Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Regulators drop their beef with McDonald’s
Regulators drop their beef with McDonald’s
Jan 29, 2026 10:05 AM

A particularly harmful Obama-era labor rule, designed to fill union coffers while harming small business owners, ing to an end. In a rule to be published tomorrow, the National Labor Relations Board mon sense and balances the scales of justice.

The NLRB rule rejects union demands that the national headquarters of a franchise be punished for labor mitted by local franchisees.

The trigger came when local McDonald’s owners allegedly fired employees trying to unionize their workforce. The NLRB ruled plaints at only 0.5 percent of McDonald’s 14,000 franchises had any merit. But in December 2014, the NLRB faulted the national franchisor, McDonald’s USA, alongside its franchisees.

For decades, the federal government held that the national office could only be held liable for actions in its local franchises if it qualified as a “joint employer” – that is, if it exercised “direct and immediate control” over a location’s employees. Otherwise, the local franchisee would be held responsible for his or her actions, not the franchise name that happened to hang over the drive thru.

But in the Obama years the NLRB, at the urging of the Service Employees International Union, changed the standard to “indirect control.”

Why did the Obama administration change the rule? It wanted to super-size labor unions.

First, the newer, laxer standard would allow anyone who has a beef with a local McDonald’s manager to sue the corporation itself. That kind of financial jackpot would prove more tempting to unscrupulous lawyers than the establishment’s crispy, golden fries. Shaking down the Golden Arches for a pot of gold would clog the nation’s court systems more effectively than (insert menu item of choice).

Second, the SEIU spent an estimated $182 million trying to organize the fast food industry, with little success. SEIU organizers hope that McDonald’s USA will sign a “neutrality agreement,” which silences employers from presenting the negative points of union membership. They also often give unions employees’ home addresses, and contain “card check” provisions that eliminate employees’ right to a secret ballot when deciding whether to unionize. If the national headquarters is a “joint employer,” it can bind all of its franchises at once.

Both of these goals would be windfalls for organized labor, which has seen its numbers decimated in the wake of the Supreme Court’s Janus v. AFSCME ruling, giving workers greater choice in union representation. The SEIU lost 94 percent of agency shop employees, who chose not to join the 1.9-million-member union but were forced to pay union dues anyway.

The thought of unionizing fast food workers makes organizers’ mouths water. The industry’s high turnover rate means they can collect a regular flow of new membership dues, while doing little to benefit workers during the time they work the fryer or fire the guacamole gun. The Capital Research Center calculated that unions would collect $155 million by organizing McDonald’s, including “$45 million in from initiation fees alone.”

Collecting tens of millions of dollars for nothing? They’re lovin’ it. But the unions’ meal deal would not be appetizing for small business owners or employees.

The new incentive to file lawsuits would drive up business insurance, placing the dream of owning their own business out of reach of the middle class. To stave off lawsuits, the national headquarters will micromanage local businesses or preemptively deny agreements to those with little business experience. Meanwhile, the SEIU’s “Fight for $15” campaign would cost between 1.3 million and 3.7 million jobs, many of them at McDonald’s. Nearly 98 percent of people making minimum wage are under the age of 24, trying to break into the labor market. Aiding well-heeled unions at the cost of the poor, the young, and the middle class hardly sounds like social justice.

The greatest offense the federal labor bureaucracy’s action would inflict is its offense against justice – a word often misinterpreted by the measure’s supporters. The lax NLRB rule would allow unions and lawyers to plunder anyone tied to the nation’s 800,000 franchise locations, although they had neither participation nor, perhaps, knowledge of the offense. The Bible condemns this in the words of the prophet Ezekiel:

The soul that sins shall die. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, nor shall the father bear the iniquity of the son. The righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the iniquity of the transgressor shall be upon him (Ezekiel 18:20).

The SEIU’s standard confuses the actions of one person to damage the reputation of another. New York City Mayor Bill de Blasio used a similar sleight-of-hand on New Year’s Eve, when he bashed Domino’s for the actions of one of its franchisees.

Thankfully, the issue is temporarily at rest. The Trump administration dropped the court case, three years into its administration, and hammered out a settlement last December. The NLRB will codify the traditional understanding of the relationship into law.

Fast food franchisees can stop worrying about federal regulatory overreach and focus on the job we ask of them – like fixing the ice cream machine.

Blue. This photo has been cropped. CC BY 2.0.)

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Event: Economic Freedom and the State
Michael Miller, a Research Fellow and Director of Media at the Acton Institute, will be participating in an economy panel discussion held on April 17th at 7pm in the Wege Ballroom of Aquinas College in Grand Rapids, Mich.The focus of the discussion will be economic freedom and the proper role of the state and the individual in creating and preserving conditions necessary for human flourishing and prosperity. As Lord Acton stated, “liberty is the delicate fruit of a mature civilization.”...
Commentary: The Left Resumes Its War on History
Did you know Che Guevara was at heart an Irish freedom fighter? In this week’s Acton Commentary (published April 11), Samuel Gregg looks at how the left “has been remarkably successful in distorting people’s knowledge of Communism’s track-record.” The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publications here. The Left Resumes Its War on History bySamuel Gregg What does an Argentine-born Cuban Communist revolutionary executed in the Bolivian jungle 45...
Up Next on AU Online
Join us as we e Mr. Jeffrey Tucker for the AU Online presentation of his popular lecture, The Nature and Function of Money. The online session is scheduled for Monday April 16 at 6:30pm ET. In this lecture, Mr. Tucker explores the centrality of money to market economics, its origins, the history of its development, and its functions in modern economic life. Visit auonline.acton.org for more information or to register. Mr. Tucker is a speaker, writer, organizer, and technology/cultural pundit...
Bubba’s Vocation is Golf, But His First Priority is the Gospel
On Sunday Bubba Watson, one of the most untraditional golfers on the PGA Tour, was the surprise winner of the 2012 Masters Tournament. But while golf may be his vocation, it isn’t Watson’s top priority. What he considers most important can be gleaned from the description on his Twitter account:”@bubbawatson: Christian. Husband. Daddy. Pro Golfer. Owner of General Lee 1.” Among the 39,000-plus messages he’s sent into the Twittersphere, he’s sure to spread the Gospel message: God made everything &...
How Religion Is Portrayed In Video Games
Danny O’Dwyer of Gamespot has created an interesting video on religion in video games. As a self-described atheist, he examines the reasons why video games “haven’t reached the point where Islam can be portrayed without a suicide bomb.” The video also looks at various instances of religion in existing games and includes an interview with his Muslim friend Tamoor who works in the game journalism industry. You can watch his 15 minute video below. Danny’s article over at Gamespot has...
Getting Hip to Bruce Springsteen’s Ruse
On his albums Bruce Springsteen may pose as a working-class hero. But as Bruce Edward Walker notes, in his real life he’s a crony corporatist: Add in the concert receipts and song royalties, and you have a guy with an estimated net worth of $250 million who shouldn’t have too much trouble making the mortgage on his 200-acre plot in Joisey and other properties valued well over $5 million. Poor Bruce and family pay $138,000 each year for taxes on...
Hope and The Hunger Games
The Hunger Games may lack a single reference to religion or God, but as Jordan J. Ballor and Todd Steen point out in an article for First Things, the books and film presents a secularized alternative to the Christian virtue of hope: The only hope that the residents of Panem have is in themselves. The best they can hope for is that perhaps someone might repay a good deed with one in return. As readers of the novel or viewers...
Video: Eric Metaxas on Bonhoeffer, the Church and Politics
Eric Metaxas, author of the recently published biography Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy, sat down with the Alliance Defense Fund to speak on the role of the church in public policy and how Dietrich Bonhoeffer’s example is especially relevant today. Metaxas, also the author of a biography on William Wilberforce, is slated to deliver a lecture at Acton University on June 14 and the keynote address at the Acton Institute’s Annual Dinner on October 24th. Click on the links to...
‘I’m Rich and You’re Not. So There.’
Scientific American has announced that rich people aren’t nice. In fact, they are passionate, more unfair and greedier than poor people. These allegations are based on the findings of two Berkeley psychologists, Paul Piff and Dacher Keltner. There were a number of studies involved, and some significant problems are evident. For instance, Scientific American reports that factors “we know passionate feelings, such as gender [and] ethnicity” were controlled. However, there is no explanation as to how gender or ethnicity passion....
Student Debt and Moral Responsibility
The Obama administration has placed a high priority on making higher education affordable. In January, President Obama spoke to students at the University of Michigan about steering American colleges and universities towards more “responsible” tuition costs. It’s an admirable goal. According to the College Board, from the 2001-2012 school years, college tuition and costs at public universities increased at 5.6 percent a year more than the cost of inflation. For the 15 percent of consumers responsible for it, college debt...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved