Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
From Tragedy To Victimization: Whatever It Is, It’s All About Me
From Tragedy To Victimization: Whatever It Is, It’s All About Me
Jul 5, 2025 11:06 PM

There are two intriguing articles at The Federalist today. They deal with different topics (mass murder and institutional racism), but they share insights into the same topic: victimization. It seems our culture wants to take whatever is happening and make it all about “me.”

First, Heather Wilhelm writes about the tragic news from California on Friday, where it seems that Elliott Rodger killed 8 (including himself) and injured 13. Rodger was known to have mental health issues, and his family had reportedly asked police to make a welfare check on him about a month before his killing spree. What Wilhelm is concerned with, however, is how this tragic occurrence got hijacked by social media into a victimization rampage, with the hashtag #YesAllWoman. Overlooking that fact that four of those killed were men, people started turning the discussion from Rodger’s illness and actions to what had happened to them: it’s all about me.

As the Wall Street Journal reports, “hours after a shooting rampage in this coastal college town that the alleged gunman said was ‘retribution’ against women who’d rejected him, a woman launched a conversation on Twitter about what it’s like to feel vulnerable to violence.‘As soon as I reached my teens, I didn’t fortable being outside in the evening on my own street,’ the woman wrote in one of her first posts under a Twitter hashtag called #YesAllWomen.”

Some of the #YesAllWomen tweets offer harrowing tales of sexual assault. The vast majority, however, seem, well, less than empirical:“I know that not all men threaten women, but that all women have been threatened by men.” (Really? How do you know?) “Imagine the creative energy we would release if half of humanity didn’t have to devote so much time in fear of the other half.” (Yes! Then they could spend more time writing things on Twitter.) “I’ve spent 19 years teaching my daughter how not to be raped.How long have you spent teaching your son not to rape?”(Quick answer—so far, on three sons, I’ve spent about zero seconds. But they’re all under six, so I figure they don’t turn into rampaging, predatory, inhuman monsters until they’re about 12 or 13.)

As Wilhelm says, sexual assault is a serious matter. However, many of the tweets had to do with a pushy boss, a badly-behaved boyfriend or a wolf-whistle on the street. Women proclaimed they were tired of having to deal with such things, whereas men were free to do whatever they wished, whenever they wanted, and no one had taught them any better. Somehow, we went from the tragic murder and injury of dozens of people to, “Hey, bad stuff has happened to me, too! Feel sorry for me, too!”

Really? Are these women so fraught with fright that they can’t handle a man with roaming hands? In college, I once worked with a guy like that. I asked my mom what to do. She told me, “Tell him point-blank to knock it off. And tell him if he doesn’t, you’re telling your boss and his wife.” I did just that, and the guy never came near me again. I understand women are vulnerable in ways men are not, but don’t give you power away, and for heaven’s sake, don’t make someone else’s tragedy your platform for your issues.

In the next Federalist article, David Masciotra opines, “One of the most vomitous and hideous regressions of American culture is the eager embrace of victimhood as a means of self-identification from Americans of seemingly all ages and races.” Masciotra discusses the issue of victimhood with Shelby Steele, author and fellow at the Hoover Institution. Steele calls the idea of victimhood “seductive.”

One has to go to human nature. There’s a part of human nature when people – particularly young people or minorities – who have very little experience in the mainstream or experience being responsible for their own advancement in the mainstream, are afraid. In other words, they wonder if they won’t be able to make it on their own. When you go through six years of an economic downturn where jobs are scarce, people are insecure. Then, the idea that ‘I’m a victim of someone else’s greed or cruelty or indifference’, is seductive.”

If you’re a victim, you “get things.” You get attention, government services, subsidies, a pay-out. Victimhood is not about personal responsibility and accountability; it’s about being scared. Steele says (regarding race in the United States):

We were vastly freer than we ever were before. What everybody at that time missed – I certainly did – is that freedom is the most terrifying thing in the world, because what freedom says is, ‘It’s all on you now.’ Freedom sits there in judgment of you, and makes you feel extremely inadequate if you don’t have the values and skills necessary to thrive in freedom. So, we were right away seduced by the idea that we can be spared the idea of individual responsibility with the Great Society. When we scream that we are victimized all the time, it spares us the terror of freedom.”

Both articles are worth a careful read, as there are many nuances that require close examination. However, Wilhelm and e to the same conclusion. There is a pervasive “ideology of victimhood” in our culture, and for some people, everything – every perceived slight, wolf-whistle, failure – is personal. It allows a person to take the tragedy of a mentally ill man killing people into a social media event giving women a way to vent about their personal issues, and gives those who’ve never experienced slavery a platform to call for reparations. It’s all about me, and everybody owes me something.

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
A Cultural Case for Capitalism: Part 7 of 12 — What have the capitalists ever done for Wendell Berry!
[Part 1 is here]. In Monty Python’s Life of Brian, the ring leader of a little band of first-century Jewish rebels asks, “What have the Romans ever done for us?” He’s sure the answer is absolutely nothing, but one of the rebels meekly pipes up with “The Aqueduct.” A moment later another rebel squeaks, “And the sanitation.” Then another, “The Roads.” The ringleader grudgingly grants all of this and then tries to wrench the meeting back on track. “But apart...
Regulators Brewing More Rules for Craft Beer Makers
It seems like nowadays everyone has a connection to someone who brews their own beer. Grand Rapids recently was named Beer City because of its lively microbrewery scene so this is especially true here. While this hobby can be very enjoyable and refreshing be aware that taking your hobby to the next step could be more difficult than you would imagine. Recent regulations have made it harder than ever for new craft beers to enter into the consumer market. Entrepreneurs...
A Cultural Case for Capitalism: Part 6 of 12 — The Distributist Alternative
Part 1 is here.] An economically free society doesn’t have to be hyper-utilitarian, materialistic and banal; and yet, here we are, living in a capitalist age marked by these very features. Some social conservatives who see capitalism as one of the main culprits argue that we should turn away from both socialism and greedy capitalism, toward a more humanitarian munity-based approach, toward a small-is-beautiful aesthetic of farmer’s markets, widespread property ownership, social responsibility and local, collective enterprise, a political and...
Soccer, Sex And The Sale of Innocence
Did you watch the U.S. v. Portugal game last night? Did you cheer for the amazing play of American keeper Tim Howard? Did you howl in disbelief at the last minute goal by Portugal? Even if you’re not a soccer fan, it’s hard not to get swept up in the fun and rivalry of the world’s biggest soccer extravaganza. Unless you’re a victim of human trafficking. Every large sporting event in the world has e a red-light district. Where there...
Surrogacy Industry Poses Threats To Women’s Health; Does Anyone Care?
India has a huge and still-growing medical tourism industry. A $2 billion part of this industry is the surrogacy business. India has few laws regulating surrogacy, and it is a popular place for people from the U.S. and the EU to head to for a baby. But the lack of regulations also means very little help, support and care for the women producing these children. The women literally e cogs in a giant machine. If one cog breaks, it’s simply...
Coffee and Cronyism: Guess Who’s Really Paying for Starbucks ‘Free Tuition’
When most people think of Starbucks they think of overpriced coffee, free wifi, and omnipresence. Starbucks are everywhere. pany was founded in 1971 and since 1987 they’ve opened an average of two new stores every day. In the U.S. alone there are 12,973 locations. When most people think of “big business”, though, they don’t often think of the Seattle-based pany. But they should. Starbucks has 151,000 fulltime employees, $15 billion in annual revenues, and three times as many locations as...
‘These Are Our Children:’ FBI Sting Rescues 168 Human Trafficking Victims
A nation-wide sweep last week by the FBI netted the arrest of almost 300 human traffickers and rescued 168 underage trafficking victims. “Operation Cross Country” was carried out in 106 cities across the U.S., the 8th such sting of its kind by the FBI. Since the beginning of this operation, over 3,600 children have been rescued. These are not children living in some faraway place, far from everyday life,” FBI Director James Comey said in a press conference Monday. “These...
Interview: Rev. Sirico on Capitalism and PovertyCure
Acton president and co-founder, Rev. Robert Sirico was recently interviewed for Beliefnet by John W Kennedy, who writes about “the crossroads of faith, media, and culture.” They discussed a variety of issues, including the Church’s views on economics, the media portrayal as business as inherently evil, the ments about economics, PovertyCure and more. See a portion of their discussion below: John W Kennedy: In your view, how can government — and religion — help create an atmosphere in which free...
Private Toilets – an Indian Woman’s Ticket to Safety
Like half a billion women and girls in India, two teenage cousins were forced to walk away from their homes in the Indian village of Katra in Uttar Pradesh to find a private place to defecate. It was during this time that the two girls were mercilessly attacked: raped and hanged from the mango trees that line the fields of their village. Perhaps the lives of these two young girls could have been protected through access to a toilet at...
The School of Love: How the Family Teaches Flourishing
In the first episode of For the Life of the World: Letters to the Exiles, Evan Koons discovers a new approach to Christian cultural engagement. Revolving around “God’s economy of all things,” he proceeds to explore six key areas of human engagement, one in each episode, including the economies of love, creative service, order, wisdom, and wonder, and, finally, through the church herself — an organism and institution that runs before and beyond all else. But it’s no wonder that...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2025 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved