, and irresponsibility are unique to developing countries. This is simply not so. Take, for example, the situation of the United States government. As of June 14, 2005, the total outstanding U.S. public debt is $7,804,534,405,437.48. That amounts to a share of debt for each U.S. citizen of just over $26,000. ...
The free and easy charity of the ‘One Campaign’
The One Campaign, an advocacy group formed by international relief agencies that is promoting greater U.S. spending on foreign aid, has drawn support from prominent evangelical Christians and a pack of celebrities including U2’s Bono. But Anthony Bradley observes that the campaign, with its focus on greater governmental action rather than personal sacrifice, “promotes a depersonalized and sterile form of help characteristic of the secular appeal to radical individualism.” Read the full text here. ...
‘This Fierce Spirit of Liberty’
As noted in an earlier post, this week is marks the 790th anniversary of the signing of the Magna Carta. Five years ago, Religion & Liberty published a series of essays on foundational documents in the history of Western civilization, or, as Edmund Burke called it, “this fierce spirit of liberty.” The first of these essays was on the Magna Carta, “In the Meadow That Is Called Runnymede.” Here are the others: John Milton’s Areopagitica, “The Liberty to Know, to...
Freedom carved in stone
Reuven Hammer writes about the rabbinic interpretation of the Ten Commandments in a Jerusalem Post article titled, “On Judaism: True Freedom” (Posts prior to 2010 have been deleted). He talks about a contemporary understanding of freedom as something that is simply free of all constraint. We moderns tend to see freedom as the ability to do whatever we want whenever we want and to view any limitations on that as tyranny or slavery. The rabbis seem to be saying exactly...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved