Home
/
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
/
Commentary: Hollywood 2012: What Messages are the Movies Sending Us?
Commentary: Hollywood 2012: What Messages are the Movies Sending Us?
Apr 2, 2026 9:45 AM

“If I had cash to spend on promoting the values and ideas and policies that I believed were best for this country, you can bet that I would be out finding talented directors, writers, and producers who shared those values,” writes R.J. Moeller. The full text of his essay follows. Subscribe to the free, weekly Acton News & Commentary and other publicationshere.

Hollywood 2012: What messages are the movies sending us?

byR.J. Moeller

The list ofthe twenty-five top-grossing films(worldwide) of 2012 has been released, and I believe there are a few important lessons that proponents of free enterprise, limited government, and traditional Judeo-Christian values can learn from its inventory.

First, let’s take a look at what types of stories drew the most attention in 2012. The top three –Avengers,Dark Knight RisesandSkyfall– are all superhero/action flicks. At their core, they are “good vs. evil” morality plays. They are about the pursuit of justice and defense of the defenseless. They are about sacrifice and loyalty and love.

Of course much has already been written and said about Christopher Nolan’sBatmanfranchise and the “controversial” plotlines and themes therein. (By the way, anytime the word “controversial” is used by the mainstream media to describe a popular movie, what they’re really saying is “there’s stuff in this that port with our progressive view of the world.”) InDark Knight Rises, we see yet again that when evil people do terrible things, when good people remain silent and allow society to decay from within, the result is not pretty. Nolan even addresses, to some extent, the dangerous, mob-like mentality that manifests itself when class-warfare is used by those wishing to “bring down the system.”

Mankind’s fallen nature is an ever-present reality in these three films. InAvengers, the spiteful jealousy of a younger brother (Loki) leads him to sell-out his family, his home-world, and planet Earth. The collection of heroes assembled bat this pressing darkness do not like one another, have egos and prejudices of their own, e together because they value human life. They realize that the importance of the talents they’ve been given outweighs the “curse” of the responsibility es along with them. Even the slightly darkerSkyfallis in part a character study of what happens to a hero when he finally begins to falter (and perhaps even fail a time or two). James Bond’s motives are noble, even if his extracurricular activities are not.

Also in the top 10—and after only a few weeks in theaters—is the film adaptation of JRR Tolkien’sThe Hobbit, brought to us by the same team that masterfully crafted theLord of the Ringstrilogy a decade ago. The honorable, traditional, and even Biblical values infused in Tolkien’s epic tales should be well-known to all. Throughout this Top 25 list there are movies that project similar values. It isn’t dark and pessimistic Indie films, or the next Martin Scorsese downer, that sells tickets like these flicks do.

Which brings me to my next point: There is money to be made in producing pelling, PG-13 movies (and, yes, movies rated for even younger audiences). This isn’t a ground-breaking discovery, by any means. But given how much influence we know Hollywood has on our kids—and even on ourselves if we’re being honest—this “You can turn a profit doing good, family-friendly work” point needs to be reiterated.

This is especially so in light of how few of us who champion traditional values are in the movie-making business. Conservatives and libertarians spend a lot of time and money on rallies and events and conferences and Ann Coulter books, but very little on influencing culture. If I had cash to spend on promoting the values and ideas and policies that I believed were best for this country, you can bet that I would be out finding talented directors, writers, and producers who shared those values. I’m not talking about simply churning out pro-free market propaganda, or only financing films that invoke the name of “Edmund Burke” a pre-determined number of times. I’m talking about recognizing where we’re losing the ideological and cultural battles and entering the fray where the fighting is fiercest.

We are supposed to be the entrepreneurs. We are supposed to be the ones who care about “free and virtuous” societies. And we are. I know that we are. But there is a bigger war for the hearts and minds of Americans—especially young people—and we’re being routed because of our nearly total absence from the entertainment industry. Even with the risks involved in making something that people will actually watch and enjoy, to do nothing—or next to nothing—is unacceptable.

My final point piggy-backs off the first two: Even in “tough economic times” people still go see movies. This was a huge year for films at the box office, and a number of quality pictures were released. Hollywood is resistant to many of our values and ideas, but you’d be foolish to miss the writing on the wall with the types of movies that are making money (and with the impressive success of smaller, independent, religious films likeFireproof).

We can and must do better in projecting our voice in the public square. The opportunity is there. Our beliefs and convictions are not only better than those of the Hollywood Left, they are needed now by our country if we’ve any hope of turning things around.

Go West, young conservatives!

Comments
Welcome to mreligion comments! Please keep conversations courteous and on-topic. To fosterproductive and respectful conversations, you may see comments from our Community Managers.
Sign up to post
Sort by
Show More Comments
RELIGION & LIBERTY ONLINE
How Americans lost their schools and how to take them back
Our schools are a mess, and parents are ing increasingly fed up, willing to challenge teachers and school boards. The question remains, challenge them to do what? A new book offers some answers. Read More… In mencement speech at Kenton College, American writer David Foster Wallace started with an anecdote, “There are these two young fish swimming along and they happen to meet an older fish swimming the other way, who nods at them and says, ‘Morning, boys. How’s the...
The two lives of Steve McQueen
The iconic star of such thrilling films as Bullitt and The Great Escape finally grew tired of the Hollywood life. His second life will undoubtedly prove more stunning that the first. Read More… Someone once said of Steve McQueen (1930–80) that his range as an actor was deep but not very broad. All right, I admit it—I said it in my 2001 biography of the all-American star who still looms over Hollywood like a sort of male equivalent of the...
Father Stu shows us strength in weakness
The film, starring Mark Wahlberg and Mel Gibson, is based on the true story of a boxer turned priest and explores how humility is the price you must sometimes pay for success. Read More… This past spring, movie theatres saw the premier of Father Stu, a Sony Pictures film starring Mark Wahlberg as Father Stu and co-starring Mel Gibson as his father. The film is based on the true story of Stuart Long, an amateur boxer from Montana who found...
Natural law limits government and arbitrary power
Human flourishing demands that laws be reasonable and in the interest of mon good, and that, as Aquinas noted, the state not “impede people from acting according to their responsibilities.” Subsidiarity, too, is natural law. Read More… Any discussion of the nature and ends of liberty and justice inevitably touches upon the role of government and law in society. A good place to begin reflecting upon natural law’s approach to these questions is Aquinas’ understanding of law. In his Summa...
When a Joke is the difference between freedom and tyranny
What can a 50-year-old movie about munist regime in Czechoslovakia tell us about cancel culture and microaggressions today? Nothing, if we’re not willing to struggle. Read More… This year, at the Karlovy Vary Film Festival, the major film attraction in Eastern Europe, there was a memento of the Prague Spring: a newly restored version of the 1969 movie The Joke, directed by Jaromil Jireš and adapted by him and Milan Kundera from the latter’s eponymous debut novel. The Joke was...
Finding wisdom in Barack Obama fanfiction
We need to stop daydreaming about Egypt and face the wilderness. Read More… This diatribe was inspired by the most amusing book I’ve ever encountered. While perusing the wares of a D.C. bookstore, I came across a tome entitled Hope Never Dies by New York Times bestselling author Andrew Shaffer, released in 2018. It isn’t an inspirational feel-good-about-your-life how-to or workout guide that makes weird forays into the philosophical. It is, and you are reading this correctly, a work of...
The Sandman is a lesson in natural law
Author Neil Gaiman’s mythos represents living expressions of human limits that cannot be violated, and tasks that must be fulfilled lest flourishing vanish. In the end, despite its more radical sexual elements, The Sandman is about the structural integrity of reality. Read More… On August 5, The Sandman dropped on Netflix. For Neil Gaiman’s existing fanbase, this show was the fulfillment of decades of longing to see a beloved story brought to life. Rumors have circulated over the years that...
The union movement was anti-black from the beginning
By pitting one group of workers against another, unionization was able to gain ground while also setting the groundwork for the deleterious effects of the welfare state on the black family. The takeaway: Prosperity does not have to be a zero-sum game. Read More… The process of industrialization upended traditional ways of life that undoubtedly caused fear and doubt. It’s no surprise that some workers destroyed machinery in fear of lost work (the Luddites) or that workers banded together to...
Customers put product value ahead of political values
Woke capitalism prioritizes politics. But paying customers always put service and price first. Read More… For years American business has allowed itself to be swayed by the push and pull of political culture. Investment decisions, corporate donations, and hiring practices have been made in response to a culture that demands acquiescence or cancellation. But as Netflix, Disney, and State Farm deal with political and cultural backlash from both sides on a host of issues, and politicians scapegoat businesses large and...
Is ‘diversity’ the new religion of American universities?
When hiring faculty, most American universities require an almost religious assent to its diversity and inclusion goals. It e as no surprise that this is resulting in more ideological conformity and less viewpoint diversity. Read More… As American universities worked tirelessly over the past couple of centuries to purge religion from institutional education, their success left a conceptual void. Without religion, the western university was in need of some of sort of metanarrative or ontological justification for its existence. It...
Related Classification
Copyright 2023-2026 - www.mreligion.com All Rights Reserved