Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Have You No Sense of Decency, Sen. Durbin?
Have You No Sense of Decency, Sen. Durbin?
Jul 2, 2025 8:17 AM

Astute Acton readers more than likely are aware already that U.S. Sen. Dick Durbin (D-Ill.) has fired another salvo in the ongoing battle to silence conservative voices. Durbin joins our progressive friends in the Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility and As You Sow – both involved in proxy shareholder resolutions that would panies to disclose donations to nonprofits – in their attempts to declare lights-out on the American Legislative Exchange Council.

At issue for Durbin is ALEC’s draft legislation called the “Castle Doctrine Act,” based on Florida’s “Stand Your Ground” law. Apparently, Sen. Durbin doesn’t like either, in much the same fashion ICCR and AYS dislike ALEC’s stand on climate-change, genetically modified organisms, Citizens United and “Castle Doctrine.”

In his letter sent last week to right-of-center and free-market think tanks across the country, Durbin demands “yes or no” answers. The numbered questions below are lifted directly from the Aug. 6 letter sent to the Center of the American Experiment in Minneapolis:

Has Center of the American Experiment served as a member of ALEC or provided any funding to ALEC in 2013?Does Center of the American Experiment support the “stand your ground” legislation that was adopted as a national model and promoted by ALEC?

Sen. Dick DurbinIf this resonates with a bit of what progressives like to call McCarthyism or even fascism in its attempt to shut down an entire side of public policy debate in the United States, well … it’s a brand new world, dear readers. Hey, at least Tailgunner Joe claimed he was chasing Commies. Durbin, ICCR and AYS – and a host of other progressives – seem to want the ghettoization of ALEC and pany or organization that doesn’t share the leftist dream of what for many of us is a Hobbesian Leviathan of centralized power.

AYS specifically gets its knickers in a twist over corporate donations to ALEC, saying these donations “can present reputational risks panies,” and name checks ALEC’s “Castle Doctrine” model legislation “based on Florida’s ‘Stand Your Ground’ law that gained national attention after the tragic killing of Trayvon Martin, for instance.” AYS conveniently leaves out that “Stand Your Ground” was never used as a defense or justification for the eventual acquittal of George Zimmerman, and boasts: “In response to investor and grassroots pressure, panies, including Amgen, Bank of America, Coca-Cola, Yum! Brands, evaluated the risk to their corporate pared to any benefits and made the decision to leave ALEC.”

Among the better responses to Durbin’s letter is the following excerpted letter from The Institute for Policy Innovation, based in Lewisville, Texas, written by IPI President Tom Giovanetti:

If freedom of speech and freedom of association mean anything, they mean that we don’t have to answer to you about our speech and about our associations.

The American people have had enough of bullying and intimidation from the Government Class. You have lost track of mitment to the Constitution and you have lost touch with those you claim to serve. Today, the Government Class lords over the private sector as rulers, rather than as “public servants.” You look after your own interests such that the Government Class has higher es, better benefits, and greater job security than those who toil to fund your extravagance and whom you have placed on the hook to bail out the unnecessary programs and unfunded benefits that you have secured for you and yours.

And when groups such as IPI and ALEC point this out and call for a return to constitutional restraints on the size and scope of government, they incur your wrath.

You yourself directed the Internal Revenue Service to investigate specific conservative organizations, which sent a clear signal to the IRS that you wanted them to help silence conservative and Tea Party groups. It is no surprise that you are the source of an attempt to put pressure on ALEC, a 40 year-old organization with an outstanding track record and broad membership from the peoples’ elected state legislators.

At ALEC, legislators exchange ideas about how to make their state pension funds solvent, how to deliver services to their residents in the most efficient and most effective ways possible, and how to create jobs within their states.

I can’t think of any more powerful retort to government overreach in recent memory. In fact, one may have to go all the way back to 1954, when Hale and Dorr attorney Joseph N. Welch lambasted Sen. McCarthy for his attacks on Welch’s subordinate, Fred Fisher:

Until this moment, Senator, I think I have never really gauged your cruelty or your recklessness. Fred Fisher is a young man who went to the Harvard Law School and came into my firm and is starting what looks to be a brilliant career with us. Little did I dream you could be so reckless and so cruel as to do an injury to that lad. It is true he is still with Hale and Dorr. It is true that he will continue to be with Hale and Dorr. It is, I regret to say, equally true that I fear he shall always bear a scar needlessly inflicted by you. If it were in my power to forgive you for your reckless cruelty I would do so. I like to think I am a gentle man but your forgiveness will have e from someone other than me.

Substitute “ALEC” for “Fisher” in the quote above, and you have a response as spot-on as that given by Giovanetti, until one arrives at Welch’s classic coup de grace:

Let us not assassinate this lad further, Senator. You’ve done enough. Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
We should not fear automation
The Cato Institute recently released a fascinating study explaining why fears about job losses via automation may be exaggerated. Many people today fear that our technological innovations, particularly automation, will result in permanent job losses. The fear especially applies to e jobs, which usually act as an entrance into the workforce for young people or others. This data, including new figures from the twentieth century, shows that this may be an historically misplaced fear. According to the study, in the...
China’s BBC ban is a warning for those who could crack down on ‘fake news’
Shortly after the Capitol riot, Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez stated, “We’re going to have to figure out how we rein in our media environment so that you can’t just spew disinformation and misinformation.” This week, China put her words into action. It banished the BBC from Chinese airwaves, allegedly because of the global news service’s coverage of the COVID-19 pandemic and Uighur Muslims’ persecution amounted to “disinformation.” The BBC reported on its own silencing: China’s State Film, TV and Radio Administration...
New series on Orthodox Christian social thought
At Every Thought Captive, a blog of Ancient Faith Ministries, I’ve been writing a series on Orthodox Christianity and modern Christian social thought. In my first essay, I explore the question, “What is modern Christian social thought?” The plight of the working poor in the nineteenth century came to be called the “Social Question,” and by the end of that century Christian pastors and intellectuals refused to remain silent or continue to pine away for a bygone social order that...
Rush Limbaugh, RIP: 6 quotations on socialism, the Founding Fathers, and life
The most popular conservative personality of modern times, Rush Limbaugh, passed away this morning at the age of 70 plications due to lung cancer. While neither an intellectual nor a writer – he did not earn a college degree – his quick wit and pithy turn of municated the message of a free and virtuous society to their largest consistent audience. His widow, Kathryn, announced Limbaugh’s death on his syndicated talk radio show this afternoon. Rush Hudson Limbaugh III was...
How Australia regulated the news out of Facebook
Imagine a world where you log into your social media account and find pictures of babies, discussion of ideas, notifications munity groups with which you are involved, updates from family and friends, and cat memes. Curiously absent is any news. This is the world Australian Facebook users have been living in since yesterday, the product of the unintended consequence of government intervention. Writing for the Financial Times, Richard Waters, Hannah Murphy, and Alex Baker give a good overview of these...
The Acton Institute holds top-ranked conference among free-market think tanks: Forbes
As we noted on this blog last month, an independent report has ranked the Acton Institute among the world’s elite think tanks. An analyst at Forbes magazine has narrowed the focus and found that our annual Acton University rated as the highest-rated conference put on by “organizations that favor the free economy.” The University of Pennsylvania released its “2020 Global Go To Think Tank Index Report” on January 28. “[D]espite certain weaknesses,” this publication – produced by James G. McGann,...
‘Religion & Liberty’ Winter 2021 issue released
The latest edition of the Acton Institute’s flagship journal, Religion & Liberty, has been released. The Winter 2021 issue focuses on the menace of political violence. Politics merce and goodwill unite. That truth has been driven home as politically inspired riots have swept the nation. In our cover story, Ismael Hernandez observes that the underlying ideology driving much of our division “is not drawn from the perspective of black Americans as they collectively reflected on the American experience; this view...
The gift of ‘regular old living’: Pixar’s ‘Soul’ on work and vocation
Surrounded by abounding prosperity, we are constantly told to “follow our passions,” to “look deep inside ourselves,” to “find our calling,” to “do what we love and love what we do.” And why shouldn’t we? Freedom is expanding. Opportunity is everywhere. Having mostly escaped the material deprivation of human history, our attentions have quite happily turned toward the meaning of our work, and for those resistant to peting allure of materialism, it is a e shift, to be sure. Yet...
Entrepreneurship in theological perspective: Creative and innovative
What distinguishes something that is truly creative from something that is simply innovative? And how do we value and prioritize one or the other? In a recent study, “Creativity, Innovation, and the Historicity of Entrepreneurship,” Victor Claar and I attempt to disambiguate what we call “creative entrepreneurship” from “innovative entrepreneurship.” We describe creative entrepreneurship (or creativity more generally) as “what human beings do in connection with the fundamental givenness of things.” There are possibilities inherent in the created order on...
‘Mental torture’? Jimmy Lai denied bail for second time
Early Tuesday morning local time, guards hurried pro-democracy and human rights advocate Jimmy Lai out of his prison transport – handcuffed, arms chained around his waist like a member of a chain gang – and inside the courthouse. Lai’s only apparent consolation came from a copy of Thomas Merton’s Seven Storey Mountain, which his wife and child had given him days earlier. The bestselling spiritual classic instructs: The more you try to avoid suffering, the more you suffer, because smaller...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved