Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Liberty > Anti-Establishment Angst
Liberty > Anti-Establishment Angst
Mar 19, 2026 12:58 PM

With Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders outperforming all expectations in the current election cycle, much has been said and written about the widespread dissatisfaction with the so-called “establishment.”

“We’re tired of typical politicians,” they say. “It’s time for real change and real solutions. It’s time to shake up the system!”

Yet, as Jeffrey Tucker points out, blind opposition to the status quo, no matter how bad it may be,is not the same as supporting liberty.

The state power we oppose is not identical to the establishment we reject. You can overthrow the establishment and still be left with a gigantic machinery of legalized exploitation. All the agencies, laws, regulations, and powers are still in place. And now you have a problem: someone else is in charge of the state itself. You might call it a new establishment. It could be even more wicked than the one you swept away.

Indeed, it usually is. Maybe always.

Or, as Peggy Noonan recently wrote, considering the prospect of pletely dismemberedGOP: “Something important is ending. It is hard to believe what replaces it will be better.”

For Tucker, the establishment is a “network of large and cooperating interest groups that have developed a stable relationship with state power,” including “finance, organized labor, public bureaucrats, government contractors, big businesses with quid pro quo relationships with regulators and politicians, political families with a strong stake in the election process, intellectuals at state-friendly think tanks and universities, and so on.”

If this is our working definition, historical examples aren’t exactlythe friend of anti-disestablishmentarianism. See: Weimar Republic.

Alas, if thistoppling of the current ordersucceeds, we’re still left with the same power structures but in new hands, regardless of thepreexisting illusions. In our case, those hands could belong to Donald J. Trump or Bernie Sanders, each of whom offers a clear picture of howthe levers will be pulled.

In the case of Trump, we see a man who boasts of his “business experience” in manipulating virtually every corner of the railed-againstestablishment. We see a man who promises to be the biggest and smartest and most audacious at executive trampling, even as he somehow befriends both parties. We see the promise of kingly“deal-making” within thenewfound political order. This is Authoritarian Cronyism with as bright a label as voters couldhope for.

In the case of Sanders, we see a range of proposals that rely on theexpansionof existing power structures. Rather than constraining government againsttherealms of abuse thatSanders disdains, his policies pointto “bigger butbetter” systems and structures, expanding the government’s control, and in turn,the cronies and special interests therein. We can pretend that Sanders’ autocratic tendencies will be mitigated by his “genuine heart” and independent spirit, hoping it will trickle down to the grand poobahs eventually appoints. Unfortunately for us, human nature is not a play thing.

As Tucker concludes, the real solution is to keep our focus on liberty and how it might properly be preserved:

A movement toward a lasting liberty has to think long term, and not find itself buffeted by the winds of politics that promise overnight results. The goal should be the tearing down of power itself and its replacement by simple human rights and a society that functions according to civilized standards.

Top-down political putsches are particularly dangerous in our times. The establishment is already on the run because of technological innovation. The ruling class is gradually losing control munication, education, industrial development, civic planning, consumption, and so much else. The old models have been discredited and new ones are replacing them, organically, in a sustainable way.

A new autocrat from the left or right threatens everything. A political movement fueled by bloodlust — mobilized by raw resentment and crying out for vengeance — could empower a new form of oligarchic control, resulting in a calamity that no one intended but no one can control once it has power.

We ought to remain keenly aware and cautious of the systems and networks of power that are currently in place. We ought to stay waryof the so-called “establishment” and how we might not e another special interest in the blur of the bloated bureaucracy.

But let’s not getdistracted about what truly empowers society: bottom-up spiritual, cultural,economic, and political engagement that values freedom overunchecked power, and fights to protect and preserve it.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
Tea Party Catholic: A Round-Up
Tea Party Catholic: The Catholic Case for Limited Government, A Free Economy and Human Flourishing, the new book by Acton’s Director of Research Samuel Gregg, has received a review from Fr. Dwight Longenecker at . Fr. Longenecker dives right in, asking “Is Catholicism Conservative?” and looking to Gregg’s book for some answers. Catholics have too often fallen into the easy trap of conflating their political opinions with their political views. So left-wingers latch on to the Catholic Church’s “preferential option...
When a Church Matches Missions with Entrepreneurship
Pastor Daniel Harrell had a heart for missions, so upon unexpectedly receiving roughly $2 million from a land sale, his Minnesota church was energized to use the funds accordingly. Though they had various debts to pay and building projects to fund, the church mitted to allocating at least 20 percent to service “outside of their walls.” “The sensible way to spend the 20 percent would have been to find a successful service agency and write the check,” Harrell writes, in...
Greece: Back to the Future
From Australia’s SBS Television: Greeks with Australian citizenship are returning here in the hope of finding jobs and a better life, away from the instability crippling Greece’s economy. Which is why so many Greeks left home and family behind for the American Dream in the early 20th Century: Greeks began to settle in America at the end of the 19th century and the influx of migrants continued up until the 1920s. Around 400,000 Greeks migrated to America at that time,...
Why Christians Should Oppose the Debt Ceiling Charade
When es to political policy, Christians in America have a wide-range of opinions about what should be done. Even when we agree on a general principle, we tend to disagree about how that informs our policy choices. We recognize, for instance, that we have an obligation to care for the poor but differ on the type and degree of government involvement. Such differences can lead us to believe that there is nothing we can agree on. But I don’t believe...
‘Okay, We’ll Pay:’ Business Owners Prefer Penalty To Obamacare
, Debbie and Larry Underkoffler, owners of North Georgia Staffing, are considering paying government-imposed penalties rather than offering Obamacare to temporary employees. The couple offers excellent health care to their full-time staff, but with hundreds of temporary employees, the cost of offering health insurance could sink their business. [U]nder ObamaCare, the pany now faces a tough choice — cover all of its temporary workers as well, or pay a hefty fine. Aside from its full-time staff, pany also manages about...
Video: Samuel Gregg Discusses Tea Party Catholic on EWTN
Acton Director of Research Samuel Gregg joined host Raymond Arroyo last Thursday evening on EWTN’s The World Over to discuss his latest book, Tea Party Catholic, and addressed some of mon objections Catholic proponents of limited government often encounter. [product sku=”1415″] ...
Autocam Files Petition with U.S. Supreme Court
The Thomas More Society stated today in a press release that they are working with Catholic Vote Defense League in a fight to seek “constitutional protection of religious freedom.” Specifically, they have filed a cert petition with the Supreme Court for the case, Autocam Vs. Sebelius. They are petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court to review and reverse the Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals’ recent decision, denying the claims of Autocam, an international automotive manufacturer, and its owners, that Obamacare’s...
Monks Triumph Over Cronyist Morticians
The morticians wanted the monks shut down—or even thrown in jail—for the crime the Benedictines mitting. Until 2005, the monks of St. Joseph Abbey in St. Benedict, Louisiana had relied on harvesting timber for e. But when Hurricane Katrina destroyed their pine forest they had to find new sources of revenue to fund the 124-year-old abbey. For over 100 years, the monks had been making simple, handcrafted, monastic caskets so they decided to try to sell them to the public....
Rich People Are Big Meanies Who Just Don’t Care, Right?
In a New York Times op-ed, Daniel Goleman, a psychologist and author, declared, “Rich People Just Care Less.” How does he know this? Because studies have been done. So there. Rich people lack empathy, don’t listen to people lower on the social ladder than themselves, and …seem to pay particularly little attention to those with the least power. To be sure, high-status people do attend to those of equal rank — but not as well as those low of status...
Deneen and Creative Destruction
Among many other bizarre claims in his most recent article at The American Conservative, Patrick Deneen writes, Today’s conservatives are liberals — they favor an economy that wreaks “creative destruction,” especially on the mass of “non-winners,” increasingly controlled by a few powerful actors who secure special benefits for themselves and their heirs…. Pace Inigo Montoya, I actually have no idea what Deneen thinks creative destruction means in this context. Setting aside the question of whether or not it is a...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved